Terrible Service for Injured Passenger

Marina Cruise Review to Europe - Western Mediterranean

Cruises: 4-6 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 21

Overall rating:

1 out of 5
Marina

10 Night Italian Impressions (Barcelona To Rome)

Sail date: September 14, 2015

Ship: Marina

Cabin type: Suite

Cabin number: 10071

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 9 years ago

Review summary

Wife fell first night in Barcelona; had hair line hip fracture - not serious enough to cancel cruise but very painful.  Oceania could/would not provide disabled transportation to or from the ship and provided very limited wheel chair assistance on board - a helpful crew member nearly got in trouble for violating Oceania's policy that wheel chairs would be provided for "emergencies" only.  Situation made even worse by terrible (close to non-existent) luggage handling embarking and disembarking and to/from airport - Oceania's response to the on-shore transportation problems was "It's not our problem!"

Injury issues aside, the ship was "tired" and need of updating, and our stateroom was the same and also in need of a lot of cleaning (mold in the shower, dirty furniture, debris on the floor, etc.).

On the upside, the food was better than average, and the crew members (below the reception desk/concierge personnel) were friendly and helpful.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5

Entertainment

3 out of 5

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
The crew members (below the reception desk/concierge personnel) were friendly and helpful. The reception desk personnel in particular were brusque to the point of being overly rude (see "It's not our problem" comment quoted above).

Ship Quality

1 out of 5

Cabin / Stateroom

3 out of 5
Tired and in need of thorough cleaning.

Ports of call

Barcelona, Spain

5 out of 5

Marseille (Provence), France

3 out of 5

Monte Carlo, Monaco

3 out of 5

La Spezia (Cinque Terre), Italy

5 out of 5

Livorno (Florence & Pisa), Italy

5 out of 5

Porto Cervo (Olbia), Sardinia

3 out of 5

Valletta, Malta

3 out of 5

Catania, Sicily

5 out of 5

Sorrento, Italy

5 out of 5

Civitavecchia (Rome), Italy

5 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 21

10 Comments

SHELDON    8 years ago

Are you sure you were on OCEANIA, seriously...

SHELDON    8 years ago

Have sailed on Marina at least three times and with Oceania air least fifteen times and have never, never had a bad experience.

Bubba54    9 years ago

That is one policy that just does not make sense. Oceania needs to look up. Compassion in the dictionary. Hope you other half is doing better.

suertudo    9 years ago

Thank you.  We're not familiar with NCL, but from what we can infer, Oceania's "customer service" may be a gross misnomer.

JusMe    9 years ago

So sorry to hear of the lack of compassion and help offered by Oceania.  Sounds like Oceania now has customer service like it's parent company NCL.

Best wishes that your next cruise is better.

suertudo    9 years ago

Thank you, CruisingCM.  We've been on a few other cruises before so we won't let this one experience turn us off cruising altogether.  We don't know if Oceania will particularly care about, or even bother to respond to, our concerns, but we are least hopeful that our problems with Oceania will seen by many, many others and may just spare someone else from similar treatment.  In a way, thought, the way cruise lines treat passengers is somewhat like a popular restaurant with great food but lousy service - as long as there are more customers than space, there's no incentive to change.

noname111    9 years ago

Very sorry to hear that your cruise went badly. I'm not sure that the cruise lines have yet realized how critical it is that on board issues be managed carefully and professionally. This sort of feedback gets seen by hundreds, if not more, eyes.  As a result of seeing this, we will think carefully before booking any sort of cruise with Oceania. This is horrible customer care.

Hope you heal up soon and don't give up on cruising as a result of this bad interaction.

suertudo    9 years ago

Thanks both glomarrone and Cruisin Tim for your kind thoughts and sympathies re my wife's accident and the related problems.  Also, Cruisin Tim, while we understand that port luggage handling is controlled by the port and not the cruise line, we have had pleasant experiences with other cruise lines (including AMA and Viking) where the luggage was handled for us at every possible step - not inside restricted airport or other areas, but everywhere else.  No idea where Oceania's ridiculous wheel chair policy comes from, but if you have ever been within a chip shot of an Oceania cruise, you will know with certainty that Oceania couldn't possibly expect no injuries and other health problems with its passengers, the majority of whom don't seem to be exactly health conscious!

Anyway, thanks again both.

CrusinTim    9 years ago

OUCH!!! Hope she's doing better. PLEASE keep in mind that any hairline fracture never truly heals completely and can be re-fractured by the littlest thing, even just walking when you consider it's her hip! Nothing worse than the excitement of an upcoming cruise being affected by an unfortunate incident. Don't get Oceania's "No wheelchair" policy!! What's that all about? I guess they don't expect those with limited ability aboard their ships! My wife had one on our Princess cruise and even though she can walk a bit, she can't stand for long and Princess afforded us a wheelchair (and a crew member) for boarding and at disembarkation without question. As for the luggage boarding and disembarking, they are right. The port luggage handling is controlled by the port and not the cruise line so there is little they can do about that. Sorry. Best of luck on your next cruise. Make sure your wife treads lightly!

glomarrone    9 years ago

Sorry that your wife's fall caused here pain.  How sad that the ship didn't help her more.  I hope that your extcruise goes smoother.

Other reviews of this sailing