A Mixed Bag

Carnival Dream Cruise Review to Caribbean - Western

Cruises: 1 cruise (first)
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 45

Overall rating:

3 out of 5
Carnival Dream

7 Night Western Caribbean (New Orleans Roundtrip)

Sail date: June 04, 2017

Ship: Carnival Dream

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 10232

Traveled as: Large Group

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

I found this cruise to be a very mixed bag.  It was my first cruise experience and I am not sure that I would go on another Carnival cruise again.  

Our dinner service waiter team, Michael Ivan, Francis, and Rowel, were great.  Very polite, helpful, and unobtrusive.  (This was made very apparent when we had to move tables one night for a medical issue because that service team made Michael's SHINE.)  Redian at the Alchemy Bar was also a stand-out employee, an attentive and excellent bartender.

The entertainment at the Encore Lounge was terrible.  We walked out of two shows shaking our heads. The comedians weren't very good either, we walked out of two of those shows as well- the jokes were tired and not funny.  

However, the VERY talented Mic Control did sets by the Alchemy Lounge, occasionally joined by The Smoking Brass.  They were fantastic and I much preferred them to the "stage productions."  We made it a point to show up to their sets on several nights and enjoyed a wide variety of songs from all decades.  I'm from Nashville and they could absolutely hold their own at any live music joint in town.

The spa was a disaster.  Not only did they get the scheduling wrong for many of my friends on the trip, the women at the front desk were rude and unhelpful.  It was strange because we got at least 2 flyers a day promoting spa specials, so I felt like they wanted my business.  But I didn't feel that way when I was there.

We had a balcony stateroom, which was just ok.  Our cabin steward had it cleaned every night while we were at dinner.  The decor and furniture could use some serious updating (the curtains were stained, there were scratches in the faux leather couch and most wooden surfaces), but we were comfortable, and it wasn't as small as I was expecting.  I was not happy the night after balconies were cleaned while we were at port and several of the balcony dividers came open at 5 am and slammed around in the wind.  A special tool is needed to close them and it took an hour and a half for someone to come see to it.

Lido deck is loud and crowded.  The pools are tiny and there's standing water everywhere after it rains.  I made a point of avoiding it. The tequila and rum bars were crowded and slow so save your money and go to the Alchemy Bar instead.  Wandering around on that level (5) we found a few quiet spots that were great for hanging out and relaxing with family.  The Pig and Anchor BBQ spot open on sea days was tasty but get there early because lines are LONG.

The highlight of the trip was Althea's Behind the Fun Tour on Saturday morning.  I really enjoyed learning about the logistics of a ship so large.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5

Entertainment

1 out of 5

Service and Staff

5 out of 5

Ship Quality

3 out of 5

Cabin / Stateroom

3 out of 5
It needs some updating- but it was comfortable.

Ship tip

The buffet was ok for breakfast- but the continental breakfast towards the back was really good and if you go upstairs behind it the upper dining room was usually deserted during breakfast if you just wanted some quiet. Alchemy Bar drinks cost $1 more but also have an extra shot!

Ports of call

New Orleans, Louisiana

3 out of 5

Mahogany Bay, Roatan, Bay Islands, Honduras

2 out of 5
Even with a ton of sunscreen every hour I still got burned to a crisp on the beach! the light is different that far south. :)

Cozumel, Mexico

2 out of 5
The VIP Catamaran Champagne Sail & Snorkel was terrible. Unless you specifically want a party boat I don't recommend it.
Was this review helpful? 45

11 Comments

jdcrowe1eaglesusiedu    7 years ago

Sunshinel9ver please refrain

sunshinel9ver    7 years ago

Sounds like we cannot change hk47's mind.

jsfun2016    7 years ago

sorry hk47, if I came off negative I really didn't mean to be. I just wanted to share my experience on the Dream and encourage you to try again. Wishing you a wonderful time on your next cruise...hopefully.

PeasnCarrots    7 years ago

Hk47, I appreciate your honest review. Also, the comment about Dream having a bad week makes sense. We were on Dream a few years ago and I hated it! We both came home with a lung fungus due to improper cleaning of vents. (Once the head engineer got involved and listened to what I was saying he looked into things and realized what had happened). I swore I would never do Dream again. Well, sailed Dream in February and loved it. Headed out on Dream in August. Give it one more shot and sail during off season months. We really enjoy October, November, January & February.

hk47    7 years ago

Why the negativity? Are honest reviews not welcome? If so let me know and I'll delete my review.

cganesh    7 years ago

sorry you had issues but nothing is ever perfect on any vacation. we don't like Lido deck so hang on deck or rear of Lido where there's less going on. We've cruised on Dream 4 times and doing 5th in Sept. the problems you mentioned have been issues on all cruises we've ever been on (Carnival, Royal Caribbean, Norwegian) plus many more things you didn't have issues with.

jsfun2016    7 years ago

We were on the Dream last October. it was our first experience cruising and we loved it. There were a few bumps along the way (we had the same experience with the heavy doors coming loose and banging after balcony cleaning - and the standing water on deck after heavy rains) but we took it all in stride given that the staff were amazing to us, and we were in the carribean seeing and doing things we had only dreamed of. We went on the cruise not really knowing what to expect and came out wanting to do it again...already booked for Oct 2018. I am sorry this trip made you question your desire to do it again. Hope you decide to try again and don't miss out on the fun, you never know how much you might enjoy the next one. Best of luck to you hk47.

erattee    7 years ago

I have been on 3 carnival cruises so far, including the dream and have never had a problem with them. I will only go on carnival ever. sorry your experience wasn't as good as ours.

sunshinel9ver    7 years ago

I understand hk47. You had a bad experience. I have never had those things happen and I love the Dream. Give them another chance..,

hk47    7 years ago

After reading older reviews and then more recent ones from this month, it seems like the Dream was probably having a bad week or something. Please don't take my negative points personally - I tried to balance them with positive ones.

Kimluvs2cruise    7 years ago

The Dream is one of my favorite ships. Sorry you were disappointed.

Other reviews of this sailing