Carnival Magic
Sail date: September 04, 2011
Excellent ship; well thought out functionality; Operationally very efficient - embarkation, debarkation, excursion egress/ingress, and good (but not overbearing) communication by the Cruise Director.
Plenty of amenities - could always find something to do and/or quiet space.
Serenity Deck - good concept that is frequently oversubscribed; in spite of crew members doing a good job enforcing the rules.
Smoking on-board is only real negative with this (Carnival) ship(s).