Do you take food off the ship?

I can’t recall and can’t find where we have had a discussion over taking chow off of the ship on this forum. But it is an issue that stirs quite a bit of interest, both for and against. On another forum this subject got rather intense. Below are a few samples. What are your thoughts?

“I have seen too many passengers sick after eating local foods. In general I do not trust them in many countries.”

“At the risk of being disagreeable... a common complaint lodged by those around me, we have often taken a picnic meal with us, especially for "on your own" tours. Prime rib left over from the night before, or whatever, some good Princess rolls or baguettes, etc. Often whatever condiments we want as well. Don't recall seeing dogs anywhere, except here in the States. I wouldn't try to bring those things into the US, but a day in Paris or Amsterdam on your own, only begs for it. The worse that I think would happen is that they take your kids' burger or steak sandwich away. Easily worth the risk in our book.”

“We understand parents that let the kids make the rules. So that being the case the situation is clear. If you take food off the ship (hidden in a backpack or somewhere) you will be fine unless there is a dog working. In that case, the dog will alert and you will be caught. In most cases they will simply take the food and let you go. On the other hand, if somebody is having a bad day perhaps they will decide to make a big issue out of your violation....which will certainly ruin your day (and also your kids).”

“On the other hand you can simply follow the rules of the host country (which is polite and classy thing to do) and not take food off the ship. If your kids get hungry you can either tell them "sorry my precious ones, but you will have to wait until we get back to the ship" or perhaps, you might spend a few dollars (OH MY GOD) and buy them something locally!

P.S. Sorry in advance but a lifetime of extensive travel has given me a dislike of the UGLY AMERICAN syndrome.”

“I have read many of these threads with dozens of posts warning of dire consequences for taking food off the ship -- but I don't recall any posts ever containing details showing the poster has personally gotten in trouble or has actually seen people getting in trouble for this. DW often makes a ham sandwich from the breakfast buffet and carries it off in a baggy -- and we have never been stopped. Note Again: this is not an official post, and I am not advocating that anyone break the law -- but I am asking for anyone to confirm that they personally have seen people getting in trouble for bringing a sandwich off the ship?”

“We have seen many passengers sick with Norovirus on ships! We live in Mexico for about 2 months a year and our main fear is that we will pick up a bug on the flight down. Once in Puerto Vallarta we have no fear of the food or drink...and having dined out over 500 times (in the past 10 years) we have only gotten sick one time...and that was when we ate "imported fish" at a high end restaurant. Go figure.”

“Can you get sick in a port? Absolutely. Can you get sick on a ship? Absolutely! Can you get sick at home? Absolutely! Can you get sick on a plane! Grrrrr. Now that is the big problem. In fact it is thought (by the CDC) that many of the Noro problems on ships are brought aboard by passengers who picked up the bug on planes.”

33 Answers

No, never have done it. I don't plan on doing it. Don't want to get kicked off a cruise.

We bring divided trays with us from home, and fill them with food from the ship. Then we walk down a side street handing out the trays to the neediest people we come across on whatever island we happen to be on.

Just got back from New Zealand and Australia. They take bringing food of any type ashore seriously down under. Particularly in New Zealand. They had an officer on board going through everybody's hand carries prior to getting on the gangway to go ashore. On the shore side they had a sniffer dog. Only items you are allowed to take off the ship is bottled water. The only thing they didn't do was make you turn your pant's pockets inside out, but then the dog was waiting.

Those food rules also apply to just driving across the border between Canada and US. Many ignore it and do take food across but maybe about 10 - 20 % of the time you will be asked.

But keep this in mind .... you are on vacation having fun ... you have paid for the cruise and an excursion ... is it worth it being detained and possible arrested or turned away because you took an apple from the ship? It may not always happen but on the off chance it can ... is it worth it? You could sort of compare it to ... do I buy trip insurance or not?

Not a new rule - just an old rule that is not well enforced.

This is about a year old but people do search for this information so I thought I'd share my personal experience with the food sniffing dogs in Cozumel. We are penny pinchers and don't like to buy meals in ports. On all port days we go up to the buffet and I make peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, pick up pastries, cereal boxes and boiled eggs. No fruit or meat because I'm well aware those are not permitted to bring into Mexico. We've gone to Cozumel on a cruise in 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016. We have done this every time. The last time, they had the dogs and you had to hold out your open bags for them to sniff. My sandwiches were clearly visible on top of the open bag. The officer asked me what it was. I told him PBJ. He waved me on and let me keep my picnic lunch. I have never heard of food being restricted to prepackaged foods only. So unless that is new to 2017, I don't think it is correct. I'm about to go on another cruise and plan to do the same thing. If anyone 100% for sure knows that this is a new rule, please comment to let me know.

I never take food off the ship but I think that prepackaged snacks would be OK.

Sounds like you guys have found yourselves a troll.

Well, it seems that the OP question has pretty much run its course, not only on this thread but on the other forum as well. We have 25 posts on this one, that one had 116, many repetitive.

As I mentioned before, I really hadn’t given this subject much thought since we never bother to take food ashore and if hungry eat locally. However, due to my passion for trying to make more of Alaska’s smaller ports and inland attractions more available for visitation I am aware of practices by visitors that turn locals off. Bringing food ashore is one of them. Compared to smoking or formal dress this issue is rather mild, but I hope it didn’t ruffle many feathers or give someone heartburn (pun intended) however, it did give me a better insight into visitor thinking on the matter, allowing me to address this with my Alaskan peers more knowingly. The medical issue, diabetes, was an eye opener. Thanks for helping out.

Actually I was rather heartened by 95% of the respondents on both threads, in that by far the majority have distain for those who ignore local regulations. For what it’s worth here is a rough tally of opinion on the two threads.

Our thread:

Okay if local rules allow. (5) Not okay under any circumstances. (7) Question the rules, occasionally break them or always do. (3)

Other thread: 1. (19) 2. (18) 3. (13)

The other thread has pretty much petered out too, with the exception of that fellow who is currently in the Caribbean and posting every day over the latest port agriculture inspections. He never witnesses any signs, dogs or inspectors, contrary to what many other posters see. At his last port, Barbados, he says he even made extra sandwiches from the buffet and passed them out to the local kids. LOL, anyway he is pretty much being ignored now, one other poster summed it up thusly:

“At this point I believe you are just saying these things to get a rise out of people. No one, and I mean no one could be this much of a (insert word here) to flaunt being dishonest on a website. You had us going for a while but ultimately, now I no longer believe a word you say and value your comments at zero. I'm sure the others do too.”

I learned my lesson years ago. In Hawaii they not only have rules applicable to what you can't bring in but what you can’t take out. One is sugar cane.

We were on our way back to Alaska with our two kid’s years ago and they had some sugar cane they gathered from a nearby field that they wanted to bring home. So I put it in a suitcase. As we were passing through the agriculture line the nice inspector was rapidly firing off questions as to, do you have this or that. “Do you have any sugar cane”? I shook my head no. He said, “Hey kids, do you have sugar cane?” Our son nodded yes.

He was about eight then, today he is 48, and has his own kids, they go to Hawaii once a year. I love to tell the grandkids that story.

*Cruiseline.com is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. Cruiseline.com does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. Cruiseline.com is not responsible for content on external web sites.