Anthem may be non-traditional but she delivers a great vacation experience

Anthem of the Seas Cruise Review to Caribbean - Bahamas

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Reviews: 8
Helpful Votes: 174

Overall rating:

4 out of 5
Anthem of the Seas

7 Night Bahamas (Cape Liberty Roundtrip)

Sail date: December 09, 2016

Ship: Anthem of the Seas

Cabin type: Suite

Cabin number: 10363

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

It has been over a month since our cruise and I forgot to do a review.  Well, here it is.  I'll say that we had a great vacation, although I need to frame that by saying we've never had a bad cruise vacation.  We picked Anthem because we have read so many great and awful reviews - we had to do it ourselves to make our own opinion.  I can now say that most of the negative posts I don't agree with.  Yes, the ship has idiosyncrasies and you need to expect them when you cruise.  If you aren't open minded or if you expect the ship to be like "traditional" ships, then maybe this isn't the vacation for you. For everyone else, you'll have a great time.

 

The ship leaves from a port that is only a 5 hour drive for us, so we could save airfare, which is a big plus. Embarkation was non-traditional (I may be using that word a lot) as there were no queues - just passengers clustered around staff armed with iPads.  While that caused me anxiety, I will admit that it was the fastest and simplest check-in ever.

 

On ship we explored.  It is a modern-looking ship with no chrome or neon (thank goodness).  We had a junior suite and the cabin was great - perhaps the best room we have had on any cruise.  Our room attendant found us quickly and was very friendly and personable.  That is a great way to start a vacation.

 

For us, the positives were the public areas, especially two70.  Sea Plex is great, the game-show type entertainments were great and the staff almost everywhere were helpful.  We found We Will Rock You to be solid and the iFly and North Star to be unique experiences. The negatives were, for us, included the food: we just didn't think there were any memorable meals at any of the venues.  Everything was well plated and service was quick, and you won't starve on this ship, but the taste was average.  Our best meal was probably at Jamie's (but noway worth $35) and the eggs we got at the Pub.  Our expectations for VOOM were high but found internet speeds to be slower than home and very spotty, with us being cut off more than a few times during the week.  We also didn't care for the Spectra or the Gift, but that is personal preference.  Also, we won't do a cold weather trip again any time soon, it was hard to enjoy the open air during the chilly days (but that isn't a fault of the cruise).  Finally, as reported by others there were almost always a line at Guest Service.

 

The takeaway for us?  We enjoyed something new and had a great vacation.  It wasn't our favorite vacation, mainly due to the chilly weather at the beginning and end of the cruise.  It also isn't our favorite ship.  Still, the fact that this beautiful ship is near our home is super and economical and we'll be on her again.

 

This ship is non traditional in that you really need to book all that you can in advance, else you may not get what you want on board.  For us that is fine as we like to plan, however, the Cruise Planner on the Royal Caribbean web site was inconsistent, with some activities being listed, others were not but would later appear.  If they could get the Cruise Planner to be fully loaded and smooth, things would be great.  Instead, you're finding yourself checking the planner very often,  making sure that you don't miss the opportunity to book something. 

 

After the learning curve you'll find yourself counting the days until your next Anthem cruise.

 

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
The food was average but we were hoping for a bit more. The plating was great but the items didn't have memorable flavor (our opinion).

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5
The ship's signature activities were great but, ouside of traditional trvia, there weren't many smaller, pop-up events during the day.

Entertainment

3 out of 5
This is a personal preferance - we didn't like the Gift nor Spectra's but most others were fine. It was my first time watching Dancing with the Stripes and it was a riot.

Service and Staff

5 out of 5
For us, we found most of the crew were friendly on this ship. Wendy, our room attendant was interactive and happy and she made our vacation great.

Ship Quality

5 out of 5
The ship was very clean and the public areas were great.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Having a split bathroom was simply great whicj helped to make this room one of our favorite rooms we ever had. The décor is simple yet still clean and modern. There were no drawers, which is interesting although I can see drawer pulls to be something else they need to sanitize often. There were enough outlets, which was nice.

Ship tip

Don't miss their game show-themed events, like Name That Tune, Dancing with the Stripes and Love and Marriage. They are fun to watch.

Ports of call

Cape Liberty (Bayonne), New Jersey

2 out of 5
Disembarkation in below-freezing temps isn't a great way to end a vaction, especially if you have a long wait outside for transportation

Cococay (Cruise Line's Private Island)

2 out of 5
We have been to Coco many times but never when they had low tide. Having the tide out was a neagtive for us.

Traveler Photos

From the North Star The iFly was fun NYC on embarkation day, Anthem of the Seas
Was this review helpful? 59

4 Comments

Happy82    7 years ago

We are going on the Anthem end of May, it's usually at least 24 degrees out so hoping it won't be cold on first and last day.

Definitely won't be freezing!

pmall02    7 years ago

Thanks for the review. I appreciate your honesty! I sail in 18 days and have found that this has been a learning experience ( especially the cruise planner...). Reading reviews and posts on this app has helped a lot ( a lot more than my travel agent!!😝). I can't wait to see for myself!!

Nancy34    7 years ago

Windjam064    7 years ago

Whew - what a run-on paragraph! I wrote this on Cruise Critic but I guess those posts get automatically copied to Ship Mate but without the paragraph breaks. Sorry it came out this way-

Other reviews of this sailing