Carnival Magic Cruise Review to Caribbean - Western

Contributor Level: Purser

Experience
1 cruise (first)

Review
1

Helpful Votes
3

2 out of 5

Customer Service left room to be desired

Sail Date: May 10, 2015

Reviewed: 1 year ago

Traveled As: Couple

Room Type: Oceanview

My wife and I were really excited about this trip as we were celebrating a graduation and it was our first cruising experience.  Because we were new and didnt know what to expect, we opted to let the cruise line arrange our flight schedule and transfers.  This was a mistake.  

They decided to fly us out the morning the cruise ship left.  As we feared, the moment we touched down in Dallas, a huge storm hit, our connecting flight was canceled, and we were stranded there with no hope of reaching the ship in time.  The next 10 hours were spent waiting in lines in the airport, or on hold with customer service reps, some of which were very rude.  We had to fight for them to help us with our situation.  I reminded them that they booked the flights and should have flown us out sooner to avoid potential problems like this.  

We eventually got to Houston later that night where we were promised a hotel and flights in the morning.  After a 90 dollar cab ride to the hotel I was told we should go to, we arrived, confirmation number in hand.  Only to be told by the hotel they have no record of us or that confirmation number I had received from Carnival.  I decided to pay for the hotel myself and make some calls in the morning.  

After more fighting and arguing with Carnival, who claimed we should have stayed in Dallas, and that they had no record of anyone telling us to do that in the notes on our booking number.  I finally got them to pay for our hotel, but they would not fly us to mexico til the day the ship arrived.  Meaning we got to spend 2 days in a rainy miserable Houston, while we were supposed to be enjoying a cruise.  

We finally reached Mexico and had to go through customs and attend meetings from the staff of Carnival.  We were never once told sorry, or shown any empathy or remorse.  They seemed to think that they were in the clear and done all the needed to do to make it right.  We were not given any accommodations or upgrades of any kind or anything in the way of a sorry.

While on the ship, we heard tales of other guests who missed the ship that were flown out by Carnival to Mexico early.  They were also put up in a 5 star all inclusive resort.  My wife and I were put in a 3 star hotel in Houston.  I brought this up to Carnival and they gave me shoulder shrugs.  I am also still waiting and fighting to get food and travel reimbursed with my receipts that they said they'd pay for.

All and all, the ship was fun, we enjoyed the 2/3rds of the trip we actually got to spend with the boat and not in Houston.  I was horribly disappointed with the customer service and lack of professionalism.  Through this whole process I'd tried to be calm and understanding and kind, with hopes I would be treated with respect in return.  Instead I got shoulder shrugs, half hearted "sorry, there's nothing I can do"s, and a lot of waiting in lines and on hold.  We are fighting them for reimbursement of the first 3 days of our trip which they have been unwilling to even be slightly understanding about.  I dont believe I should have to pay for days I didnt get to spend in the ship.  We also might as well not have gone to mexico at all, all we saw of it was in the taxi and dragging our own luggage to the ship right before it departed for the next port.

Sorry for the long-winded review, but I even left out some more fun details for the sake of length.  If it were up to me, I'd pick a different cruise line then Carnival.  Cheap cruises customer service has been really hit or miss, we had good and bad experiences through the whole trip with them.  Cruise at your own risk, and fly to the port the day before! You never know what kind of weather could ruin your vacation.

Ship Quality
There was crew everywhere, they seemed to keep the place pretty clean and functioning smoothly.
Food and Dining
Food was good, and the menus were pretty expansive. Service was often very slow.
Service and Staff
The cleaning and food staff were very friendly and kind, many even learned our names by the end of the trip. The customer service however, the ones who should be the most kind, were very hard to deal with and very cold and unhelpful.
Entertainment
We loved our time on the ship, plenty of fun things to do all day and late into the night. We had to skip some so we could get up in the morning early enough for our excursions.
Destinations and Excursions
If you do book excursions that arent with Carnival, they will cost a lot less, but be wary of the schedule. Carnival will take great care of you if you pay for their excursions. Otherwise, it might be tricky to meet up with your tour groups, and the staff will be less than helpful in getting you to where you need to be.
Cabin / Stateroom
Our room was great, we had hoped the window could be slid open to get some air but alas, it was bolted shut. We feel it probably would have been worth the extra money to spring for the private balcony rooms. Everyone says thats the way to go. Honestly we didnt spend much time in the room anyways but to sleep, and it functioned great for that.
Belize City, Belize
The cave tubing here was really great. We went with Island Marketing LTD. They had really fun guides that told us all about the country and the caves. Very informative and fun, we had a great time.
Mahogany Bay, Roatan, Bay Islands, Honduras
This is the best place to do ziplining. They have big strings of ziplines that send you straight through the jungle, with a great view of the ocean too. I recommend doing ziplining here. There is a public beach right next to port that can be walked to and accessed for free. It more than served our needs for white sands and clear waters. If you want to do snorkeling or other beach activities you might want to look elsewhere though.

Tip

I lived on deck 10, the "lido deck", great food there. I really recommend at least one of the "extra" dining experiences. We did the steakhouse (35$ a person), and the cucina (15$ a person) and we greatly enjoyed them both. Much more personal and quiet dining experiences and worth the money.



Was this review helpful? 3

4 Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember: Be polite and respectful. Our diverse community is home to members with different opinions and a broad range of cruise experiences.

Anonymous



*Cruiseline.com is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. Cruiseline.com does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. Cruiseline.com is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top