Radiance of the Seas vs Carnival Spirit

Radiance of the Seas Cruise Review to South Pacific - Australia

Cruises: 4-6 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 54

Overall rating:

3 out of 5
Radiance of the Seas

8 Night Queensland (Sydney Roundtrip)

Sail date: April 10, 2017

Ship: Radiance of the Seas

Cabin type: Inside

Cabin number: 4049

Traveled as: Family (older children)

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

Beautiful Ship but would prefer Carnival Spirit over it for future cruises, Spirits main areas were a lot cleaner than Radiance.

Food

Radiance Dining - Windjammer 5*s - Dining Room 3*s didn't like the Menus

Spirit Dining - Lido 4*s - Dining Room 5*s great Menu every night, 24hr Ice cream & Pizza

Entertainment

Radiance - 3*s - Like the Orchestra but not a fan of the shows

Spirit - 5*s - Playlist Productions are fantastic

Cabin

Radiance - Interior 3*s - Great size, uncomfortable beds & pillows, Small bathroom, nicer colour scheme than Spirit and loved the curtain to close off sleeping area

Spirit - Interior 3.5* - Great size, bigger bathroom than Radiance possibly due to the large lounge in Radiance where Spirit only had a chair. Beds and pillows more comfortable

Cruise Director & Entertainment Staff

Radiance - 3*s - Think his name was Steve (forgettable), Entertainment Staff, only liked a couple and where was Bingo? Never heard an announcement!

Spirit - 5*s - Eli - Best Cruise Director ever and entertainment staff from Jess, Baby Jane and Mason are all fantastic, BINGO was the best with Jess!

Adult Area

Radiance - A hot solarium that smelt of chlorine, never saw the bar open and kids freely walked through

Spirit - SERENITY Deck - PERFECT!! Pool, spa, pods, hammocks, bar always staffed, live music at times and no kids. I have no problem with kids on cruises, i take my own but sometimes you need to just chill and relax.

Access

Radiance - Well my calves got a workout using stairs as the lifts were hopeless. There's 6 i think near Centrum and some forward but that's it

Spirit - Glass elevators in Atrium and elevators at either end

Salon

Radiance - Great staff and service

Spirit - Not used it as yet.

Tour of Ship

Radiance - All Access - Missed some due to timing, no photos at all with Captain who wasn't there at the time

Spirit - Behind The Fun - FANTASTIC tour and a must do. Price included photos with Captain on the Bridge with you/family and the whole group, also had photos with Head Chef in Galley, food samples and champagne in Steakhouse.

This is based on my personal experience, remember everyone's experience is different, happy cruising.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

5 out of 5

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5

Entertainment

1 out of 5

Children's Programs

3 out of 5

Service and Staff

5 out of 5

Ship Quality

3 out of 5

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5

Ship tip

Go to Helipad and enjoy the sunsets, accessible from Deck 5

Ports of call

Sydney, Australia

5 out of 5

Newcastle, Australia

3 out of 5
Didn't get off ship.

Airlie Beach, Queensland, Australia

5 out of 5

Brisbane, Australia

5 out of 5
Australia Zoo is a must!!
Was this review helpful? 54

6 Comments

magichappens56    7 years ago

We love all ships but Spirit food was very hot and spicy for us. Chili overload in everything. Fish was overdone and dry. Pizza was good but can't live on that lol. Also theatre doors were closed until showtime so standing in long lines down through the bar area was not great for sciatica. Pros and cons for all ships. Whatever floats your boat lol.

Sneakerss    7 years ago

I also noticed you went on Spirit in 2014, shes been in drydock since then and the upgrades are great.

Sneakerss    7 years ago

Michelletoweel, no i didn't confuse ships but if you read it correctly, i did prefer windjammer over lido but Empire was better than Cascades. Never had a problem with towels on either, probably why i never mentioned in MY review. I didn't 100% hate Radiance, did say she is a beautiful ship but overall I'd pick Spirit over Radiance. The colour of decor isn't a deciding factor ☺

bobky    7 years ago

I was on the Radiance for an Alaska Cruise and had a wonderful time on the ship. The crew and staff were fun and attentive. The ship is aging, but nothing that interfered with our vacation experience. There were 2 room items that needed attention and the maintenance crew immediately fixed it. We are totally ready for the Hawaii itinerary for next week.

Michelletoweel    7 years ago

Really? Not a fan I've spirit..the food was the worst. The fit out of the ship is hideous to say the least and the towels and sheets were horrid. Thin and yellowing. However Radiance is beautiful and sailed on her twice. Are you sure you are not confusing the ships?

cbelc2    7 years ago

Usually bingo isn't announced on Royal Caribbean. The place and time are in the Compass. I'll be on the Radiance in July. I've been seeing some negatives. But I've never yet met a cruise I didn't like!