So my BF and I had a great debate tonight... We agree we both want to go on an alaskan cruise. We have been loyal crown and anchor members on RCI, but I've been looking into Celebrity for this Alaskan cruise. I will soon be platinum with RCI, and if I understand correctly, I would have a similar level on Celebrity's program. I tried explaining things to my BF about exploring outside of just RCI, different itineraries, ports etc etc, but his stance is "Why would we sacrifice a cruise and points on a cruise with a different line"

So loyalty aside, because it may just take some time to convince him, but honest feedback for those who have done Alaska.. What is the best cruise line for Alaska...

 

Thinks I know/prefer: 

Get a balcony

must be 7+ days 

Prefer to port out of a US port- Seattle more than likely