Good, but not great

Oasis of the Seas Cruise Review to Caribbean - Eastern

Experience: 7+ cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 0

Overall Rating:

3 out of 5
Sail Date: February 01, 2010
Ship: Oasis of the Seas
Cabin Type: Balcony
Traveled As: Couple
Reviewed: 8 years ago
Having cruised before on RC, Celebrity, Disney and Carnival... I have to say this cruise was only "average". I am highlighting a lot of the negatives with hope that they will be improved, but please do not think that the cruise was "bad"... it was good, it just wasn't great; so if you get a good deal and want to just chill on a big boat, this cruise may be perfect for you. The Spa - The Spa was terrible, avoid it! For being one of the biggest cruise ships in the world, the Spa seemed like an afterthought. First the treatments were all premium priced, not bad in and of itself, but it set expectations high. $120 for 50 minutes isn't exactly cheap, but its not ridiculous either. What was a shocker is that this DID NOT include access to the steam rooms! That costs another $30. I have never heard of a Spa that didn't offer a "Day Pass" with their treatments. The steam room area could apparently only hold 30 people, and I will say it was tinny! It had 1 dry room, 2 rain showers, 2 steam rooms and 4 heat beds. There were only 8 people in there when I went and it felt full. This to me is a joke, other ships (including from RC) have included the Steam room and the rooms were bigger. Each actual steam room on the Oasis could only sit about 4 comfortably. There also were not enough lockers went. My treatment was great, I had 50 minutes of Reflexology and it put me to sleep (good!) but at the end they gave me the hard sell of body detoxification mumbo jumbo. The therapist said based on my feet reading, I needed to spend $150 to $200 a month for 6 months to clean my system. I did the polite No thank you and she continued, I did the polite I will think about it and she continued, I looked ready to walk out and she continued and then stopped. As I was checking out, I saw what appeared to be the head therapist berating some poor guy over the head with how much he needed to buy the treatments, how diet and exercise for him, simply were not enough. The cure, of course was $200 a month in pills and baths for 6-12 months. I could hear the annoyance in the guys voice. So to sum it up, the Spa sucked and only made things worse, by trying to up sell me and others every chance they got. The Casino and Poker This casino came with 3 fully automated poker tables (no dealer). While I missed having a dealer and the feel of chips in my hand, you get used to it. Thats not really the problem though, the problem is that rake (or what the house takes each pot). The rake payout was not clearly posted and based on what I and others saw was approximately 10-15% up to $10 per hand. For anyone that plays poker, this is HIGH (way high). May casinos only take $4 or $5. So at this table, the average game was playing 8 handed, with the average buy in of $100 (it was rare to have people buy in for $200 or more). This means that at any one time, there is about $800 at the table. With the average pot being about $100 and the average hand taking 3 minutes the table looses $10 every 3 minutes to the house! So with players just trying to have a good time, over the course of an hour the rake was taking out 2 players per hour - 60/3 = 20 * $10 = $200! It is amazing at how fast this killed the action at the tables and how much fun this took from the experience. I am a big poker fan and so were the 50 or so regulars that were in the casino each night. Me not being able to have fun playing poker on this trip definitely reduced my overall fun on the trip. To the bean counters at RC, this fun tax on the poker game cost you easily 3 drinks a night from me and based on my conversations the same from the other 10-15 people I spoke with. So the $200 rake instead of a $100 rake, actually cost you at least $300+ in bar tabs.

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
The Food The food was average at best. We have dinned on Carnival, RC, Disney and Celebrity before and I frankly expected RC to be better than Carnival when it came to food it wasnt. I am not one of those people that is overly finicky or pretentious and the food was good. It just wasnt as good as I remember our last RC cruise being, or our Celebrity cruise or our last Carnival cruise. They also didnt have a flaming dessert or baked Alaska two staples of cruising IMO. The Drinks The drinks were average, they didnt carry my favorite vodka Ciroc.


3 out of 5
The Shows and Activities All were very good! Hair Spray was definitely Broadway quality and I personally liked Oasis of Dreams better than O in Vegas. FlowRider was a lot of fun. The zip line wasnt as cool as other reviews made it sound. The only ding is that they budget for Karaoke was apparently small (the staff even joked about it). The list of songs that were NOT available would surprise any Karaoke regular.

Service and Staff

5 out of 5
The Staff 99% of the staff was excellent and frankly saved the cruise for me. The only exceptions were our main dining room bartender; he wasnt fun at all. The other was our Head Waiter. To be frank, now that we have assigned tables, assigned times and so many other choices for dining, I dont know what this guy did for me other than waste 30 seconds of my time, every other night to remind me he existed.

Ship Quality

3 out of 5
The ship / staterooms All very nice, very cool, very clean, very modern. Despite its sizing and having everything, this ship didnt have a cigar lounge. I smoke a cigar maybe once every 2 years, and on a boat in, on vacation, with friends is definitely a time that I like to do it. THE CROWDS The ship is BIG (BIG) and is very, very cool. But I feel size is hitting a point of diminishing returns. This ship is 220k tons and supports (based on specs and what I overheard from staff) ~6000 guests; while a Voyager class ship (my last RC cruise) is 138k tons with approximately 3000 guests. This means that on the older ship, each guest got ~46 tons to them self, while on the Oasis, each guest only gets 37 tons to their self. So size is up, but the guest count feels to have gone up faster. If you dont like crowds, this isnt the ship for you.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5

Pros: The staff, the ship, the shows

Cons: The Spa, The Casino, The Crowds

Recommends Oasis of the Seas? No.

Was this review helpful? 6

Leave a Comment

Remember: Be polite and respectful. Our diverse community is home to members with different opinions and a broad range of cruise experiences.

* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top