Carnival Liberty Cruise Review to Caribbean - Southern

2-3 cruises


Helpful Votes

3 out of 5

Southern Caribbean cruise

Sail Date: May 24, 2015

Reviewed: 1 year ago

Traveled As: Couple

Room Type: Balcony

The southern Caribbean was beautiful.  The Carnival Liberty ship was so-so.  The exhaust fumes were so thick you couldn't walk on the walking track which was on the upper level.  The food was average.  Even in the main dining room (not the buffet), the food tasted like frozen fast food.  I had a grilled chicken breast that looked and tasted processed, not fresh like I expected.  Therman (sp?) was a great waiter.  You could smell sewage periodically throughout the ship and even in our balcony room.  Although the strong smell didn't last long, it was very disgusting.  Our toilet had particles that looked like coffee grounds in it even after flushing.  We wondered if the smell was coming from our lavatory but smelled it throughout the ship as well.  For those of us that don't "party", it was very annoying when the drunks would come down the hall at 1 - 2 o'clock in the morning, laughing, yelling and screaming.  Another couple had decorations stolen off their doorway and placed on another doorway, just goes to show the drunken antics we experienced.  I realize that Carnival has a "party" reputation, but if you want a peaceful experience, I would recommend another company.  Overall, just a very average experience.

Ship Quality
The carpet and lamp shades were stained.
Food and Dining
Disappointed, the main dining at night was poor quality. It looked and tasted like frozen, processed meat.
Service and Staff
Not exceptional, just normal. We had trouble on several nights in the main dining room, just getting served iced tea and coffee. We had to catch our waiter as he would walk away from our table without even acknowledging us. Seems like we were ignored???
We went to several "PG" rated shows. The comedians were good.
Destinations and Excursions
Definitely read trip advisor before booking. Some were good and some were not worth the money. I realize that tourism is the main form of income for these islands, but I felt that I was being pinched for money all the time as you would need a taxi to get to the excursion, or the excursions wouldn't let you take your own photos to get you to buy their expensive photos.
Cabin / Stateroom
The balcony room was nice. The ships decks was so crowded and pools were small, it was nice having a quiet deck to get away from so many people.
San Juan, Puerto Rico
This was considered your "first" port. However, we you arrive at the airport, you really don't have time to see the town. The excursions were very expensive.
Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas
We snorkeled looking for sea turtles at Buck Island. The turtles were small, brown dots on the bottom of the ocean floor. The ship's captain and assistant were excellent but didn't see the squid, octopus or anything else except a sea urchin.
Bridgetown, Barbados
This excursion was better. We did the "Ultimate Shipwreck and Snorkel". The sea turtles were closer to shore and you could actually see them fairly close. The ship wrecks were interesting. I would recommend this trip.
Castries, St. Lucia
The Countryside Drive and Beach tour was not worth the $55 (each). It was educational to see how the people of the island live but boring. At the end of the tour, the bus driver dropped us off at a beach and then left! The beach (Pigeon Island) was not pretty, it was full of sharp lava rock. I did not enjoy this trip and cannot recommend it.
Basseterre, St. Kitts
We did the dolphin encounter at St. Kitts. It was very disappointing as you may be in the Caribbean ocean, but it is still an enclosure and with only 1 dolphin. The excursion details said that you could swim with the dolphins - NOPE! You stand on a platform. The other detail that they interestingly forgot to tell you is that you cannot take your personal camera in with you. If you want pictures, it will cost you $35 for 1 picture of ONE person. Or $115 for the entire CD for 2 people, $175 for 4 people. So if you splurged on a GoPro like I did. Forget it. They make you lock it up.
Philipsburg, St. Maarten
We took the 4.5 hour bus trip around the island. Educational, but not exciting. We were able to see the main sites of the island and of course, the main shopping stops. The food was not good, a ham sandwich was $8 and had one thin slice of deli ham and the bread was so dry, you couldn't choke it down. Take your own snacks.


The ship and food was average. The excursions were average as well. The descriptions of the excursions don't tell you the cost of a taxi fare or that the taxi drivers practically attack you for your business when you get off the ship.

Was this review helpful? 6


Leave a Comment

Remember: Be polite and respectful. Our diverse community is home to members with different opinions and a broad range of cruise experiences.


* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top