Didn’t Meet the Hype

Scarlet Lady Cruise Review

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Reviews: 4
Helpful Votes: 53

Overall rating:

3.9 out of 5
Scarlet Lady

14 Night Transatlantic Miami To The Med (Miami To Barcelona)

Sail date: April 21, 2024

Ship: Scarlet Lady

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 7 months ago

Review summary

Virgin has a lot of potential, but my cruise experience was not very good. I came away from a 14 day transatlantic very unsatisfied; beautiful looking food that was served cold & greasy, badly planned or no activities at all, entertainment that was repetitive & bland, cattle call style lineups for venues, poor communication, little bang for the buck. On the good side, the ship is very easy to get around and is one of the most comfortable ships I’ve sailed on. The gym & its programs are the best in the cruise business.

Embarkation

4 out of 5

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

2 out of 5
Pink Agave- excellent Dazzle Dazzle- excellent/ good The Wake- good Test Kitchen- good Gumbae- good Extra Virgin- awful The Galley- bad, awful, a little good The dock- good Gumbae- farm raised shrimp were squiggly and tasteless. Fried items were served cold and greasy. You couldn’t get the squid pop without disgusting mayonnaise on it. Beef was good, but overly salty from the sauce that was used. Kimchi rice was inedible being sooooo greasy. Extra Virgin was surprisingly, not Italian. A few pasta dishes with adulterated, greasy sauces that were uninspiring. For instance, gnocchi was ordered. Only 5 gnocchi in a huge bowl, and served cold. Pink Agave was by far our favorite restaurant. Everything, while being far from authentic Mexican, was very good and served hot. Razzle Dazzle was overall very good with some major clunkers on the menu like the hot cauliflower which was basically like Outback’s blooming onion, but this was served as a main. Disgustingly greasy. BTW, greasy was the common thread through almost all of the food onboard. Razzle Dazzle shined for breakfast where the watermelon with tofu cream and the bacon were fantastic. The Wake was just good. Our steak was served cold and they put mayonnaise on the asparagus. Spatchcock chicken was disgusting. I found all of the beef onboard to be overcooked even if ordered rare, the chicken undercooked and mostly dark meat, and all of the shrimp was farmed raised and tasteless. The food in all of the venues onboard is done basically by assembly line. There’s no other way to cook for nearly 3,000 people 3X daily. So, that being said, a lot of times the problem was cold food. But, something that IS in Virgin’s control; the amount of oil and fats used. They want to portray themselves as vegan friendly, but in this case, vegan doesn’t mean healthy. All food, however, was presented with great flair & style. But, Test Kitchen was surprisingly good, but almost everything was served cold and not quite hot enough. The Galley- other than the salad bar during the day & bagel bar in the morning, the Galley was dreadful. Cold food that was repetitive. The burgers were awful, too. French fries were good. No rotation to the desserts. Always the same. Sushi was awful. tuna, salmon, and fake crab in a salad style with mayo rolled up in hard rice that wasn’t completely closed so every piece fell apart when you picked it up. Truly disappointing. The breakfast burritos came premade & couldn’t be accommodated for individual dietary needs. Same with the sandwiches & the Ramen Bar. Want just strawberries with your yogurt? Can’t have it. That’s premade too with other berries and things that I can’t eat. Calling the Galley not a buffet is like calling McDonald’s a steakhouse. The Galley IS a buffet. It’s just served to you. The quality is somewhat better than on most cruises, but the monotony and repetitiveness on a 14-day cruise was painfully apparent. Even MSC changes up the menu a little more. The Pizza Place was very good, if you got your pizza with very little or no cheese. The cheese they use is so wrong for pizza; too gooey & soupy. But, the crust is tasty. Lick me Til I Scream is just awful. It’s not ice cream, it’s non-dairy vegan. Stick with the few sorbets. it just didn’t live up to it in taste

Gunbae

3 out of 5

The shrimp are large and plentiful, but have no flavor other than the sauce they’re in. Beef was salty. Kimchi fried rice inedible. Very nice chef/ host/ waiter. Enjoyed all the pomp. Hated the food.

The Social Club Diner

1 out of 5

This is where they held all their onboard games like trivia & name that tune. Problem was, the space doesn’t hold many and you got shut out every time because people from The Villages held seats for their fellow villagers. First time I was ever on a cruise, and a 14 day one at that, where I never played any puzzle, trivia, or group game. Bad logistics, bad planning.

Razzle Dazzle Restaurant

4 out of 5

The menu is like a minefield. Some really good items, and some true duds. But either way, it will be served cold. Good- beet perogie, lamb shank.Awful- hot cauliflower, carrots in foam.

The Pizza Place

4 out of 5

Very good even though the cheese kind of sucks. I had many pizzas Napoli style; no cheese!

The Manor

1 out of 5

Always crowded. Lines for entry every night at least half hour wait. No reservations accepted. Many fellow sailors would go to the same show multiple times shutting out other sailors. First come first serve is just a bad idea.

The Wake

3 out of 5

I really wanted to like the Wake. But, serving mayo on asparagus & serving both a filet and strip medium cold just doesn’t cut it. But, it is a beautiful restaurant and had one of the best desserts onboard in the crepes cake.

The Galley

2 out of 5

Repetitive and uninspiring. They often ran out of ice for drinks. Most food was premade & not to order. Basically, it’s a buffet where they serve you.

The Dock

4 out of 5

The octopus was delicious as was the fish & shrimp. Chicken kebabs were served undercooked

Lick Me Till...Ice Cream

1 out of 5

Not ice cream at all. Made from non-dairy “milk” like almonds, cashews, or rice. And not very good vegan even.

Extra Virgin

2 out of 5

Greasy & awful. Spatchcock chicken, not very Italian, was undercooked. 5 gnocchi on the plate. Not many red sauce options.

Bento Baby

1 out of 5

Awful sushi. Less than supermarket quality.

Onboard Activities

2 out of 5
Activities were standing on line, getting shut out of trivia, and trying to get ice for my soft drink at night. I played no games & saw only one (very bad) show. Really bad system Virgin uses to fill their venues. First come first served doesn’t work when your fellow sailors are a bunch of gluttons.

Entertainment

2 out of 5

The Red Room

2 out of 5

After we waited on line for over half an hour, we got to finally see a show (our third try at seeing one.). Sooooo not worth it. Not to take anything away from the one performer who truly performed, but the choreography, story, choices of music, and so on, were lame and boring. 9 members of the ensemble, and only one of them spoke or sang. It was as basically a one man show with a lame supporting cast that looked lost most of the time.

Service and Staff

5 out of 5
Great staff, except the ones who were standing on line in back of us in Funchal who thought it was OK to smoke online. Yes, 5 Virgin crew members lit up at the same time under the alcove while waiting over an hour and fifteen minutes to get back on board. Rude!

Ship Quality

5 out of 5
One of the best designed, easy to get around liners there is. A little prone to unsettling movement when turning.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Our cabin was spectacular. Plenty of storage and well designed. Our cabin stewards were also awesome!

Ship tip

Don’t order drinks while within any governmental jurisdiction, you’ll be heavily taxed. Wait until in international waters. Tax free then!

Ports of call

Miami, Florida

3 out of 5

Malaga, Spain

4 out of 5

Valencia, Spain

5 out of 5

Funchal, Madeira

5 out of 5

Barcelona, Spain

5 out of 5

Disembarkation

5 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 4

9 Comments

Sogmoore     4 months ago

Great review and thanks for sharing

Ladyjunecliff     6 months ago

Thanks for your honest review.

Gwbigdog     7 months ago

Thanks for sharing

Dumfy75     7 months ago

All of the restaurants being included on Virgin is a big draw, but not if the food’s greasy (massive no no for me, makes me ill). At least you tried it, sorry you were disappointed.

AuntPinkie     7 months ago

Appreciate your very detailed feedback. Sorry this cruise didn’t meet your expectations.

cruising2004     7 months ago

Thank you for your detailed review. Sorry this cruise was not up to par.

ggeane     7 months ago

Food is one of the most important things. It doesn’t have to be endless but it has to be good. Sorry to hear this

HeavySeas     7 months ago

Thanks for sharing

javawoody     7 months ago

Sorry you were disappointed