Worst Cruise Experience Ever

Carnival Magic Cruise Review to Caribbean - Western

Cruises: 4-6 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 37

Overall rating:

2 out of 5
Verified Review
Carnival Magic

7 Night Western Caribbean (Galveston Roundtrip)

Sail date: October 11, 2015

Ship: Carnival Magic

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 8267

Traveled as: Family (older children)

Reviewed: 9 years ago

Review summary

This is the fifth cruise we have taken on four different cruise lines and this far and away was the worst cruise we have ever been on.  Here are some of the reasons why. 

 

There were waiting lines for nearly every meal throughout the cruise.  Breakfast and lunch wait lines ranged from 10-15 minutes.  For breakfast, the buffet lines were set up such that you might have to go to three or four different lines to get what you wanted and each line was 10-20 people long.  Most unorganized mess I've ever seen.  Our wait for "Your Time" dining one night was over an hour and two nights later we waited for over 30 minutes. When I went to the desk to see how much longer the wait would be, I was informed that they already showed that we had been seated. obviously we had not.  

 

On our first day, we asked four different staff members on the ship for directions to the video arcade so we could take our grandson there.  We got four different answers none of which were right.  We finally asked a young ship passenger if he could help us and he told us exactly where to go.  We experienced similar responses from staff two or three other times during the cruise where ship's staff had no clue where things were.  Pretty unbelievable quite frankly. 

 

The floors in the lido dining area were slick all the time.  We saw one lady fall.  It was like a skating rink most of the time.  I'm surprised that different floors coverings can be put down to mitigate this risk.  It was worse coming into the dining area from the pool areas on both ends but was also bad all the way through.  On one occasion, I observed on of your wait staff carrying a tray back to the kitchen area and a glass full of ice and drink fell off onto the floor.  He just kept on walking.  Several other staff members were in the areas but no effort was made to isolate the area to keep someone from falling while it was cleaned up, which by the way, took quite some time. 

 

For shore excursions, you were pretty much on your own to find your way.  There was very little guidance given as to where you were to go, when and when you asked ship staff, they could not give you a clear and concise answer. 

 

Finally, the debarkation process was the worst I have ever experienced.  We elected to do the self assisted debarkation process as we had another commitment that we needed to get to.  The instructions provided to us told us that we needed to be out of our room by 8:15 and that we were to go to certain designated waiting areas to be called.  Elevators were pretty much out of the question as everyone on the ship was trying to move to these areas and the elevators were in total gridlock.  We carried all of our bags down four floors of steps to make sure that we didn't miss our designated debarkation time.  The schedule showed starting the debarkation process at  8:15 for Priority members and decks 1 &2.  Decks 6&7 were scheduled for 8:30 and decks 8&9 for 8:45.  We were on deck 8.  We were in our designated waiting area at 8:00 and the debarkation for priority members and decks 1&2 were called at around 8:00.   No other announcements were made until after 9:00 when they finally called for deck 6.  I asked on the ships staff when our deck would be called and was told just to wait, it would still be quite a while.  Finally at 9:15, out of total frustration with the whole process, we took our bags, went to deck 3, got in line and left the ship.  No one questioned the fact that they were still on deck 6 and that we were from deck 8.  I have to assume from this, that there are absolutely no controls in place to monitor the debarkation process and therefore it is first come first off.  Had I known that, we would have went immediately to deck 8 to disembark the ship rather than waiting for over an hour and a half.  I also have to assume that had we followed the process that  had been provided us, that we would not have been off the ship until after 10:00, over an hour later than the schedule said.  If you have rules to follow, you need to put controls in place to make sure that they are followed.  You also need to be honest with the passengers about the times.   Finally, people were sitting everywhere, in the halls, elevator lobbies, on the steps, etc. waiting.  Not only is this frustrating to your passengers, in my opinion, it poses some significant safety risks. 

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5

Entertainment

3 out of 5

Children's Programs

3 out of 5

Service and Staff

3 out of 5

Ship Quality

3 out of 5

Cabin / Stateroom

3 out of 5
Cabin was clean and comfortable.

Ship tip

Expect to wait in lines for nearly every meal. Also expect a long wait for the debarkation process, much longer than they will tell you.

Ports of call

Galveston, Texas

3 out of 5

Cozumel, Mexico

3 out of 5

George Town, Grand Cayman

3 out of 5

Montego Bay, Jamaica

1 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 37

28 Comments

Jtwillow    9 years ago

We have cruised the Magic twice and we will not go back. The first experience was nice but second not so much. I had the same experience where the staff had NO IDEA where things were and I feel that should be priority. The entertainment was the same 2 years later, very disappointed with that as it is the most you do on the ship at night.

DFromATX    9 years ago

I have cruised magic twice. Overall, we've enjoyed it. We also do my time dining. Luckily for us, we only had to wait once for 20 minutes and that was on elegant night. It is a crowded ship, that I agree with. I was surprised no one helped you find the arcade. I remember on our first cruise we couldn't find the kids' area. The director happened to see us and personally escorted us with a smile.

jatexas    9 years ago

we sail out of Galveston in Winter....most of the nuts are warm in their little secure homes. We have not been disappointed. Rule #1. Relax, take a breath and be smart.

Jtwillow    9 years ago

I think it depends on the staff at that time, we have been on magic twice and first time was awesome but second was not great. Staff didn't know anything as far as where things were and would not find out for you and the entertainment was the same as the first one which was two years later, I was a bit disappointed.

Yorkienut3    9 years ago

I'm just thinking you didn't do your homework before you went on the cruise. There is maps of where everything is and shouldn't have to ask. As for the excursions I've never had s problem of where to go. First you get off the ship that would be deck 0. When you get off there is people everywhere to direct you or have signs. Even if it's not their excursion the person with s sign can tell you.

amymoore94    9 years ago

We were on the Magic three weeks ago...best cruise out of the ten we have been on!!! no complaints! as long as I don't have to cook I don't mind waiting a bit for the buffet. CD Dr. E is the best! We are booked on the Magic again in March.

thurtow    9 years ago

The Magic was my 1st cruise with Carnival. It was the ship that made me a fan of the Carnival brand. We had a blast. I agree that it was more crowded than I was used to, but well worth every dime and every minute. Disembarkation, to me, is ALWAYS unpleasant.

glomarrone    9 years ago

Thanks for posting your lengthy review supporting what you experienced.  We all can be on the same ship and have completely different experiences.  I hope that your next cruise goes smoother.

glomarrone    9 years ago

 

As you reach higher levels on Carnival you will not have to wait on long lines at embarkation.  We are brought to a separate room with seating and are processed next.    When you carry off your own bags, we always left the ship whenever we wanted after the announcement was made allowing passengers off.  Wet wet floors are a real problem on all ship's Lido decks.  My husband has almost fallen a couple of times so I know what you are saying.  We are really careful walking around the pool.

 

 

rochelle7403    9 years ago

Also, it is by cabin... So, if there are four people in one cabin.. everyone in that cabin gets it... So, buy ONE per cabin.. not per person.

rochelle7403    9 years ago

I am not familiar with the Carnival Australian Cruises. But, it never hurts to either call carnival to find out.. Or you can check to see if they are available on your cruise by checking under your booking. Just look under excursions and choose the departure port. It will be listed there. If it is listed.. it will also state whether or not it is sold out. But, check back often, as they open more.

jewels1960    9 years ago

Rochelle I hope they are available to Australian departures too

rochelle7403    9 years ago

Jewels1960.. FTTF is Faster to the Fun... there are limited sales of this on each sailing. But, if you can get one, they are so worth it.

jewels1960    9 years ago

FTTF SORRY WHAT IS IT?

rochelle7403    9 years ago

As for debarkation..... We bought FTTF and it is worth EVERY penny... We had head of line privileges at the service desk, tendering, and on debarkation with the Diamond and Platinum guests.... Was great!!!!! You are on vacation... Do not let others ruin your time.. If you do... then it is your fault for letting them...

rochelle7403    9 years ago

we sailed the Magic in September, the staff were very friendly, and professional. we had rain on our sea days and NEVER found slick floors on lido or any other deck.... You are at sea.... expect wet flooring and be prepared... Yes, there were lines and never did I think they were too long... Not to mention.. there are MANY options for dining at all hours of the day and night....

PFD8reiJBSO3ze5ynqCnaXJVR    9 years ago

Magic is a large ship, no argument, this time around its one of Carnivals smaller ships, Paradise

dillonmr    9 years ago

is Jay the Karaoke guy still on the Magic? he was great!!!

YannaBugg    9 years ago

Gee, that makes me worried. Scheduled for my first cruise with my two teens and disabled mother in December. Any tips or suggestions?

janicegrren    9 years ago

We love the magic! This is our 5th curies and our second time on the magic and when I sail again I hope it will the magic. It is a great ship.

dillonmr    9 years ago

we had no problems on the Magic...loved it!!

sw100148    9 years ago

hell I waited longer than that to eat outback salt grass etc . guess you should of planned better that is also why they have maps of the ship

lordoftraffic    9 years ago

The buffet lines can be long, however there are so many other choices you missed out taking advantage of. Debarkation is always a mess, over 2000 people getting off the ship through 2 doors. CBP screening of returning people is what dictates the speed of everyone getting off in a timely manner. Don't be in such a hurry, you're on vacation.

lordoftraffic    9 years ago

Wow, sorry you had a bad experience. I've been on the Magic 3 times and will be sailing on her again November 1st. I'm surprised to hear the staff couldn't provide you with proper directions to the arcade, I've never had any issues with staff on the Magic. All the staff I have ever communicated with has never been anything short of professional.

sassy1969    9 years ago

we were on the magic last week .... I agree debarkation was a total mess ... we however didn't experience these issues ... sorry you did .... we had an amazing time on the magic

jewels1960    9 years ago

sorry didn't see ship name at first

Sandy220    9 years ago

Wow sounds like you had a bad time.

jewels1960    9 years ago

what ship was it

Other reviews of this sailing