Sadly NCL is Going Down the Tubes

Norwegian Gem Cruise Review to Transatlantic

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 35

Overall rating:

3.6 out of 5
Verified Review
Norwegian Gem

15 Night Transatlantic Eastbound (New York To Rome)

Sail date: April 15, 2023

Ship: Norwegian Gem

Cabin type: Suite

Cabin number: 11524

Traveled as: Singles/Friends

Reviewed: 1 year ago

Review summary

The concierge we spoke to prior to the cruise (at 855-625-4283) did not follow through on my requests. I had to ask the butler and cabin attendant to handle things after we embarked though I specifically asked to have this handled prior to embarkation! NCL never sent us priority luggage tags though we were in a suite, the entire ship had to search for our luggage and we received it 5 hours after we embarked. That is unacceptable in a suite, forget the stress we had believing it was left behind! NCL has extremely poor communication! Very poor! No info regarding which dock we were arriving at, no one could tell us so we almost missed a shore excursion as the tour operator went to Tobaco Dock in Lisbon but we were at the other dock. With a knee that was bone on bone, I had to go back into the ship to get help; they sent me back out to the NCL shore excursion guy to help us though it was not an NCL excursion. That guy (who looks like Gary Busey) was mean and useless and clearly he had no interest in helping. I had to go back on board a second time (long walk on a bad knee) and our concierge called the tour operator to figure out what to do. Why do you not have travelogues of each port we docked at to give clients an idea of what they might want to know? The info on the TV was pretty useless! And why do you not provide maps of each port because some ports had maps, one charged a euro for a map and several had none. Um really? Too much money for NCL to provide them to their clients? NCL did not communicate that there was a "Behind The Scenes" tour; we asked once we got on board but it was full! How is that possible? Why does NCL not have down loadable maps of each deck available to clients after they book (even have them on board if you don't want us to print ahead of time). The NCL web site has diagrams but unprintable unless you want to print many pages, cut them up, tape together, decrease the size to use them. The diagrams by the elevators are useless except to give you a generic idea of what is what. No instructions as to how the wi fi worked and it took 3 employees to help us figure it out. Why are there not written instructions. Though I did a screen shot each time I logged on and off wi fi (many times after 1 or 2 minutes as it never loaded) I had proof yet the log showed I used 50 minutes while off the ship on a shore excursion...impossible...and 70 minutes while we were at dinner. Yet...each time I logged off and had proof that I did not forget to log off. Yes, they gave me back those two sets of minutes but the rest was just a nightmare trying to accomplish anything on wi fi! What a joke! The afternoon savory and sweet canapes/snacks were simply the most boring and repetitive offerings ever. At least 4 times we got a plate with chocolate candies...not great chocolates and not good! You all couldn't even do chocolate covered strawberries at least once??? You couldn’t vary the savory canapes instead of the same ones day in and day out? The shops are also really boring...same old, same old! Liquor, souvenirs and jewelry. If you had a boutique or two, women would buy clothes and accessories I assure you! Impossible to believe we found not one thing to buy that was cool, different or interesting! The room service form is ridiculous...it doesn't list all the breakfast items including toast, english muffins etc. We had to write all over the back of that menu which was just ridiculous and made it hard to read for the butler to decipher??? Why??? Revise it unless it is too much trouble??? The art auction was a joke! We compared it to the one on the Panama Canal cruise last March (2022) which was organized with efficient staff. This one was chaotic, disorganized and on one they registered people but wouldn't let them in to peruse the artwork so that just delayed the whole shebang! The lighting in the living room was atrocious; you simply could not read or write in such dim lighting that pointed everywhere except where you would sit. We had to rearrange our suite, moved the couch under the lights and our cabin attendant brought us a floor lamp. This made it palatable but why would it require that? As far as room service which we had often...the blueberry muffins were very dry, the french fries were rarely hot and often undercooked, coffee often not hot in the pot, cole slaw was served in a tiny "bowl" and I use that term loosely...the bowl was about the size of a fifty cent piece? Finally, the Mallorca port was hell on earth! The walk from the ship to the outside of the port was horrific; you all provided shuttle buses to take people to the Cathedral but they refused to allow those of us who were handicapped to get a ride. The NCL staff could not have cared less; they were all yelling and basically said...too bad...start walking. We did not care if you wanted to charge us for a shuttle but to do nothing....nah...that is a violation of ADA!!! You should be ashamed! So...I'm as tired of writing this as you are of reading it! I plan to send a cleaner version the the NCL CEO's and President so no worries. I think they should know we wouldn't cruise with NCL ever again if you offered me a free around the world cruise, that is how serious I am. Going back to Celebrity! P.S. Why would NCL take credit in their ratings for whether or not a port was great? You should be asking how your shore excursions were in each port because those were a zero!

Embarkation

5 out of 5
It was fine because we were in a suite with a butler and concierge!

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

4 out of 5
We ONLY ate in specialty restaurants! However, we did room service and it was difficult to get the food hot. Other issue which I address below.

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5
No interest!

Entertainment

1 out of 5

Children's Programs

Because I did not bring children hello???

Service and Staff

5 out of 5
The cabin attendant Nyman/Newman was excellent! So friendly and helpful! Our concierge Nashira was the absolute best!!!!! Professional, friendly, efficient, just the best ever! Our butler Gilbert was new but worked hard to give us a great experience. The waiters in the specialty restaurants were wonderful...Le Bistro kudos to Farook and Stany as well as Julius the chef! The best entree on the ship.... dover sole!!! At Cagneys Roy was super as our server. La Cucina kudos to Paul! DD (DeeDee) in Effy was a pleasure...friendly and professional! We did not eat any meals in any dining rooms or cafes.

Ship Quality

4 out of 5
No problems

Cabin / Stateroom

4 out of 5
All was excellent except the lighting...see comments below!

Ship tip

Do NOT count on any wi fi even if you pay for it. Seems if airplanes can do wi fi 37,000 feet above sea level, NCL should be able to get decent wi fi. It was not just this cruise but the last two I took with NCL!!!!

Ports of call

New York, New York Did not visit port

No interest!

Ponta Delgada, Azores

3 out of 5
Private excursion; worked fine; not the most interesting port.

Lisbon, Portugal

4 out of 5
Private excursion; great tour!

Cadiz (Seville), Spain

1 out of 5
This was the only NCL shore excursion we booked because NCL excursions were sub standard! We had another one booked for Mallaga but NCL cancelled as they were not making any money off it. This one was horrible; misrepresented in every way and just made us want to crawl away in disgust!

Malaga, Spain

4 out of 5
We did it on our own because you all (NCL) cancelled for no reason but we figured out NCL had charged too little money so were going to lose money...better to cancel than to lose money. We spoke to other passengers who had Malaga cancelled at the VERY last minute and the reason given was lack of interest...ha ha! Another falsehood! There was plenty of interest!

Palma De Mallorca, Balearic Islands

4 out of 5
We did a private excursion and it was great!

Barcelona, Spain

4 out of 5
We did a private excursion and covered every place we wanted to see. It was great as it was not an NCL excursion!

Cannes, France

4 out of 5
We had a private driver and car; it was great! No credit to NCL!

Livorno (Florence & Pisa), Italy

4 out of 5
Did a private excursion; it was great!

Civitavecchia (Rome), Italy

4 out of 5
We did all of our plans in Rome with private excursion companies and never NCL!!! All went just perfectly!

Disembarkation

5 out of 5
We were in a suite so of course it went just fine!
Was this review helpful? 35

8 Comments

Cruisers4Lyfe     5 months ago

Thanks for sharing

AuntPinkie    1 year ago

hollysmomtravel    1 year ago

Jerrec    1 year ago

I’m guessing you aren’t very tech savvy. The NCL app has maps of the ship in it. You don’t need to pay for WiFi to use it. There are also things like Google and Apple Maps that work way better than a paper map. You can even download Google maps to work offline if you don’t have network access where you are.

cruising2004    1 year ago

Thank you for sharing your cruising experience.

Gwbigdog    1 year ago

Thanks for sharing

NCLARRY    1 year ago

Sounds like your cruise was everything you hoped it would be. All your research and planning really paid off.

Kalaka    1 year ago

Holy cow.

Other reviews of this sailing