Queen Mary 2 is showing her age !

Queen Mary 2 Cruise Review to Transatlantic

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Reviews: 4
Helpful Votes: 137

Overall rating:

2 out of 5
Verified Review
Queen Mary 2

Westbound Transatlantic Crossing

Sail date: May 09, 2014

Ship: Queen Mary 2

Cabin type: Oceanview

Cabin number: 5001

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 10 years ago

Review summary

The hype and "glamour" of sailing on the Queen Mary is not that special. Yes, it is a truly fine ocean liner and handles the North Atlantic well but everything else is just about standard for a Carnival Company owned ship. We've sailed on many of them: COSTA, HAL, the old Carnival back in the 70's. We've also sailed with RCL. Holland America is actually better. The ship is 10 yrs old and could use some facelifting. Sained and dirty carpeting, less than comfortable seating, bath towels like sheets of canvas and buffet food offerings less than sumptuous. Not impressed with how the buffett was organized, always seem to be closing the station we just got to. Food handling was not as sanitary as I would have expected and some of the offerings were just too repititious. The embarkation process was chaos. Over 2 hours to load and not enough staff. They sent an email advising to not arrive till after the lunch hour. Got there at 1:30 and didnt board till 3:30 ! Disembarkation was just as bad. No announcement, crew was surly and nobody knew the status. almost an hour behind schedule. the entertainment was less than stellar, although several good lectures were had. Our dining room staff did well but the menu needs help. Kudo's for carrying a non-alcoholic wine (at $30/btl) and the High Tea was well done. Spending quality time with family compensated for the poor overall experience. Oh, and never got a final on-baord spending statement before leaving !

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
Poor would be a better choice

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5

Entertainment

1 out of 5

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
some were good but many were dis-interested or downright surly

Ship Quality

3 out of 5

Cabin / Stateroom

3 out of 5

Ship tip

Stay away from the King's Court Buffett. Hot food should be hot, cold should be cold and cooked food should be well presented.

Ports of call

Southampton (London), England

1 out of 5
Why dig up the streets when you know well in advance that this pecail sailing is scheduled ?

New York, New York

5 out of 5
If you are a US resident, no problem. Long wait for the foreign passport folks
Was this review helpful? 70

5 Comments

BDRebel    9 years ago

Your followup is greatly appreciated. Every ship will have an "off" cruise, which unfortunately seems to be the one you were on. The fact that you went the extra mile to find out why, and then amend your review, is terrific.

noname111    9 years ago

Thank you for posting your review.  You provided your honest opinion of the experience and I appreciate that you provided an amendment as to contributing circumstances.  Hopefully you next cruise is a fabulous experience all around.

railroad98    9 years ago

As a follow-up: My research has uncovered the fact that over half of the ships crew "turned-over" just prior to our sailing and were not fully experienced with the ship and each other. There were other extenuating circumstances, Prince Phillip's visit for one but perhaps it is time for a refurbishment.

glomarrone    10 years ago

Sorry to read that you had multiple complaints about the ship. Perhaps the ship is due for a refirbushment?

DougSmith362    10 years ago

I honestly don't know what some people class as "Luxury". Their expectations must be SO HIGH, that nothing is ever to their expectations. Having been onboard Queen Mary 2, and infact, all 3 Cunard "Queens", I have to say that everything that people have said, just does not add up. Queen Mary 2 - and, come to think of it, her 2 "Sisters" - way surpassed my expectations when I went onboard her, and when I cruised on her. The buffet restaurant is one place that I WOULD recommend to go for something to eat, along with Todd English Restaurant and the Golden Lion Pub. In fact, I found that all the restaurants onboard were superb, and the food was FANTASTIC!. The staterooms were immaculate, with everything in place... so much so that, you would have thought that everything was brand new. I must also say that the staff were absolutely fantastic and very smart indeed. NOTHING was too much trouble... especially when it came to assisting guests with disabilities to/from the ship at the ports of call. My Stateroom Steward was, again, extremely friendly and helpful, and if I required any assistance, he was more than happy to assist. The shows in the main theatre were, as expected, typical West End or Broadway style shows, with very professional cast. Also in the main theatre, the talks were exceptionally done by experts in their own fields. Overall, I would give Cunard a 5* rating, as my times onboard have been nothing short of exemplary!!! GO CUNARD!!!

Other reviews of this sailing