Since I spent a bunch of time in there recently, I went and looked at some old reviews of ships I hadn't been on in a while..some of which Ive actually cruised on more than once. Most of them have been refurbed, and some more than once. My memory may not be perfect, but as usual, I wondered if the reviewer was even on the same ship. Crews change, both hotel and ship side..cooks, guest services, stewards, all of them, get rotated from ship to ship or simply replaced.
So the question is, at what point does a review actually become out of date? Five years, ten, never?