Carnival Magic Reviews

Wish the staff adhered to rules, Serenity constantly had chairs with towels that had been there for hours. Woman filled water bottle with the water spout, unsanitary.

Had a great time. Only issues we really had were due to rocking motion of the boat, which had nothing to do with cruise line. Would go again.

Cruise and ports were very nice and beautiful. You can be as busy or lazy as you want, the choice was yours. Food was good; nice entertainment especially for families.

Over all a pretty good cruise. If the speciality eateries had better open times, and there was a more efficient way to serve so many people. The lines were obnoxious at best.

We had a wonderful time onboard and ashore. Everyone worked so hard to make sure our vacation was exceptional.

This was a great cruise. The ship is in good shape, food was decent (not great), the entertainment was good, the ports were interesting and beautiful and we had lots of time to relax. I think we might need to do this one again!

We had a great time! There were 14 of us and Lauren was in a group that got second place in the lip-synch competition! Very fun overall experience!

we had 2 grandkids with us, so we had 2 connected balcony rooms - it is much better than taking a suite & price is almost the same

These large Carnival ships are not for us. Better for families with lots of kids. Better for casino and bar people. Not for music or cultural lovers. We also like smaller ships rather than the large mega ships no matter who owns them. We do not like ships with 4,000 or more people on board. I do not agree with your overall rating of 3 out of 4. We really feel it is a 1 out of 4.

Loved the cruise. Love Carnival. Amazing trip. I'll go again and again and again and again. You get a hotel room, non stop excellent food, shlept to three places, a boat ride, incredible service, and top notch entertainment for around a $100 a day. Where else can you get that? No where!!!!!

Very disappointing. The Spirit Airline of cruises

Weather was rough so the ship was rocky. I had noisy neighbors frequently from 2-3AM and I should have complained. I will make sure not to take future cruises in Jan. Photos are too expensive. On the positive side, the staff was WONDERFUL!! Big praises to the Cruise Director MARC Q! Food was fresh and well prepared. Ship very clean!

We had a blast and hope to do it again next hear!!!!!!

Excellent vacation! Loved the Caribbean in January. Had only travelled during summer months in the past.

I really have no complaints. We had a lot of fun. At times it was hard to find a chair at the pool

Overall I would recommend the cruise. Decent cruise experience.

Some things were great and others like to dining room food was not. A/C not fixed and was cold the whole trip. Ship needs to have upgrades as is old and rusty. They stopped give out year dated pins for gold members for just carnival pins.

I really had a great time!! It was our first cruise but definitely not our last!!!

We went to a bunch of new ports which were amazing. Cozumel is still awesome every time.

this was an amazing New Years vacation ! If I had a chance to go back and make these reservations again, nothing would change.