Hits and misses

Scarlet Lady Cruise Review

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Reviews: 9
Helpful Votes: 97

Overall rating:

3.9 out of 5
Scarlet Lady

5 Night Dominican Daze (Miami Roundtrip)

Sail date: May 26, 2023

Ship: Scarlet Lady

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 1 year ago

Review summary

This was our first trip on Virgin after two on Disney and five on Princess. This is much different and some of that I liked. The service on board is sporadic. Every person I met, or even passed in a hallway was very friendly. They do pride themselves for some reason on a lack of announcements which meant if you had questions you had to ask someone. The employees seem to only know about what they do and nothing else so some were not helpful. The service issues impacted the dining also. In the galley (sort of buffet) they take your order and then somebody else comes and delivers your food. There are about nine different food stand options in the galley and each delivers their own food. So if you order food from multiple places, you will get your food delivered at different times. This can be challenging if one person gets their food twenty minutes before another person when you are dining together. Sometimes it was very quick. Other times, not as much. The food stands in the galley had varied hours so it was difficult to predict when anything might be open. My biggest service gripe was one night in their gaming/sports area. I arrived a half hour before the hockey game to get a good seat and table to watch the playoff game. Five minutes before the game start, the employee came over and placed a “reserved” sign on the table telling me I would need to relocated because it was reserved for a “Rock Star status” group. I don’t really mind the fancy people getting their perks but if they were going to reserve the table it should have been done much earlier so I would not have chosen it in the first place. I was not offered any compensation for getting screwed out of my spot. Moving on to something more positive, the food was excellent. Food in the galley or any other specialty restaurants was all outstanding. Pink Agave was our favorite. The ship itself has some nice touches and some shortcomings. We loved the Dock area at the back of Deck 7. It’s a great area to lounge during the day that has shade, a more relaxed atmosphere, good food and the only not busy bar on board. I liked the gray color of the ship and the wide promenade deck. I didn’t like that the promenade deck had high partitions around a lot of it that limited the sea view. The overall layout was ok but I did find myself getting turned around and that never happens to me. We loved the fun vibe of the ship. It was a very diverse (in any way you could possibly define that) group of people and that made it interesting. The entertainment was a bit frustrating. This is partially my fault for not doing more research but I didn’t know you had to reserve your shows when you first board so we didn’t get to see any of them. They have a standby line but I’m not thrilled with lining up for a chance to see a show so we didn’t partake. They have lots of activities that are fitness related and not near as many that aren’t. Embarkation and debarkation was fairly easy but they should have more seating outside for your arrival if they aren’t going to let you in. I also didn’t know that I had to go to Sailor Services to get a bag tag for my bag before you leave it out for them on the last night. There seems to be some assumption they people will just know the things they don’t announce. Overall we enjoyed our trip. I would do Virgin again but not as a first choice.

Embarkation

4 out of 5
They make you wait outside until your boarding time and there is limited seating. Once through the doors, the process was fairly quick and easy

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

5 out of 5
Outstanding food from every venue.

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5
The pools are tiny and get overwhelmed fast. It can be difficult to find any lounger, much less one with shade. The nighttime shows were supposedly good. I wasn’t able to get into any because I didn’t know you had to sign up as soon as you board so they were quickly filled for the week. Most activities were fitness related. Good for folks that are into that.

Entertainment

3 out of 5

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
Everyone was friendly but they all only know whatever it is they do. They know nothing about anything else on ship. They make no announcements so it’s hard to understand what is happening or what you are supposed to do.

Ship Quality

4 out of 5
It was very clean and well maintained. I like the gray color which is different than every other ship at sea. I love love the Dock area at the back of deck 7. It’s a great area with shady loungers and a great bar and good food. Best place to hang out. Other aspects were odd to me. The overall layout is still somewhat confusing. I have an excellent sense of direction generally and I still got turned around more than I would like to admit. There are limited public restrooms or they were so well hidden that I wound up walking halfway across the ship to find a bathroom. A lot of the promenade deck has double high partitions which limits the view of the ocean. We loved the hammock on our balcony.

Cabin / Stateroom

4 out of 5
The bed was super comfy. We loved the hammock on the balcony. The room was similar size to most other lines but the bathroom was tiny. The shower was bigger and had a door which is nice but the rest of the bathroom was super small. Many ships have limited counter space but they make up for it by adding some higher shelves for things. Not here. Just a tiny counter. The lighting options in the room were a nice touch. The powered curtains were more trouble than they are worth.

Ship tip

Book your entertainment as soon as possible or you will miss it.

Ports of call

Puerto Plata, Dominican Republic

3 out of 5
Pretty little city by the ocean. It’s obviously a poor country and I wouldn’t feel safe wandering off too far.

The Beach Club (Virgin Voyages), Bimini Bahamas

5 out of 5

Disembarkation

5 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 7

7 Comments