Mildly Entertaining

Celebrity Reflection Cruise Review to Caribbean - Bahamas

Cruises: 2-3 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 11

Overall rating:

3.7 out of 5
Verified Review
Celebrity Reflection

3 Night Bahamas & Perfect Day (Ft. Lauderdale Roundtrip)

Sail date: July 05, 2024

Ship: Celebrity Reflection

Cabin type: Balcony

Cabin number: 6238

Traveled as: Family (older children)

Reviewed: 4 months ago

Review summary

While we might consider Celebrity for future sailings, awareness of what not to expect for ship entertainment and misrepresented shore excursions will be on the agenda prior to sailing.

Embarkation

5 out of 5
Fast and Friendly

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
Selection lacked what was experienced on another cruise line. Basic offerings repeated daily

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5
Pools were overcrowded and only the fee entry places of solace were available. The basketball court was used by the on-board babysitting services and did not notice scant games on decks being played by cruise attendees.

Entertainment

3 out of 5
Shows were akin to high school musicals; and the "magic show" was seen at our local library performance.

Service and Staff

5 out of 5

Ship Quality

4 out of 5
The staff worked hard, but were no match for cruisers who utilized stateroom hallways as personal trash cans for many drink glasses and trash.

Cabin / Stateroom

4 out of 5
The staff maintained the cabin in excellent condition and were working very hard to complete the tasks given in the brief amount of time they had to service each room.

Ship tip

Price reflects the quality of the cruise and is worth the trip

Ports of call

Ft. Lauderdale (Port Everglades), Florida

4 out of 5

Perfect Day At Coco Cay, Bahamas

5 out of 5
Maintained in great shape, and the efforts to renovate the services on the island were well received by the guests! Schedule all of your shore excursions for this port, as you will be sorely disappointed with Nassau!

Nassau, Bahamas

1 out of 5
Swimming with the pigs excursion was a great disappointment as the tour lists five hours total, but is misrepresented. Customers are taken to "Pearl Island" which is an extremely narrow strip of dirt with ONE unmaintained cement walking path with room for two people to walk side by side only. The toilet accommodations are akin to porta potties, with doors shortened to the point of open viewing to the activity therein. Passengers are expected to either sun on the limited number of chairs available, use the worn paddleboards/canoes or swim in the limited bay area (which appears to have nothing like the amenities at Coco Cay). Expected to be waiting for your boat transfer to yet another strip of dirt for the swimming with the pigs activity, you cannot be late, but the driver may just "forget" to pick up your party for over a half an hour as was what happened with our experience, as everyone was waiting in the very hot sun. With the tour scheduled during the lunch hour, we were only then told was a 45 minute "swim," which left customers questioning how the tour and the same time lunch were to occur if both coincided. The answer from a member of the staff was that we should have eaten earlier, and needed to meet our leaving shuttle on time, no exceptions. So, customers ate breakfast on the ship, between 7-8 am before the tour, then were expected to eat a 10:30 am lunch? Not happening... When the shuttle boat finally arrived, the passengers were taken around the neighboring island, and expected to walk a boarded path, single file, to where the pigs were housed in a wood pallet enclosure, crowded, in the searing heat, awaiting snacks. The tour operators then gave each customer a clear plastic cup with 3-4 pieces of cut apple, with a wood skewer and directions to feed the pigs, before entering the water themselves with large buckets of food and mush. Naturally, the pigs swam to the tour operators, and customers had to chase down the pigs to even feed them, winding their way around the staff who held a pool leaf strainer to pick up feces in the water. The shores of the "island" were extremely rocky, so be warned, and wear water shoes to prevent cuts and scrapes. The event is called swimming with the pigs, but should read, "get in the water to feed 3 apple pieces to pigs, then get out" It was after this brief encounter that the water shuttle was directed to bring the craft to the exact area where the pigs were, noting we didn't have to walk the boarded path back to the opposite side, though no explanation was given for why that direction wasn't chosen prior. Back at "Pearl Island," guests headed towards the "buffet" lunch which consisted of placing foods (mushy brown rice with scant beans; soaked vegetable blend of cauliflower/carrots/zucchini; one chicken drumstick; and a few pieces of what was to be fried fish, with the outer portion falling off due to the boiling effect), from the chafing dishes, onto paper plates. The drink consisted of plastic cups, half filled with luke warm water, and the direction to only take ONE! Terrible. Many passengers waited to board the cruise ship to obtain actual food. One passenger asked for ice from the bar, and was given it, but when another approached a few minutes later, was told that they charge $1 for the same product! And yes, that comment was indicative of the staff on "Pearl Island" who were seen drunk, making comments to people walking the cement sidewalk, and having no sympathy for time constraints. To Celebrity: please seriously consider another off shore tour and place of such, as "Pearl Island" was a total BOMB!

Disembarkation

5 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 11

9 Comments

connectr     4 months ago

Celebrity is not the problem here, it is Nassau

dlwatkins4     4 months ago

I thought it was a great, honest and I thoroughly enjoyed the comments about the “Swim with the Pigs”. Also someone commented on Celebrity Reflections 3/4 day cruises…I too wonder why Celebrity spends so much time on these 3/4 days cruises and when they should be doing 7 days cruises on this large ship. How about it Celebrity!

Gwbigdog     4 months ago

Thanks for sharing

javawoody     4 months ago

Appreciate the review

Flcruisepro     4 months ago

I always pass on the swimming with pig poo excursions. After 4 recent cruises on Reflection, I agree that the food is repetative and gets old fast. The buffet has too few options for what I call edible food. And the 3 night cruises are just drunken party cruises. Hardly what you would expect from Celebrity.

cruising2004     4 months ago

Sorry the cruise and excursions were not up to par.

TiffyTaffy     4 months ago

Thanks for the review.

CruzeFan     4 months ago

Glad you enjoyed most of it. Independent excursions are usually a better option than those through the ship. Online reviews and YouTube videos are a much better indicator of what to expect on any excursion than what is listed in the description.

HeavySeas     4 months ago

Thanks for sharing your cruise experience

Other reviews of this sailing