Bigger is not always better

Norwegian Breakaway Cruise Review to Caribbean - Bahamas

Cruises: 4-6 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 49

Overall rating:

2 out of 5
Norwegian Breakaway

7 Night Bahamas & Florida (New York Roundtrip)

Sail date: March 19, 2017

Ship: Norwegian Breakaway

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 9318

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

One of the biggest ships in the Norwegian fleet, I was a disappointment. This was our first "super ship" cruise and we were eager to compare it with our experiences on other Norwegian ships (Dawn and Spirit). Breakaway is a very large vessel with many amenities however many of them are extra $$$. Of the 22 bars and lounges on board many were only open during specific hours and most were always overcrowded. I spent 45 minutes trying to get a drink at the atrium bar during one of the cruising game shows held in the atrium. With the place packed with people trying to see the show and only 2 bartenders working, well you see my point.

The  ICE BAR at $20 per person for 30 minutes standing in a walk-in freezer to have 2 martinis, there was 1 large ice block chair and no tables except for the bar surface (definitely not like the photos in brochure) .PRIME MERIDIAN situated between two of the "specialty dining $$$) restaurants had seating for about 12 people and was only open after 5:30 for the dinner crowd.

With so much centred around their atrium it is far too noisy to enjoy a quite drink in O'Sheehan's neighborhood bar with the sound of the Arvin and Emily banging out their interpretation of Neil Diamonds Sweet Caroline with the music so loud you can't hear yourself think.

i got the feeling at the Second City comedy show that someone had mixed up all the cues and lines on a TelePrompTer, but this was not the case, the participants had no flow and no connection with each other (Left after about 20 minutes)

likewise ROCK OF AGES was a disappointment because we had heard such great things about it. This production seemed to be like a puppet show with half the strings cut. The performers were over embellishing their movements and did not seem to know when to stop. 

It reminded me of an elementary school play where the teacher is off stage giving instruction to the actors, except in this case the teacher was not there.

my biggest complaint was the smoking on board. It seemed to be permitted everywhere in the casino, which with its open concept to above and below, meant that the smell of smoke was everywhere. We had just finished a nice meal in the dining room only to be faced with the smell of smoking when we exited the dining room(Savor). The casino itself was unbearable for me as the smokers were everywhere.

The only bar at spice is surrounded by the smoking area, however I found out midway through the cruise that smoking is allowed everywhere at Spice H2O.

Although mathematically the ratio of crew to passenger is the pretty much the same on different size of vessels. This vessel seemed to be really short staffed the bartenders seemed especially overworked.

we shall give Norwegian another shot on a smaller vessel, however I hope that they have not taken this approach throughout their fleet. 

One last thing, double-wide strollers have no place aboard a cruise ship.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
Adequate, but seemingly to encourage you to go the $pecialty dining room$

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5
Overcrowded, had to make reservations and/or pay extra

Entertainment

1 out of 5
Over stated and sub par. Amateurish

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
The cabin stewards are amazing. Everyone is friendly, however when you are overworked even the most pleasant person can develop hostility

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Cabin was great, we had aft facing which I was concerned about because we would not be able to see anything until we were beyond it. But we had been to all the ports on this cruise previously so we gave it a try. The balcony was huge, with two loungers, two deck chairs and a small table . Still there was plenty of room for more.

Ship tip

Prepare yourself for crowds and noise wherever you go. I guess that's why they promote it as having the heart of a New Yorker.

Ports of call

Port Canaveral, Florida

1 out of 5
Why this would be a destination port is beyond me. There is not enough time to experience anything. Would you pay full price to Disney only to get on one ride then have to leave.

Great Stirrup Cay (Cruise Line Private Island), Bahamas

1 out of 5
Under construction! Lots of opportunity to spend more money on snorkelling swimming parasailing etc.

Nassau, Bahamas

3 out of 5
Great place to get off an explore. Ship tours are expensive , however your can get on the exact same tour for less by booking independently.

Traveler Photos

Ice bar Overcrowded beach Departure party
Was this review helpful? 49

15 Comments

Gwbigdog    1 year ago

Thanks for sharing your cruise.

StephanieE1    7 years ago

There was a small portion of the casino with slots that was suppose to be non smoking.  Unfortunately the only signs were small ones on the bottom of the slot machine, so everyone was smoking.  I ask a casino worker about this and he said "They were told it is non smoking if they notice it happening".  As he walked past me at 2 smokers.....

Badstina    7 years ago

Yes I agree with many things you said.

kathystarcher    7 years ago

The comments about the smoking are dead on correct. I think that there are some ships that provide more options for smokers and Breakaway is one..smokers know this so they enjoy sailing on her. That's fine... but if you don't smoke it can be bothersome so knowledge is power. Look at another ship.

LadiesCruisin30    7 years ago

I am just the type to make the best outta any situation if I wanna have a good time I will you just might see me double fisted no complaints there lol

LadiesCruisin30    7 years ago

Well it's a review not everyone is going to have the same experience & some have different expectations/standards than others no one person the same,a cruise is a luxury & just being away for 7 days is great but I hope everything goes smoothly on my May 14 on Breakaway seems I've been seeing a lot of reviews of everything coming down to being understaffed

alaska1692    7 years ago

I don't understand all the negative reviews, I was on the Breakaway this past December, I don't have one complaint. staff was wonderful, no long lines for drinks, food was great in complimentary and specialty restaurants. Enjoyed the shows. I certainly got my money's worth. Cruise on!!!!

esm54687    7 years ago

- before everyone has a meltdown concerning bonbon326's blanket statement about the "gratuity increase".... understand that the $3.50 increase is only on the Sky and that is NCL's all-inclusive ship.... the Sky's passengers always paid the same as the fleet but didn't pay 18% on any beverages (that other ship's passengers did) so they've been under the radar for a while. The Sky is a little more because it's now including that 18% - the majority of passengers on NCL will see an increase of just $0.49 pp / pd. - Below is the breakdown: Fees for standard cabins and mini-suites will jump from $13.50 to $13.99 per passenger, per day, while cruisers in suites will be charged $16.99 per person, per day, up from $15.50. That amounts to a respective per-person increase of $3.43 or $10.43 per seven-night sailing. The increases will apply to all vessels, with the exception of beverage-inclusive Norwegian Sky. On that ship, cruisers in standard cabins and mini-suites will now pay $18.99 per person, per day, while those in suites will pay $21.99 per person, per day.

JAltmire    7 years ago

I guess this ship is under class for you. we had nothing but an amazing time. you pay for what you pick and sounds like your choices weren't good. lol! good luck finding one up to your standards

bonbon326    7 years ago

the gratuity increase is $3.50 a person for inside rooms thru balconies and a little more for upper class rooms I don't find this expensive considering everything you get. in regards to breakaway i have been on there twice. I agree about the ice bar waste of money. but we have had a great time never had an issue I find its how you think as to whether you have a good time or not. also how you treat the staff is how you will be treated these folks work an average of 7 days a week 12 hrs or more. I find giving a little extra tip and writing good reviews at the resturants goes a long way. anyone can nit pick any thing if these chose to. attitude is everything for God's sake your on vacation for one week you don't have to cook, clean etc.

wl1962    7 years ago

The breakaway is one of the worst ships we have been on Everything is true although we did enjoy tock of ages. We have been in ncl 6 other times and enjoyrd every other ship. Oh by the way have you all seen the gratuity increase ncl just implemented. Bad very bad. Big league bad

KDEES2    7 years ago

Well when a cruise ship says it carries 4,000 passengers, you're gonna be surrounded by 4,000 passengers that maybe smoke, drink, talk loud and form long ling lines to get to different events and dining. Perhaps the "SS Minnow" would be better suited. Just saying.

ICruise4Bacon    7 years ago

Sailed on the Breakaway the past 4 January's. Never experienced anything like this. Guess I won't meet you aboard in Jan 2018 and 2019.

carolrichards01    7 years ago

my 2 favorite ships are the dawn and the spirit. we have done alot of cruising with ncl and have been on the breakaway and the sister ship getaway and they are identical. we were very disappointed with the layout of these ships and we did enjoy the shows. overall these mega ships are massive and the staff as always were always pleasant but I find they need more staff for the amount of people. not the same as a smaller ship or as personal. we are doing are first royal Caribbean Cruise in may the oasis of the seas so its even bigger then the other 2 ncl ships and I am no sure what to expect.

fishface    7 years ago

I imagine as you stumped up two stars there was something positive about your cruise, did you forget what it was?

Other reviews of this sailing