Disappointed

Carnival Liberty Cruise Review to Caribbean - Western

Cruises: 2-3 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 24

Overall rating:

2 out of 5
Verified Review
Carnival Liberty

5 Night Western Caribbean (Galveston Roundtrip)

Sail date: November 26, 2016

Ship: Carnival Liberty

Cabin type: Inside

Cabin number: 2311

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

Best part was meeting new friends; however... There were several minor/major issues that made this particular sailing a disappointment. We understood that they were cancelling a port and we were fine with that. We were fine having nearly $400 of OBC and were happy that it would be on our Sail and Sign account when we boarded the ship (that is what we were told multiple times on the phone by several Carnival employees), but that isn't what happened we only had $75 ($50 from Carnival for our booking and $25 from ). We didn't get the rest of our money until until LATE the second sea day. However, they sold us by saying we would get more time on the ship on debarkation day (instead of early morning it would be later in the afternoon. They took the long way around to get to Cozumel for the first day so we arrived early evening leaving not much to do if you're not a drinker or a party goer. Our second day on our excursion we found out that Carnival will not allow them to serve shots (tequila, Fireball, mixed shots). We paid for all you can drink (not that we do lots of shots or drink a lot), a shot is still a drink. The description of the excursion did not provide a disclaimer of shots not being included or not allowed. We were celebrating our 12th anniversary and we were given a $50 spa credit. That is nice if there were something we could do at the spa. This is a terrible marketing scheme. If Carnival really wanted to do something special for people celebrating a special occasion (as long as mentioned at time of booking) a photo or a discount from from Pixels or something would be more appreciated. This tells me that Carnival didn't really want to do something nice for us, instead they wanted to gain from our very special occasion and that isn't acceptable. The hot tubs seemed to have problems throughout the cruise. There was a time when the hot tub was way too hot (I love a good hot tub), you could have poached eggs in it and many people were getting out because of the temperature. Then the hot tubs on Serenity deck just stopped working all together. We asked the crew to get someone to fix it and they didn't care (one even shrugged his shoulders and walked away). We called and still no sense of urgency to fix the problem (this is what I was looking forward to, getting away from the kids and talk with adults while relaxing). By the time it was fixed a heavy rain storm came through. Then there was the food... I've cruised on Carnival before and the food wasn't too bad, this time around food was sub-par most nights. I've had weight loss surgery and wanted to pre-plan my lunches (I knew I could find something at breakfast and dinner even if I had to eat the same thing everyday). I saw on the website that Fish & Chips was available and they had a steamed mix among a few other healthier things. I got on board to find out that had been replaced with a BBQ place that is the equivalent to eating at Luby's or Golden Corral (As a Texan, this is not good BBQ) and the seafood was now a place that required one to pay. Most days I didn't eat lunch because I can't have salad as it hurts my new stomach. Most everything is carbs and dishes covered in sauces. For the MDR we called to see if they could give me smaller portions so food didn't go to waste and I wasn't tempted to eat too much and they said "Yes, just tell your Head waiter and they will accommodate you." That is not what happened, they said no and gave me full size portions.  Lastly, this cruise seemed to have a lack of activities. On my last two cruises (7 day on Magic and 5 day on Triumph) there was always something to do and almost always had to pick one thing over the other, this was not the case this cruise. We really did love meeting new people and will likely plan a group cruise with some of them. Our room steward, Asep, was great and always greeted us with a smile. My husband and I believe that Carnival should do something to make up for our experience. We don't normally take time to complain because we rarely have complaints, this cruise just didn't make the cut and left us very disappointed to say the least.

 

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
Sub-par most times, had to pay for lunch (instead of the free seafood as listed on website). Need a healthier free variety besides salad.

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5
Not many activities there were large gaps of time in between where there was nothing but the pools/hot tubs/tanning. We like the water activities but also enjoy doing stuff when there is stuff to do indoors.

Entertainment

3 out of 5
Just okay. Theater, I fell asleep to their dancing/singing around the world. I LOVE theater, but this was a disappointment.

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
Asep was AMAZING!!! Staff was fair, breakfast waiter on last day was rude and after asked to bring creamer nicely 3 times he brought it back and slammed it on the table.

Ship Quality

1 out of 5
Problems before sailing and obvious problems while on board. Rusted around pool areas making it look dirty. Dining rooms look outdated.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Asep was SUPER AWESOME! Always had a smile for us! The room was as expected for an interior. The only downside was one mirror has a decorative glass light on it making the mirror pretty much useless.

Ship tip

Carnival should charge less for pictures or revise their contract with Pixels A) they force you to buy an 8X10 if taken in that size B) They don't resize They should load pictures digitally instead of wasting paper and allow passengers to buy later Alcohol on ship is very weak.

Ports of call

Cozumel, Mexico

3 out of 5
Casa En La Playa - A Select Retreat is Amazing and the water is BEAUTIFUL! It's a must! Staff is great too!

Traveler Photos

First Day on board!
Was this review helpful? 24

Be the first to comment

Other reviews of this sailing