Carnival Magic Cruise Review to Caribbean - Eastern

Contributor Level: Purser

1 cruise (first)


Helpful Votes

2 out of 5

Very Disappointing Customer Service Experience EXCEPT for Dining Room and Housekeeping

Sail Date: April 26, 2015

Reviewed: 2 years ago

Traveled As: Large Group

Room Type: Balcony

Good News - 5 Stars for the following: The dining in the Northern Lights Dining Room, and for the Housekeeping Services: The dining service was 5 star. The food was excellent and the wait staff was extremely professional and made our group feel as tough we were on a luxury vacation. The Housekeeping Services made our stay delightful and the cleanliness of the rooms was perfect. The singing and dancing shows were entertaining. The magic shows fun. The Spa was nice, but expensive! Spend some money there - it is worth it. The crew did a great job keeping us all safe through very choppy waters.  Once the winds dyed down the sea and sky were beautiful and enjoyable. Getting on and off the ship were very well planned and executed - smooth experience.

Bad News: Customer service for the vacation experience is non-existent. The guest services could care less about your vacation experience. There is no customer service experience, no concierge service to assist your choices on or off the ship. Schedule information is delivered to your room late in the evening for the following day - forget planning ahead. If the ship docks late or if the weather is bad - too bad - no notice or help re-planning your experience at the port. 

The Cruise Director, Eli and the Assistant Cruise Director, Dee, made fun of Texans on several occasions during the cruise. The majority of guests were from Texas. There were jabs about how we talked and about what we eat. The jokes were not funny and were delivered in very poor taste (over and over again).  We watched the cruise directors morning show to learn what was available to do on the ship, and the majority of the 30 minutes Eli and Dee talked about ranch, grits, and other weird things Texans eat. All the while making fun of how we say those things as well. This is not OK and very unprofessional.

There is ZERO information provided about the excursions. Guests are on their own if they are not a part of a Carnival provided excursion. Even when our Carnival snorkel excursion was cancelled, we found out by overhearing some other guest asking. We asked the Carnival employee on the dock and were told to turn in our tickets for a refund to guest services before midnight that night, when we went to the desk the young lady acted like we were crazy and asking for her first born child. She argued with me for 5 minutes telling me the snorkel excursion went out, even though it was raining (pouring) and "are you sure you didn't go?" WHAT??? I responded - yes I am sure we did not go in the pouring rain on the boat - here are my tickets. She finally checked our account and it had already been refunded. (this is a good example of how our experience went with guest service all week).

Guests are continually bombarded to spend money. buy Carnival Excursions, Spa services, diamond jewelry, or the art on the ship.  Everything on the ship is an additional cost. The food, pool, and hot tub are free. The free tea, water and coffee are NOT delivered by the wait staff if you are at the pool, clubs, or events on the ship. We were with a group of high school seniors and if we ordered tea to drink the wait staff said they would bring Long Island Iced Tea, but no free tea. 

There is a Casino in the middle of the ship where smoking is allowed. It is very thick with smoke. The smell of smoke permeates throughout the ship. Just be prepared - this is not a non-smoking ship. The comedy was no good - filthy. Being able to say the F word 18 times in 30 seconds is not funny. So skip the comedy shows unless you like the F word so much that you would just laugh until you cried! 

We learned from other guests that other cruise lines offer a great customer experience with the ultimate vacation experience in mind. So I will take another cruise on another line to see if cruising is worth the money. This one certainly left a sour taste.  I would prefer to eat "grits" smothered in "rayanch" like Eli and Dee think all Texans like to do! (yuck).

I suggest Eli and Dee embrace Texans and learn about our culture if they want to sell excursions and diamonds to the natives who sail out of Galveston.

BTW - grits are made with hominy, and they are delicious with butter, salt & pepper - or if you have a sweet tooth - butter and honey.  

Ship Quality
Cool decor and well taken care of.
Food and Dining
Great food and marvelous service.
Service and Staff
Bad - Guest Services. Great - Food and Housekeeping Services
Shows are recommended, except for comedians.
Children's Programs
we did not experience them
Onboard Activities
Employees with guest services were rude
Destinations and Excursions
Docked late in Key West missed excursion, no notice from ship. Rained other two days.
Cabin / Stateroom
The balcony room is worth the upgrade.
Galveston, Texas
Eat at Fish Tales great food and service
Key West, Florida
Do the jetski tour through Priceline. It is AWESOME! Butterfly Sanctuary is GREAT.
Freeport, Grand Bahama Island
Beach is beautiful. Go on your own to the free beach.
Nassau, Bahamas
Pirate museum is cool. Beaches are free and you can snorkel off the beach.


Plan everything yourself and research your stops thoroughly. Do not expect any help on the ship. Go to the dining room for all your meals, and the brunch on sea days. Enjoy the hot tubs, get a massage, manicure or pedicure. Don't go to any of the presentations for free stuff; it is a lie.

Was this review helpful? 6


Leave a Comment

Remember: Be polite and respectful. Our diverse community is home to members with different opinions and a broad range of cruise experiences.


* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top