NCL has seen the last of me!

Norwegian Gem Cruise Review to Caribbean - Eastern

Cruises: 4-6 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 59

Overall rating:

1 out of 5
Norwegian Gem

10 Night Eastern Caribbean (New York Roundtrip)

Sail date: February 01, 2016

Ship: Norwegian Gem

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 8 years ago

Review summary

I waited a short while before writing this, to let my emotions simmer down.  I already posted on Cruise Critic. 

We paid a few extra $$ to get VIP status.  Our cabin # was 9500.

When we arrived at the port (NY) our VIP status immediately went out the port hole as one of NCL's shore personnel shoved us into a VERY long latitude members line. 

Once aboard it did not take long to remember why I very much prefer Holland America.  Several mornings we went to one of the restaurants (Cagney's)  for breakfast.  Service was slowww!  Had to ask for tomato juice twice.  Had to go looking for our wait person a couple times.  Had to ask for butter.  Even when the toast came we had to ask for butter again!  Duhhh!  Another occasion for breakfast at the main buffet/dining area I asked the wait person to bring me tomato juice.  He brings me ketchup packets!

After (about) the 3rd day they closed La Cucina, another specialty restaurant, for some unknown publicly unannounced reason.  It never re-opened.  On dis-embarkation morning a part of the buffet/dining area was closed to accommodate La Cucina patrons. This resulted in many passengers having to eat standing up, taking their food back to their stateroom or eating in one of the public areas.

I lost count of the number of people I overheard with their various complaints.  I asked a few of them if they had ever been on Holland America.  The answer was invariably "no".  I advised them to book at least one cruise with them and they should expect to see a big difference in quality of food, quality of presentation, quality of service and quality of entertainment.

Finally, when it came to getting off the ship, we waited ENDLESSLY.  Then they opened up the gangways for a free-for-all. VIP status still in the bilge.  Logistics was an absolute mess.  It is a shame when the "invisible" people--people you don't see--but still rely on for service, mess it up for the people you do see every day.

Title says it all: NCL has seen the last of me!

Rene G

 

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

1 out of 5

Entertainment

3 out of 5

Service and Staff

3 out of 5

Ports of call

San Juan, Puerto Rico

5 out of 5

Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas

5 out of 5

Philipsburg, St. Maarten

5 out of 5

Tortola, British Virgin Islands

1 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 59

13 Comments

jchrist    8 years ago

I loved the gem.. was my first cruise. Staff was friendly and amazing, food was great, entertainment was wonderful. It's all what you make of it. I booked the breakaway for November and super excited

DonnaDi    8 years ago

I agree crstine3, I'm on a beautiful ship going to beautiful ports with loved ones. Life is good 😊

crstine3    8 years ago

It's what you make of it. You can't let things bother you..I mean you're on vacation 😁

samrocks01    8 years ago

I stayed in the Haven was butiful the only issue I had was a bag didn't come to my room until the next morning but I wasn't mad. I really like the food and the shows.

crstine3    8 years ago

I really liked the Gem. The people were very nice and the entertainment was great. I had a few issues that were corrected immediately no questions asked. I have sailed NCL and Carnival and I would take NCL any day.

samrocks01    8 years ago

Nice I can't wait to go I heard it is a awsome ship what did you think of the gem

crstine3    8 years ago

The Breakaway in October for 7 days and the Breakaway again in January for 13 days. Can't wait!

samrocks01    8 years ago

Cool what ship will you be going on i am planing to go on the breakaway this winter

crstine3    8 years ago

I agree samrocks01..never had an issue on NCL that wasn't minor and attended to in a swift manner. I just booked my 5th and 6th cruise with them and I am so excited!!

samrocks01    8 years ago

You guys don't know how good of a cruise NCL is its definetly beter than Holland America and any other cruise lines

janetlb    8 years ago

I am glad this was my second ncl cruise if it was my first it would have been my last cruise. The food was always cold all the machines for juice,coffee ice cream were always out of service. Departure was terrible getting on they treated you great we had a person in a wheelchair getting off they just took you off the boat and left you at the bottom of the ramp I had to juggle two suitcases and friend helped with the wheelchair it was a total mess. The entertainment was also not half as good as out first cruise. My next cruise will be on a different ship.

tpkuhnen    8 years ago

We love holland america, taking our 4th cruise with them April 26th. Service impeccable! Love every aspect of cruise.

samrocks01    8 years ago

Duhhh when you go to a specialty resturant you are supposed to wait and talk to people if You wanted quick service you should have just gone to the buffet. BTW What ship were you on?

Other reviews of this sailing