Worst Vacation

Carnival Liberty Cruise Review to Caribbean - Southern

Cruises: 4-6 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 64

Overall rating:

1 out of 5
Verified Review
Carnival Liberty

12 Night Southern Caribbean Carnival Journeys (San Juan To Galveston)

Sail date: March 06, 2016

Ship: Carnival Liberty

Cabin type: Oceanview

Cabin number: 1359

Traveled as: Singles/Friends

Reviewed: 8 years ago

Review summary

Carnival Liberty, Puerto Rico

 Sail Date March 6, 2016

 

Served bacteria and mold contaminated water and under-cooked chicken, as well as loud construction noises outside my stateroom at 5 A.M. resulting in lack of sleep. These events have tainted my cruising experience aboard Carnival anytime in the future.

The first day of the cruise, I ate fish and chicken tacos.  The chicken was under cooked for lunch and tasted bad so I stopped eating it.  I wound up going back to the room early that night and vomiting all night long. Since Carnival was not enforcing the use of hand sanitizer prior to going to the buffet, I thought it would be safer to start ordering room service.  I would order hot tea; it took me a couple of times receiving the tea to realize that the pots smelled like feces and were corroded with bacteria and mold.  I brought one of the pots up to management, and they told me it was a fluke.  Meanwhile, I had another pot in my room that was the exact same.  Management then apologized and admitted that these pots should have never made it to my room, but in the meantime my boyfriend's and my entire 12 day trip was ruined. I asked that they keep the pots as evidence and they swore that they would, but discarded them and the water that was in them; therefore, I had no evidence.  However, I was able to take pictures of the contaminated pots.  I don’t have the pots only pictures of them after they were somewhat cleaned and returned to me by Carnival. They promised they wouldn't do that or discard of them but they threw one away and rinsed the other one out. Although they discarded them they admitted I should never have received them but said there is no proof that is why I was sick.

 

I was supposed to be sharing a room with the female of the party, while my boyfriend was sharing another room with his buddy.  Because I was so sick my boyfriend had to pay out extra money to the girl I was sharing a room with because she and I had a more expensive room and he was forced to stay with me to take care of me.  Before we realized what was going on with the room service, he had tea with me and was soon also sick. My boyfriend had to be in the room with me so much that he was barely able to use his alcohol package that he paid extra for.

We notified the infirmary of what transpired and that we had food poisoning; they said they would only treat us if they quarantined us.  We were only asking for Pepto Bismol and Imodium.  We told them we did not want to be quarantined and then they said “okay, then we can't give you anything”.  If it was mandatory we be quarantined, why did they allow us to leave and wander the ship?  This is very disturbing!!

On top of all of this, at 5 AM the last 3 or 4 days of the trip the crew started doing work on the ship right outside our stateroom that was extremely loud.  I complained to Tina in Guest Services and she kept telling me they never received the complaint; so I started calling every 15 minutes.

Guest Services was extremely rude on this ship.  More often than not they had an “Oh Well” attitude.

 

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

1 out of 5
The servers in the dining room were nice but the food was terrible

Onboard Activities

3 out of 5
if there was a seminar going on inside they would have it on the speaker and tv outside instead of fun music. If I wanted to go to the seminar, I would have.

Entertainment

3 out of 5

Service and Staff

1 out of 5
Guest Services was terrible. Others were ok except those making loud drilling noises at 5am outside our room and would not stop.

Ship Quality

3 out of 5
Design was nice Cleanliness was terrible. The pool by the slide smelled like urine the entire time. The room could have been cleaner. They did not enforce individual use hand sanitizer. The pots of water were corroded with mold and bacteria and smelled like feces.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Cabin was a outside window cabin and was very nice. It could have been cleaner.

Ship tip

The blow dryers are terrible.

Traveler Photos

Part of the water pot
Was this review helpful? 64

17 Comments

sunnyskies67    8 years ago

Was on this cruise too. Hubby got the 'virus' and self quarantined and drank only canned soda the day we should have been ashore in Aruba. There were MANY people with stomach issues on this sailing. It was odd that it seemed to be just one in most couples get ill. That seemed more food than virus related. The next sailing went out late. I'm guessing Liberty got a thorough cleaning.

aDudley    8 years ago

Some are never happy.

ARLady    8 years ago

I'm very sorry you had such a bad experience. We have cruised with several lines and Carnival is our favorite. What I find most disturbing about your post is that you think the hand sanitizer would have been a miracle worker. That stuff is killing everything inside of you that fights germs. Wash your hands with soap and water and never use that stuff!

ischycr    8 years ago

I am so sorry others are replying with negative and mean comments. You are just reporting your experience and trying to inform others what to look out for. I thank you. I will now be more observant of the food and containers they come in.

livewire03    8 years ago

Sounds like maybe someone wants a carnival kick back.

ajont    8 years ago

I think u had a virus. Sorry u had a bad experience, but u really have no prove that carnival was responsible.

showboat    8 years ago

Sounds like high maintenance to me!!!

showboat    8 years ago

Sounds like high maintenance to me!!!

jordan11898    8 years ago

I was on that cruise also. And yes others were getting sick, but it's not from contaminated water and moldy pots. Don't believe it. Every cruise I have been on everything is cleaned to perfection. It only takes a couple sick people to spread something around by not taking care of hand washing and then touching everything. And if you do get sick they need to stay away until they are better.

teddygoogs    8 years ago

No pictures....hmm what a surprise. SMH

lisalu    8 years ago

Service wasn't much better on the paradise it took 3 hours to get served in the elation dining room with few choices and minimal amount served plus no one came to get our drink order. Sorry you had a bad time. I've sailed on carnival 5 times and this was the worst cruise for me. Gonna use royal Caribbean Cruise line in future they was awesome last year

jmarie2731    8 years ago

What a horrible experience! Kitchen staff must be really angry to be serving such terrible food and using dirty pots. No sympathy from customer service. All afraid for their jobs. On a positive note....at least you all must have strong constitutions, you survived! I wish you fantastic future vacations.

TNTGreen    8 years ago

I agree with Mikedebb; a lot of others would of had the same experience not just 1 isolated incident so it must of been a virus in your system prior to cruising(I'm also a doctor). Whenever you travel in the future especially outside the US you should always pack a "meds" bag with the basic Tylenol, motion sickness medication or bands, digestive medication. It's more difficult &expensive abroad

joeeel    8 years ago

I cruised on it on May 2015 & it was wonderful, no complaints, food was amazing, staff lovely, the ship was amazing! Sorry you had that experience

ericke    8 years ago

Girl, bye!

debbmike    8 years ago

I would think almost everyone on the ship would have been sick if it was because of contaminated water and the chicken.

noffsinger2001    8 years ago

How do you know it was from the food and water?? You could of had the flu before your cruise and it did not hit you till then. Everyone always blames the ship

Other reviews of this sailing