Disappointed in Carnival

Mardi Gras Cruise Review to Caribbean - Eastern

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 19

Overall rating:

2.7 out of 5
Verified Review
Mardi Gras

7 Night Eastern Caribbean (Port Canaveral Roundtrip)

Sail date: December 16, 2023

Ship: Mardi Gras

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 17205

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 10 months ago

Review summary

Never again on Carnival - they nickel and dime you

Embarkation

5 out of 5
It was great because I signed up for the Faster to the Fun program

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

1 out of 5
I had better food at Golden Corral. The buffet had very little variety of food for a ship with 6000 plus people as well as different hours when it was barely open and not to mention that they didn't use the entire buffet. the buffet was dissapointing. the specialty restaurants were terrible - 555 steak house the service was lackluster as the staff looked like they were on their first cruise and very no personable. We felt rushed to get in and out really fast and the atmosphere in there was cold and not warm and romantic at all. the steak was good and I didn't mind the upcharge but the staff made the experience very awkward. the italian specialty was just the same - the staff very cold and uninteresting and the food was cold and bland. the staff were hanging around their station and talking and joking as we were trying to eat. chibang was not very fun at all and very bland and again service was terrible we could never eat in the main dining room because of the 40 to 70 minute wait each night but we tried the breakfast after a 30 minute wait only to be told that we can share a table because there were no little tables available.... however, when walking to our table we noticed 3/4 of the dining room empty and lots of little tables open and even next to our table it was open. then the waiter came to get the drink order, got 4 people out of the 8 and disappeared, then brought coffee for one person, ran out of coffee then disappeared again. we noticed the waiters again huddled around their station looking like they were lost puppies. finally he came took our order and waited a long time for the food which came cold. the only good place we found was the sushi place.. they were fast courteous and efficient the street eats were disappointing as they would not have a good variety and the only one that stayed open all the time was the high dollar seafood one - imagine that .. the high dollar paid one stayed open the longest guys burgers was ok bbq buffet was ok as well but again staff not very personable

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5
we could never get to any because of the wind - and the pools were crowded

Entertainment

1 out of 5
I have to say, that they need to make some changes but I feel it's too late. they have everything so tightly arranged that if you are in the comedy show, they have music playing right outside the door in the next venue. when we were at the brass magnolia listening to jazz across the hall they had a guy playing the guitar which basically drowned each other out the main stage being in the middle of the ship and trying to watch a show while kids and adults walking behind you talking and yelling was unique and not very pleasing

Children's Programs

no kids with us

Service and Staff

1 out of 5
Our Room Steward was fantastic!! very personable and very courteous, not to mention very knowledgeable. the Bartenders at Brass Magnolia were top notch and very efficient everyone else was terrible. no fun waiters and even the management seemed lackluster. i didn't see any management that was on top of anything like you see on other ships also this ship had something weird.. they allow the staff to get in line with the guests and basically cut in front of you to get condiments, etc.. in fact they received better service than the guests. the lady on the room service phone was cold and very unfriendly in fact 99% of the staff looked miserable and very not well managed

Ship Quality

2 out of 5
the design is very confusing and not well laid out. the ship was clean and well maintained but then again.. its a new ship

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
The balcony was our only escape on this ship as it offered better access to the outside than anywhere on the ship. the room was clean and the size was perfect for us

Ship tip

If you love Walmart then go on this cruise because they make you feel like you are at walmart

Ports of call

Port Canaveral, Florida

4 out of 5
easy to get to

San Juan, Puerto Rico

4 out of 5
it was nice to be close to the forts

Amber Cove (Puerto Plata), Dominican Republic

5 out of 5
the tour of the rum factory and cigar was outstanding.. they did a good job on this tour

Grand Turk Island

1 out of 5
beach was crowded and we got ripped off getting a chair and tent as we were walked far then the guy dissapeared

Disembarkation

5 out of 5
the faster to the fun makes this super easy
Was this review helpful? 19

10 Comments

browns1     10 months ago

Are you sure you were on a cruise. Maybe you were at Walmart.

steve126     10 months ago

I guess I missed the nickel and dime part since most of the specialty dining is included on this ship. Your review is completely opposite of my experience during spring break, which was equally as crowded.

sfcvan     10 months ago

Well, with Karen's, they do expect more and believe the staff is their personal wait staff. I guess since you compared it to Walmart, you shop there. Goodbye, and I hope to never see you on a cruise. I hope you didn't complain to your friends and family while cruising, because I'm looking for their reviews about the complaining friend or relative who made their cruise horrible.

javawoody     10 months ago

Wow, experience is different from many others

Gwbigdog     10 months ago

Thanks for sharing

Niavlys     10 months ago

Yet another bad comment on Carnival...

lsbs     10 months ago

Thanks for the review.

Mmjay     10 months ago

Is there such a thing where any cruise lines do not nickle and dime passengers? If there are any cruise lines do not, then they are sure to be really expensive.

Lawnboy1956     10 months ago

When you’re cruising at Christmas, you have to expect crowds and poor weather. You like the Carnival pricing but unfairly call them Wal-Mart when we all shop there. If you did some research you could have found a cruise line that better suited your expectations but it would cost more, I suspect you already know that.

cruising2004     10 months ago

Thanks for your review.

Other reviews of this sailing