Carnival Magic Reviews

1531 reviews




3 out of 5

Okay by frobe11

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
Service was excellent, cabin was good...everything else (food, entertainment, choice of shows, etc.) was basically mediocre. 3 of 4 ports were good and local guides for excursions were great.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 1
3 out of 5

Glad I had friends along by jarylu

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Singles/Friends
It was just ok. Will I go again? Probably. But I want what's advertised. I didn't even get my onboard credit! Some deal! The ship and their activities were nice. Next time I want a boat with golf available.

Read more

Was this review helpful?
3 out of 5

Okay by frobe11

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
Service was excellent, cabin was good...everything else (food, entertainment, choice of shows, etc.) was basically mediocre. 3 of 4 ports were good and local guides for excursions were great.

Read more

Was this review helpful?
4 out of 5

Fall Cruise by asummers8585

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
Very nice cruise. It went very smoothly. Our cabin was great. The ports were average. The it itenery was adjusted due to prior hurricanes. We felt the food and service were very good. The evening shows from the house entertainment staff were very good.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 5
4 out of 5

Nice getaway by Dmh00

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
Wasn't able To do original itinerary due to hurricane, was ok, Bahamas eh, half moon cay I would do again. Grand Turk would like to see after they recover from hurricane mess

Read more

Was this review helpful? 1
5 out of 5

Wonderful Caribbean Cruise by janetwyatt7

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Family (older children)
Deluxe OV Cabin was great. The smell outside the cabin was terrible. Smelled of mildew and mold. Definitely a water leak close to cabin (1419). Fans used outside in hall almost daily.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 1
4 out of 5

Enjoyed the beauty by Cruiser45859429

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
I went with my sister and made memories . We were the best hands at sea cruise met a lot of nice people in our group enjoyed being part of them my sister is a Pezz head collector and I am her enabler. I enjoyed the guy Ferrary‘s burgers and of course you’re pizzeria I took full of vantage of those areas your desserts were OK the one that was my favorite was the chocolate melting cake

Read more

Was this review helpful? 8
5 out of 5

Cruise Time by treyster0706

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
A lot of fun, great atmosphere, great crew, we really had a relaxing enjoyable time. Our room Stewart and dining room group was funny, great team worked good together. The food was amazing.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 4
5 out of 5

Excellent Vacation by Lucy23462

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
Excellent vacation - great weather would love to see another port than Costa Maya - maybe visit Costa Rica. If you get a chance, try the Premium Vista Balcony, Very quiet and the balcony is wonderful

Read more

Was this review helpful? 7
3 out of 5

Disappointing by DebKY

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Family (older children)
Probably my first and last. Felt should have been offered a refund when original itinerary was changed, I also think it should have been discounted or on board credits given. I know another family that was upgraded to this cruise from a 5 day cruise. Paying less for their trip than I paid and also received free parking at the terminal, another $128:charge. Took a cruise because didn't want to go to Mexico and ended up having itinerary changed to having 2 ports there. My daughter had her debit number stolen at Cozamel and cleaned out her bank account. What's not to like!!

Read more

Was this review helpful? 2
4 out of 5

Western Caribbean by dendarah

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Family (older children)
This was definitely the least enjoyable cruise I have been on. I think it would probably have been okay if not for the terrible service we received in the dining room and at the quick service dining areas. I am not sure if the dining rooms were understaffed or if the waiters just didn't care or if we were provided poor service because we had our children with us (compared to our service staff's other tables, who were all adults). Whatever the reason, it really put a damper on our vacation. We may try another cruise line next time after this experience.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 3
5 out of 5

Amazing experience! by rosiemera

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Singles/Friends
I definitely recommend this cruise because of all the good activities on board and the ports were just wonderful, you get to know different cultures and try different things.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 6
5 out of 5

Fantastic cruise by tbaileyfsu

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
What an amazing experience. Especially for this being our first cruise. I can't wait to book another cruise and take my kids next time. Setting up a sail and sign account is a must. Makes cruising so much easier.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 6
3 out of 5

Fun with the grandkids by allbrewsters

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Family (young children)
This cruises was to be a gateway cruise with the grand kids, our daughters and their husbands, so getting everyone's schedules aligned was difficult and this cruise aligned with our needs. Overall it was a good cruise, especially for the grand kids however had it been just my wife and I we would probably gone with a different cruise line.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 1
4 out of 5

Intersting Cruise by KimberlyFabbrin

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Family (young children)
It was an ok trip. Was disappointed in a few things of the trip. The staff overall was friendly but didn't seem like they all knew anything you would ask them where something was or how to do something you either got 3 different answers or I Don't Know sorry. The Debarkation was horrible took forever to get through the lines and back out. Wouldn't go thru Port Canaveral anymore and would not definitely go back on this ship again.

Read more

Was this review helpful?
5 out of 5

Awesome Sauce We Loved It by Lyriq

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Family (young children)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)!!?!!?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Read more

Was this review helpful? 3
3 out of 5

Carnival screws up a good cruise. by brtreasg

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
I was switched to a less expensive cruise (Eastern Carribean to Western- $350 difference for the same stateroom ) 3 days before departure. After driving 4 1/2 hours we left Canaveral (Western cruises leave from Tampa, near my home) and then hit Cozumel, Belize, and Costa Maya, Mexico. We enjoyed the trip, but it was not because anyone went out of their way to make it better. We chose the ports of call for a reason. We absolutely did NOT want to go to Mexico. If I had cancelled or rescheduled, I would lose the money I spent. We would have been happy to postpone our trip to wait for the affected ports to recover.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 2
5 out of 5

Great by andrewpreddy

Verified Review
/
Sail Date: / Traveled As: Couple
Went to Mexico and Belize b/c of hurricane damaged. Cozumel and costa maya were great. Truthfully you could stay in port and have a good time at these places. Belize is a dump. Stay on the boat.

Read more

Was this review helpful? 3

*Cruiseline.com is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. Cruiseline.com does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. Cruiseline.com is not responsible for content on external web sites.