QUESTION OF THE WEEK: Smoking on a Cruise

I was a smoker - then a vaper - now I'm back to smoking and vaping , The non-smokers definitely have the advantage as to non-smoking areas on the ships in general. I know that many would prefer that the entire ship be smoke free and not unlike many hotel chains that have adopted that policy, it is probably forthcoming....

That said, I agree that the non-smokers who complain about the smoke in the designated smoking areas are in the wrong ... it's clearly designated smoking area, so stay out if it bothers you. There are very distinct designated smoking areas in the casino (a little symbol on the machine will indicated if it's a smoking machine) and most casinos have "smoke-free" nights.

The ventilation on ships in cigar lounges and smoking bars could be improved but I have yet to see any system that works effectively. The Royal and Regal Princess seem to have the best outdoor areas for smokers.

People who go to a clothing optional beach don't tell others to put their clothes on so I see no reason why people who come to smoking areas should criticize those smoking.

As a smoker, I appreciate the areas that Carnival has set up for smokers. They have nice seating in outdoor areas. I never smoke indoors at home, so oddly enough, the casino smoke bothers me--I can thus empathize with non-smokers about that situation. When we had a balcony cabin before the new rules against balcony smokers took effect, I thought it stunk to the high heavens, so I totally agree with that rule.

The one thing I encounter nearly every cruise are non-smokers who choose to sunbathe or relax in the smoking area and then loudly complain about the smoke. I honestly try to be courteous and respectful of non-smokers, but I expect the same in return.

I read lots of complaints in ship reviews about offensive smoking - usually relating to passing through the casino. It isn't a problem for me - I do smoke cigars - and the cigar lounges are usually kept clean enough for an enjoyable experience. I will say that when the HVAC or ventilation goes out - smoking lounges can become sties. I do think that the "pariah" image of smokers is often exaggerated.