Very Disappointed!

Oasis of the Seas Cruise Review to Caribbean - Eastern

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 22

Overall rating:

1 out of 5
Oasis of the Seas

7 Night Eastern Caribbean (Ft. Lauderdale Roundtrip)

Sail date: July 09, 2016

Ship: Oasis of the Seas

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 9622

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 8 years ago

Review summary

I am an avid RCCL cruiser and have been on over 20 cruises with this line alone. I am a 45 year old business owner who has been very loyal to the line for the following reasons:

Better quality food ( The most important reason :)
Great entertainment
Exceptional service
Awesome ships
Great excursions and ports of call 

Due to business I was unable to cruise for the past 2 years. I was told by family and friends that RCCL had really fallen off. They told me there were more pay restaurants than all inclusive ones now and that you were nickeled and dimed to death, and that Carnival was the better choice. I of course being loyal did not believe this so My wife and I along with 11 others booked the Oasis of the Seas cruise that started July 9, 2016 thru July 16, 2016

I will start with the positive! My stateroom attendant was awesome! Unfortunately that is where it stops. These sites are governed by the cruise lines to draw customers so I expect any honest reviews will be removed before most can read but here goes the absolute truth on our cruise with RCCL and the Oasis of the seas. The check in process was smooth and quick. The problems start when you board the ship. You quickly notice the wear and tear on the vessel due to the 6k passengers each week. The carpets are stained the smell from the casino smoke is breathtaking while nothing works including the new Coke stations you just paid $ 65.00 to use for the next 7 days.

I will do my best to provide you with an honest step by step account of my trip in this review. As I state above we walked on the ship expecting the best only to find a ship that looked much older than it's age. I was extremely thirsty so the first thing I did was bought a beverage package. I was given a cheap plastic refill cup and was told there were coke beverage stations all over the ship and I could refill at any one of them. The guy that sold me the package told me this was RCCL's way of allowing the waiters to better serve the alcohol drinkers while making the rest of us service ourselves. I can already see how unimportant I am becoming. Regardless I went to the closest beverage station to find that it did not work. I then went to 5 more to find lines of people upset because the others were non operable as well. That's right we buy a package to serve ourselves and all the stations on the 5th floor didn't work. But the bar was in full bloom. All the alcohol stations worked fine. So I went to the bar closest to me and asked him to fill the drink cup and was told they did not do that in bars anymore to use a station. I explained the stations didn't work and I was told to report the issue. I then found a manager walking by and explained to him my issue he went straight to same bar tender and had him fill my cup along with the 200 others standing behind me. The drink stations only worked in certain areas and even then only worked at times during our 7 day trip. I share this story to set the tone as to what your should expect as I walk you through the rest of my review.

At 1:00 we are allowed to go to staterooms. So we went in and met our attendant. This was the highlight of my cruise. He was a great guy and did a fantastic job. We had dinner reservations at Izumiz Japanese Hibachi restaurant and were waiting on our luggage which never arrived. Nor did anyone else on our side of the 9th floor. The odd thing is there was luggage in halls but none in front of the staterooms it belonged to. So we all started walking the halls on both sides of ship looking for our luggage. We could not find ours and decided to go to dinner and deal with it later. We had prepaid online for the Izumizs package prior to boarding and did not want to be late. We get to the restaurant and are handed our menus. We then find out that what we bought was only for the lower items on the menu and if we wanted premium meats we would have to pay $ 10.00 more. You should expect this price gouging for your entire cruise. After dinner I gave the waiter my sign and sail card for the extra $ 10.00. Now keep in mind I questioned the waiter over the upcharge and clearly told him I thought that was shady since we prepaid. He returns with my card and tells me that my card was declined. I explained to him I booked excursions and bought the coke package all using same sign and sail card that is to be charged to my Amex platinum card. He then in front of all guests says sir you can go to guest services and put money on your card to avoid the embarrassment going forward. As you can see his comment was meant to embarrass but ended badly for him.

I then went to guest services to find a line that had over 120 people in it. That's right I'm not the only one having issues. While standing in line we hear no one can find their luggage, the beverage stations still do not work and the air conditioning in several rooms do not work. The issues are endless and after 1.5 hours on our first night of the cruise we get to the Guest services rep who informs me that there is nothing wrong with my card and the issue is with the restaurant and that she would have her staff locate our luggage. That is right I waste 1.5 hours in line for a working card. We go back to our room to see if luggage is there and still nothing. I then see my neighbor whose luggage was missing as well. We decide to go floor by floor if need be to find our bags and start our search. At 10:30 pm we start noticing the luggage still in the halls belong to rooms all over ship. For example on the 9th floor we found luggage that belonged on the 7th and so on. At 11:15 I locate my neighbors bag on the 8th floor and his wives bag on the opposite side of 9. At 11:30 PM I find our bags together on the back hall of 8. We were in room 9622.

We prepaid for the Atlantis water park excursion that started at 7:15 the next morning that promised 4 hours. We meet at 7:15 am Day 2 and get to Atlantis at 8:15 to be told the water park is closed until 10:00 and that we could use the pools until then. Now keep in mind the ship sails at 1:00 and last shuttle back is 12:30 and park is closed until 10am. This explains itself and when we all complained we were told to go to guest services. LOL. I then cancelled the rest of our excursions immediately.

Now I will quickly hit the highlights of the other issues we had to eliminate a long read.

Entertainment -  reservations were a mess. You would make reservations for shows on your TV and at Guest services and get to shows to find no reservations. This was a common issue for everyone. Their systems were always down and no one could explain why you were lost! There is limited seating for every show and without reservations you can not enter. Some good advice pre book every show prior to boarding if you want any chance to view. Otherwise you will be treated poorly.

Dining - There are now more pay restaurants than all inclusive ones on the larger ships. And even on your main dining menu you can have lower quality selections or pay for better quality dishes. The food used to be the one thing that separated RCCL from Carnival. Now thay are about equal in quality but nickel and dime you to spend more to get better selections. The food on the Oasis is at best average! 

Cleanliness - The grande didning room is located on same floor as the casino. The odor and smoke smell from the casino is so bad many refused to eat in the grande dining room. There are products that kill this odor and smell I hve no idea why this is an issue but it was terrible! The common area restrooms were nasty all the time. The floors were black in the restrooms closest to Opal Theater. People were actually taking pictures of the mess to report. I took a paper towel am wiped an area on the floor. My clean mark was there on Friday night when I went to sleep. My thoughts are way to many people on a ship. Furniture is knicked up, cup holders broken in theaters, carpets filthy, brass tarnished, glass a mess, spa nasty. The overall condition and cleanliness was poor. All surveys will convey this!

Bar Staff - Should be replaced! If you but alcohol they will come to you at poolside but you will pay $ 12.98 per 10 ounce Mudslide specialty drink and get a nice $ 2.00 gratuity added to bill to bring it to you. If you drink non alcoholic drinks forget service and be prepared to buy you a few 2 liters before boarding. The bars will actually refuse to fill our coke cup when your self serve machines do not work. On day 5 I started acting in the same manner as the bar staff. If they walked close Id stand and yell do not avoid non alcohol drinkers we deserve the same damn service as others. And when a guy at the bar refused to fill my cup Id cause a scene. This quickly changed things after a few of these fits!

In closing my thoughts are this. The new ships have to many passengers and not enough staff. RCCL is more concerned with making even more money they forgot what made them different. It is no longer all inclusive therefore no less expensive than flying your family to a destination. If you want decent food and a few beverages expect an additional $ 600.00 to 1k  each added to your sail and sign card. If you have issues they do not care and clearly will do nothing to assist as seen by our luggage. 11 of us went on this ship and unfortunatley all of us had same issues. 12 couples had planned on taking the Allure cruise in April. We all cancelled after this experience and booked Carnival. I am very loyal and really enjoyed my past vacations with RCCL. So I sad to see this occur. Very Sad! I tried explaining my concerns with RCCL Customer support and got same treatment so I refuse to spend my money with such a company! I hope this helps others to avoid the messes we did! James Tipton Knoxville TN
 

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

1 out of 5
Average at best unless you pay for upgrade meats and or restaurants

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5
Same ole same ole all designed to get you to spend!

Entertainment

1 out of 5
Nowhere enough seating for guest. If you do not book your shows before getting on ship u will not see any. Always booked and never an opening.

Service and Staff

1 out of 5
Stateroom attendant was awesome. Rest of staff were awful especially waiters and bar staff. If you are a non alcohol drinker forget getting any service at all.

Ship Quality

1 out of 5
Ships restroom floors were black and could be cleaned with a paper towel. The smoke smell from Casino was so foul that hundreds refused to eat in the Grande dining room located by casino due to smell. Ships beat up and shows wear everywhere. Sad really

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Excellent State room attendant!

Ship tip

RCCL has abandoned the all inclusive vacation cruise and has added more pay restaurants than free ones. There is an upcharge for everything including the main dining room and added soft drink machines all over the boat that never work. I will no longer cruise with RCCL

Ports of call

Ft. Lauderdale (Port Everglades), Florida

5 out of 5

Nassau, Bahamas

3 out of 5

Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas

5 out of 5

Basseterre, St. Kitts

5 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 22

33 Comments

smittycruiser    8 years ago

James, your cruise sounds like a huge disappointment. Your details were enlightening. I'd recommend following the correct channels to let RCCL know about all the issues on board. If you booked through a good travel agent they should be able to help. Always use a travel agent, it shouldn't cost any extra for a cruise and when things go wrong they can be a huge help. Don't give up on cruising!

robert85    8 years ago

Makes for better prices then for ppl like me :)

peaceharmonync    8 years ago

RCCL is going down hill fast...I'm Diamond Plus and last year was my last cruise with them....bye bye

robert85    8 years ago

U people are bullies.

robert85    8 years ago

robert85    8 years ago

I'm sorry too. No one should have the feelies hurt

jflowers0826    8 years ago

Thank you so much for your thorough and detailed review. I read every word. I'm sorry you were attacked for sharing your experiences. Thank you again!

littlescraper    8 years ago

nenna2205. Love your comment. You nailed it.

johnbchef    8 years ago

Thank you for taking the time to explain the situations you have faced on your cruise in such detail. I value your feedback. I have basically this exact same thing on Serenade in 2014 to a smaller scale. I get that their job is to maximize profit for their shareholders. But it really makes it hard for me to help you with that when your cruise company delivers these transient intense defecations on guests from time to time. I put RCCL on Ice since March 2014 if I get this effect in November this year they are going to lose me for life. I'm a 2 strikes and you're out kind of person.

kathymo35770368    8 years ago

I had lost luggage on our last Disney cruise...but it did come at the end of the first night. I now prep for that...bring an easy pack dress for the first evening and anything else that I need like that in my carry on bags. We ate at 150 Central Park and we're open to a unique experience. Mostly very good. The rest of the meals were all over at the various included dining places. Mostly good.

littlescraper    8 years ago

Well said nenna2205 ! I to have cruised a few times and share your experience.

littlescraper    8 years ago

Well said nenna2205 ! I to have cruised a few times and share your experience.

Johngold    8 years ago

Just a note, Your review , unless it contains subjects outside of the community guidelines will remain. You are entirely entitled to your view of this cruise.

I want to thank you for the precise descriptions in your review. I will look forward to other reviews of this cruise and read those as well. I hope your next cruise is better.

robert85    8 years ago

I've had similar incidents with luggage on Carnival. Our last one I didn't get my clothes until like 9pm

obpd217    8 years ago

I hate to say it but we had to look for our luggage too! We were on 6/18-6/25/16 cruise. Cruise was excellent though.

ghiagal    8 years ago

And I know in October the ship looked beautiful, carpets were very clean, stateroom clean public areas were constantly being cleaned and repairs done as needed.

ghiagal    8 years ago

At breakfast and lunch, Johnny rockets at breakfast, park cafe, promenade, sorrentos, room service, board walk dog are all included. If you choose to pay there's 150, chops, Giovanni's, Izumi, solarium at dinner, Sabor, Johnny Rockets and vintages.

ghiagal    8 years ago

Dargriff60, go through reviews on here or cruise critic, even Yelp. We were on in October and I am not saying his experience didn't happen. But it couldn't be further from our experience. Our bags were at our door by 3 pm- hours earlier than I expected with 6300 people. Staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, you don't ever have to pay for food if you don't want to, MDR, buffet, pizza, solarium

jallaway    8 years ago

I might disagree with his one star rating, but I think it's an honest statement of his experiences.

dargriff60    8 years ago

I have 7 cruises booked on that ship. Omg

jimnkathy    8 years ago

I've cruised on Royal Caribbean and Carnival and my wife and I prefer Royal Caribbean hands down. We didn't have a negative experience with Carnival we just prefer Royal Caribbean.

robert85    8 years ago

Some people just cannot be pleased no matter what cruise line staff does to try and help them out. I've never had one negative experience with staff on any ship I have been on. But it may also because I am always respectful in my interactions with crew members and anyone else for that matter. Maybe next time just do your research? Now what you are paying for before you buy so you're not surprised by any additional charges...

JamesTipton    8 years ago

It's all good, my review was honest and I was a loyal RCCL cruiser as well. But as with our current political mess people will do what the wish regardless of facts. I wish everyone the best. But I'll spend my dollars somewhere it's appreciated. 1385 negative reviews for cruise ending 7-8-2016 and 1130 negative reviews for cruise ending 7-16-2016 says everything without me needing too. We're not complainers but this was a real mess!

ghiagal    8 years ago

Well said nenna

jallaway    8 years ago

You better watch it! There's some yellow dog royal carribbers on this forum and they don't like you talkin' stuff about their brand.

robert85    8 years ago

Wow, I don't even have time to read that review. Very long. I will say this, we've done 3 with Carnival. It's nice and you can't beat the price, but with any of there ships, after the 3rd day you've seen everything that the ship has to offer. We are looking forward to our 1st RCC cruise!

ref00095    8 years ago

Sorry to hear of your experience. Will be trying Oasis in 2018 and have heard very few negatives. Just sailed FOS have to say perfect size ship for me. But the Oasis is an experience look forward to it. RCCL is my type of cruising, laid back and so much to do.

ngrafs    8 years ago

Sorry to hear about your experience! I was on the oasis back in December and had a fantastic experience and loved the coke freestyle machines! Maybe I'm just a little more laid back when it comes to having waiters serve me the entire cruise.

JennaFullmer    8 years ago

I have a hard time believing it had only been 2 years since you have been on a rccl ship. I've been sailing thr Oasis and Allure the past 5 years and the coke machines have always been there. The pay for resteraunts have also. I have never had any of the problems you have mentioned. I've never had an issue going to any bar and getting a soda. And my luggage has always showed up right at my door, no issues at all. It's passenger like you who brag about the many cruises you've taken expecting a parade as you enter the ship. No vacation, wver goes off without some sort of issue, it seems like with you the smallest issues turn into the biggest deals. Your on vacation lighten up. If you think carnival can please your needs go for it. Hate to burst your bubble but the charge for everything as well. If you had gone on as many cruises as you claim, and as recent as you say none of this shpuld have been a surprise. Your review indicates to me that you may be trying for a partial refund. Have fun on Carnival, and hopefully they will have the parade you may expect, heck they may even name a ship after you since your so special!!!

eddiemac1    8 years ago

You will have horrible reviews on almost every ship in every line. Some are just bs and blown out of proportion and some are legit. You can have a bad experience at any time anywhere. Not just cruises. I have been on RC, Carnival, Norwegian, Holland America and Celebrity. Not a bad time on any of them. As far as restaurants, there are the same amount of free ones as always. Don't want to pay, don't use the speciality ones. This review is a small small reason why I won't sail on the 'mega' ships. I like the smaller ones.

dhansen413    8 years ago

So sorry.😟 What a mess, however I hope you enjoyed your time with family and friends. Carnival has improved so you might want to give them a try. Personally we like Princess and Celebrity and I know their are horror stories about those lines as well. I don't mind a couple of specialty dining rooms, but it's getting out of hand.

capttrips    8 years ago

I'm sorry you had a bad experience, but we were on Oasis in early June and it was absolutely perfect! We also have cruised with Royal about 20 times, and will continue to!

smurfette64    8 years ago

Oh dear now I'm starting to worry about my xmas cruise on Explorer of the Seas

Other reviews of this sailing