Great to get away, but a few downers

Carnival Magic Cruise Review to Caribbean - Eastern

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Reviews: 2
Helpful Votes: 77

Overall rating:

4 out of 5
Verified Review
Carnival Magic

8 Night Eastern Caribbean (New York Roundtrip)

Sail date: July 18, 2022

Ship: Carnival Magic

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 6347

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 2 years ago

Review summary

It was nice to get away considering the past two years. We really enjoyed the entertainment.

Embarkation

5 out of 5
Considering the number of guests, it wasn't bad.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

4 out of 5
Food in dining room was great (breakfast, brunch, dinner). Lido deck buffet could have been better. A step down from past years. And 18% tacked on to every drink purchase was gouging in light of the fact that gratuities are added to your account at the end of the cruise.

Onboard Activities

4 out of 5
Two small pools could not accommodate the number of guests onboard. Unless you got in the pool early in the morning, you were faced with large crowds. We were able to utilize the pool on Amber Cove day because we returned to the ship much earlier than scheduled time, so only a few people in the pool. The Serenity deck was the same in terms of crowds and not enough chairs/cabanas. If you didn't get there extra early, you were out of luck.

Entertainment

5 out of 5
Awesome entertainment! The comedy shows were great and I cannot sing enough praises for the musical entertainment. The best of all were Music & Magic Duo. They were the highlight for me.

Children's Programs

We didn't travel with children,

Service and Staff

5 out of 5
Everyone was courteous and went out of their way to accommodate you.

Ship Quality

4 out of 5
Everywhere was clean and well-maintained. Getting to certain locations was a bit confusing if you didn't take the right elevator.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
The cabin was very comfortable with adequate closet and drawer space.

Ship tip

If you've cruised in the past (particularly Royal Caribbean or Norwegian), this ship may not live up to your expectations. And the WiFi package is a joke. Works well with the Carnival Hub app, but a hit or miss (mostly miss) with other apps. I purchased the Value plan and was upgraded to Premium which was no better.

Ports of call

New York, New York Did not visit port

We were already staying with relatives, so we traveled directly to the terminal on embarkation day.

Amber Cove (Puerto Plata), Dominican Republic

4 out of 5
Extremely hot! and it was a very long walk after leaving the ship. You did have an option to take a bicycle ride to/from the ship for $5 each way.

Grand Turk Island Did not visit port

Half Moon Cay, Bahamas (Private Island)

1 out of 5
Very disappointing. We were advised that it was not necessary to rush to get the shuttle passes, as they would be available for the remainder of the morning, and were not required beginning at 1pm. We had passes numbered 23. Our number was called sometime shortly after 12 noon. By the time the shuttle left for the island, it was 1:45pm. Unfortunately by the time we arrived on the island, the beach was packed; no where to sit or lay a towel. And the BBQ had ended at 2pm!

Disembarkation

4 out of 5
Was not as smooth as embarkation. Once our numbers were called to proceed to the terminal to pick up our luggage and go through Customs, we then had to lug our heavy bags to the street. We had scheduled an Uber however passengers waiting to be picked up had to trudge across 12th Ave, as cars were not allowed to pick up passengers in front of the terminal. It got a bit hectic, besides being hot.
Was this review helpful? 42

9 Comments

lesplas    2 years ago

Thx for sharing

GabeNSteph    2 years ago

Thanks for sharing

sycamoregrill    2 years ago

We’re on the Magic next week. Am expecting big crowds as there were only a small amount of cruises from NY and we got a great price. Glad to hear entertainment was good as we love the Magic. Happy cruising!

cydney    2 years ago

Sounds like we were on the same cruise out of NY. Great review. Have to do mine.

Gwbigdog    2 years ago

Thanks for sharing

javawoody    2 years ago

Appreciate the review

AuntPinkie    2 years ago

Appreciate your feedback. Glad you mostly enjoyed your cruise!

WhippetMum    2 years ago

Thanks for your review

kef2016    2 years ago

Thanks for sharing your cruise experience.

Other reviews of this sailing