How often do you dine in a specialty restaurant on a cruise, if at all? Are the meals worth the extra cost?
This topic has been archived due to inactivity and closed to further replies.
Specialty Restaurants
19 Answers
The specialty restaurants save us. Without them sometimes the entire cruise would amount to a negative as the MDRs can be "not so good". We only use Regent, Princess and HAL. My MDR comment does not apply to Regent as the cuisine and service there is always great, ironically their hard to get into specialty restaurants (no charge but not that good either) one probably wants to avoid. Princess charges $25.00 per and HAL $29.00 per for specialty dining.
We do love formal nights. For us, it hearkens back to the days of yore, days of romantic ocean travel which many yearn for the return thereof. Unfortunately, poor performance in the MDRs completely ruins a good formal night. So our first order of business on Princess and HAL is to book a specialty for formal nights.
On Princess the specialty restaurants can be exquisite, particularly Sabatini's and the Crown Grill. We also book the "Crab Shack" almost every time we have the opportunity. A pleasant surprise on the two new Princess ships is the high end "Alfredo's Pizzeria" which was a no extra charge restaurant laid out like a fine dining Italian restaurant and located in a central portion of the ship's huge three deck level atrium complex. With HAL, "The Pinnacle" can be excellent as well.
On Princess recently we discovered the "Chef's Table", a specialty dining experience, not a restaurant on the ship. I called and found out that was a special arrangement only offered occasionally where they really do it up big. As they advertise; "An extraordinary treat for both gastronomes and gourmet novices. Enjoy a behind-the-scenes galley tour with Champagne and hors d'oeuvres, followed by an extravagant multi-course dinner created and hosted by the executive chef." This pitch is not an overstatement, it is truly an eating experience. They even forget to mention the variety of wines served with each course and that you end up in a special section in one of the MDRs (They drape a huge circular curtain over the entire dinner party after being seated). Only ten guests allowed each time, very-very good. My wife loved it. Trouble was I didn't ask the price. Found out when we received the final bill getting off the ship. $230. But it was still great.
I guess for dinner we eat close to 40%-50% of the time somewhere other than the MDR, not the buffets either.The only disadvantage is the specialties have the same menu each night so if you eat there a lot it can become mundane.
It is unfortunate that the specialty restaurants don't change their menu.
I have been on 98 cruises and I will not pay extra to eat on a cruise ship
We dine in the Crown grill on Princess at least twice during a 14 day cruise, I am not a big fan of Sabatini's two bad experiences not willing to give them a third chance.
Holland we will eat at Pinnacle Grill for dinner at least twice and lunch whenever they are open. I will go to the Caneletto at least once, I really enjoy the lemoncello dessert.
NCL, maderno grill at least twice.
I think it's worth the extra price, we do enjoy them.
Depending on the cruise line. On NCL you have to go to the specialty restaurants to get a decent meal as the MDR is not good. On Celebrity the MDR is so good I do not need to pay extra. On RCI and Carnival I will go once or twice a week. On HAL the specialty was good and when I wa on Princes it was so long ago they did not have specialty restaurants back then, but the MDR was so bad that it was my first and last time on Princes line (I understand that they now have good food but still a bit gun shy to try them again)
Best meal I have had on a ship surprisingly was the Emerald Steak House on the Carnival Glory. That compared with Morton's or Ruth Chris. I rate it one of the best meals I have had land or sea. Worth every bit of the $ 35.00 per person.
I have avoided Princess for a different reason but when I was on the Crown Princess the food was good.
On Princess we have dinned only twice, Once at the steak House on the Golden Princess and the other at the Italian restaurant. On NCL we went to all the restaurants in rotation as a group. The French Bistro on the Dawn was the best. The Italian was the worst restaurant I've ever been in ever........ NCL paid me back the money I spent on that one. Are they worth it?
Yes.... If you decide that the few bucks won't make a big difference on the overall cruising bill.
Next year we will be travelling to Alaska on the Norwegian Sun. When we get on we will check out the restaurants and plan our schedule accordingly. When our son joins us in Seward we will have a plan for dining on the way back. Do we plan a bit too much? Maybe, but we are seldom disappointed in the results.
Don't mess with success.
On Princess we have dinned only twice, Once at the steak House on the Golden Princess and the other at the Italian restaurant. On NCL we went to all the restaurants in rotation as a group. The French Bistro on the Dawn was the best. The Italian was the worst restaurant I've ever been in ever........ NCL paid me back the money I spent on that one. Are they worth it?
Yes.... If you decide that the few bucks won't make a big difference on the overall cruising bill.
Next year we will be travelling to Alaska on the Norwegian Sun. When we get on we will check out the restaurants and plan our schedule accordingly. When our son joins us in Seward we will have a plan for dining on the way back. Do we plan a bit too much? Maybe, but we are seldom disappointed in the results.
Don't mess with success.
We'll dine in the specialty restaurant for a special occasion like a birthday or an anniversary.
Depends on the cruise line... NCL and RC - always dine in specialty restaurants. Princess - dined in steakhouse 3 times on our 28 day cruise. Celebrity - 2 times on a 7 night cruise
We rarely dine in the specialty restaurants unless our TA gives us that as a perk. But on our next cruise, we have so much onboard credit that we will some of it on dining. In them.
REALLY any post is just one persons OPINION.....I did not know I had to state that I only put my opinion and not your opinion!!!
The question was "How often do you dine in a specialty restaurant on a cruise, if at all? Are the meals worth the extra cost?" I answered for myself, not for you.
I agree with Jusme here. It is not necessary for a commentator to have to insert the language, "my opinion only", as a qualifier onto every single observation or experience expressed. After all, that is a given, almost all of these posts are generally of the opinion variety. If a poster decides to employee factual rhetoric, then pertinent evidence should be provided to substantiate such declarations of fact.
Likewise, opinions dealing with such things as food quality, cabin arrangements, service levels, ship amenities are almost always very "subjective" and most understand that. No need for responders to continually point that out either.
I'm not saying though posters should not disagree, my all means do so. Disagreement should be duly and courteously noted though. "Let the games begin."
While on this subject, this all touches on one of the problems I have with ship and cruise reviews in general. Most believe a reviewer is rating the cruise or ship as he/she experienced it. So, if there was bad weather, a lousy bunch of traveling companions on board, etc, etc, you get the drift, and the rater gives a negative rating, that is the rater's viewpoint as to the cruise or whatever, applicable to only that rater's observations.
Okay, I understand that and don't argue with it, however I get irritated when they tally up all these one stars or four stars or whatever in order to format a general idea of the ship or cruise experience as expressed by our peers. Because, those reviews are rarely very comprehensive, therefore very limited for analysis purposes since quantitative data is sparse.
I've only eaten once in a specialty restaurant -- the Italian one on Carnival (lunch is free).
Although it was delicious, I couldn't justify an extra $25 dollars for it considering the MDR.
Of course my taste buds have drastically changed from living too long on the US/Mex border.