Overcharging Customers on Celebrity Cruises and How to Avoid Overpaying

Celebrity Edge Cruise Review to Hawaii

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 11

Overall rating:

4.2 out of 5
Celebrity Edge

Hawaii

Sail date: May 01, 2024

Ship: Celebrity Edge

Cabin type: Inside

Cabin number: 11166

Traveled as: Couple

Reviewed: 6 months ago

Review summary

I am repeating here the lengthy comment I made else were in this review: Rip-off Cruise Prices and How to Avoid Them-Beware of Royal Caribbean and Celebrity Recently, I went on a Celebrity Cruise. Before making the final payment for the cruise, I did my usual check and found that a lot of cabins were still available. As a person who has been on 75 plus cruises, wrote a dissertation on travel agencies, and teaches the Cruise Ship Management/Marketing course at my University, I am quite aware of the cruise lines marketing practices. So, I did the usual thing and checked to ensure there would not be a price drop after the final payment. This was checked directly with the cruise line, and guess what? They lied to the travel agency and me! Further, they would not make any accommodation to make up for the overpayment. In this case, the overpayment was over $1,200. The one other time I had this happen for a lower amount was with Norwegian Cruise Line and they offered me a future cruise credit or a cabin upgrade. After many runs around, Celebrity would do nothing. I also found on the cruise that many people had the same story. I would say it was at least 25 percent of the passengers but it may have been a lot more as just people I asked at random amounted to much more than 25%. Cruise lines overprice things, and then when they go into non-refundable fare periods, which are usually 120 days before the cruise, they tend to drop the price due to unsold cabins. This is largely due to the fact that some of them do not have good capacity controls, and from what I have seen, Royal Caribbean and Celebrity are the biggest culprits. (Capacity controls are statistically calculable and are used by most travel companies, including airlines, hotels, etc.) Often with other travel products, you get a better price if you book early! Many other companies, such as Delta Airlines, always give you a credit for a future flight (always frequently check the fares for airline tickets after your initial booking) and if you do not pay for a rental car in advance (I advise not to pay for any rental car in advance unless it is a huge bargain) it is often that if you start checking about a week before your rental, you will find a price drop. From my experience, Gate 1 Travel and Virgin Cruises have excelled with the concept of pricing correctly early on and then raising the prices rather than lowering them. Many others do much better than RCL/Celebrity. Other cruise lines price things accurately and, therefore, do not have these problems with filling the ship. Carnival, NCL, and MSC, from what I have experienced, are not as guilty, and clearly, Virgin is the champion at not doing this. On Virgin , I booked a cruise months prior to departure, and they gave me a lot of perks and the best price. The price included $700 worth of bar purchases for a seven-day cruise. I think I will be buying drinks for a lot of cruisers! As a result of the Celebrity debacle, I will never book an RCL or Celebrity cruise before 120 days prior to the departure of the cruise. If we all do this, they will be forced to stop screwing people who are loyal to them and book cruises far in advance. Celebrity also tends to tout you with what are really non-bargains to book again while you are on the ship. Other cruise lines try to get you to book another cruise while on the ship but are usually offering a better deal! It is pretty easy to see if a price drop will or is likely to happen. Go on the site of the cruise line or any of the online agencies and try to book it about 125 days out. They will show you the cabins that are available in each class of cabin, so it will take a while to get a good picture of what is happening. If you see many cabins still available, you should probably not make your final payment and cancel your reservation. Usually, there is no penalty for doing this or very little. (Incidentally, when you make the original booking, make sure there is no penalty for canceling within 120 days before the cruise. Sometimes, the cruise line does this to try to lock you into the reservation further.) Also, be more cautious when booking any cruise that is ten days or more because these are the ones that sometimes have booking problems simply because not everyone in the population can afford to take this amount of time off. If you see many cabins left, drop any reservation you may have had and look forward to the price drop. If the price does not drop on the cruise you booked, you can rebook it or just pick from the many other last-minute availabilities that are out there.

Embarkation

5 out of 5

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

3 out of 5
Food was below average overall. Late night food was poor and the buffet food quality was fair. Celebrity and Royal Caribbean need to learn how to make pizza!

Onboard Activities

5 out of 5
Pools and onboard activities were good. The Cruise Director was excellent. Jogging track is probably the best of any cruise line and gym is excellent.

Entertainment

5 out of 5
One the Royal and Celebrity excel in is entertainment.

Children's Programs

3 out of 5
Children's program is available and good, however, this ship lacks anything that kids would like in terms of facilities. As such, it is not recommended for families with kids. I believe that is more or less by design. Entertainment was excellent and lower rating here is due to the fact that this is not a good ship for kids.

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
The dining room and staff were excellent. The captain was very personable, except he lied to us about why, at the last minute, we had to skip circumnavigating Kauai. This was actually due to him bringing the ship too close to the shore and not the stated "environmental reasons". The incident was reported widely on the news. Also, like many cruise lines, when a problem occurs I was given a big run around about the amount that I was tricked into overpaying for this cruise.

Ship Quality

5 out of 5
The thing that goes up and down on the side of the ship rarely moves. It was used for a tender dock, which was very good, and the lifeboats are very big, which makes tendering easy. However, I am not sure the expense of that is really worth it. The rest of the ship is very adult-oriented and has more pool space and hot tubs than most ships.

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
Cabin is about as perfect as it can be.

Ship tip

Rip-off Cruise Prices and How to Avoid Them-Beware of Royal Caribbean and Celebrity Recently I went on this Celebrity Cruise. Before making the final payment for the cruise, I did my usual check and found that a lot of cabins were still available. As a person who has been on 75 plus cruises, wrote a dissertation on travel agencies, and teaches the Cruise Ship Management/Marketing course at my University, I am quite aware of the cruise lines marketing practices. So, I did the usual thing and checked to make sure there would not be a price drop after the final payment. This was checked directly with the cruise line, and guess what? They lied to the travel agency and me! Further, they would not make any accommodation to make up for the overpayment. In this case, the overpayment was over $1,500. The one other time I had this happen for a lower amount was with Norwegian Cruise Line and they offered me a future cruise credit or a cabin upgrade. After many runs around, Celebrity would do nothing. I also found on the cruise that many people had the same story. I would say it was at least 25 percent of the passengers, but may have been a lot more as just people I asked at random amounted to much more than 25%. Cruise lines overprice things, and then when they go into non-refundable fare periods, which are usually 120 days before the cruise, they tend to drop the price due to unsold cabins. This is largely due to the fact that some of them do not have good capacity controls, and from what I have seen, Royal Caribbean and Celebrity are the biggest culprits. (Capacity controls are statistically calculable and are used by most travel companies, including airlines, hotels, etc.) Often with other travel products, you get a better price if you book early! Many other companies such as Delta Airlines always gives you a credit for a future flight (always frequently check the fares for airline tickets after your initial booking) and if you do not pay for a rental car in advance (I advise not to pay for any rental car in advance unless it is a huge bargain) it is often that if you start checking about a week before your rental you will find a price drop. From my experience, Gate 1 Travel and Virgin Cruises have excelled with the concept of pricing correctly early on and then raising the prices rather than lowering them. Many others do much better than RCL/Celebrity. Other cruise lines price things accurately and, therefore, do not have these problems with filling the ship. Carnival, NCL, and MSC, from what I have experienced, are not as guilty, and clearly, Virgin is the champion at not doing this. On Virgin , I booked a cruise months prior to departure, and they gave me a lot of perks and the best price. The price included $700 worth of bar purchases for a seven-day cruise. I think I will be buying drinks for a lot of cruisers! As a result of the Celebrity debacle, I will never book an RCL or Celebrity cruise before 120 days prior to the departure of the cruise. If we all do this, they will be forced to stop screwing people who are loyal to them and book cruises far in advance. Celebrity also tends to tout you with what are really non-bargains to book again while you are on the ship. Other cruise lines try to get you to book another cruise while on the ship but are usually offering a better deal! It is pretty easy to see if a price drop will or is likely to happen. Go on the site of the cruise line or any of the online agencies and try to book it about 125 days out. They will show you the cabins that are available in each class of cabin, so it will take a while to get a good picture of what is happening. If you see many cabins still available, you should probably not make your final payment and cancel your reservation. Usually, there is no penalty for doing this or very little. (Incidentally, when you make the original booking, make sure there is no penalty for canceling within 120 days before the cruise. Sometimes, the cruise line does this to try to lock you into the reservation further.) Also, be more cautious when booking any cruise that is ten days or more because these are the ones that sometimes have booking problems simply because not everyone in the population can afford to take this amount of time off. If you see many cabins left, drop any reservation you may have had and look forward to the price drop. If the price does not drop on the cruise you booked, you can rebook it or just pick from the many other last-minute availabilities that are out there.

Ports of call

Honolulu, Oahu

5 out of 5

CRUISE NORTH PACIFIC

5 out of 5

Hilo, Hawaii

3 out of 5
Our visit to this port was messed up due to the last-minute change in itinerary due to the captain going too close to the shore of Kauai on the cruise that came from Sydney. (See previous note in the review.) Shore excursions on this cruise were insanely overpriced if purchased from the cruise line. Found this to be the case on a previous Celebrity Cruise.

Kailua-Kona, Hawaii

4 out of 5

Vancouver (Canada Place), British Columbia

5 out of 5

Disembarkation

5 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 11

12 Comments

Cruisers4Lyfe     3 months ago

Thanks for sharing

angelo0502     5 months ago

Sorry to hear about your cruise. I booked way in advance and I for one noticed that the excursions I booked early are more expensive now. So glad I booked early. This will be my first cruise on Celebrity and I am very excited! But thank you for sharing.

iankaus     5 months ago

For someone who educates in this area, it is surprising the advice you are giving. While you may have seen a significant cost reduction on this cruise, this situation is rare in the high demand Celebrity/RCI market. We have been on over 20 cruises with Celebrity and rarely do prices come down. We do always book early to get the best price. If you are loyal to a line, you will often get category upgrades, and if you book onboard, you will usually get onboard credit for the new booking. We have a Med cruise booked for Sept (111 days away) and current price is $1800pp more than we paid, so waiting until 120 days in this instance will see you far worse off, and this trend is common, and you may miss out on the cruise all together. You will often find airfares are more expensive booking close to the flight date, so you need to weigh up the overall cost of your vacation. In the rare instance the price comes down, look for higher categories at the price you paid, and Celebrity has in the past moved the booking to that higher category (eg Standard Balcony to Aqua Class). In terms of excursions, there are always third party options to save costs, or keep an eye out for cruise planner sales as they have done this last weekend and you can save over 35% on Celebrity offered excursions. It’s a shame you let the cost of the cruise and missing a scenic cruising ruin your whole vacation.

Gwbigdog     6 months ago

Thanks for sharing your cruise

RedDawn55     6 months ago

Wow, 175% single supplement?? I guess they try to justify that because they've put aside some infinite balcony room for singles but better to set aside the cheaper interior cabins. Best priced solo cabins hands down are on NCL. Also, best travel agency / online website to figure out single supplements is "vacations to go". they have a whole section there for single cruiser supplements.

AndrewPap     6 months ago

One more thing. The usual 100% single supplement is now closer to 175% on Celebrity Cruises. I was wanting to book cruises with them, but not any more.

RedDawn55     6 months ago

I was on the same cruise as you and also enjoyed it. Thank you for the information regarding early payment. I completely agree with you, have seen the same thing with Royal Caribbean and Celebrity regarding prices,and will stop booking before 120 days also.

cruising2004     6 months ago

Thank you for your review.

javawoody     6 months ago

Thanks for sharing

AuntPinkie     6 months ago

Appreciate your very detailed feedback. Celebrity markets itself for adults so it is no surprise that the children’s program isn’t extensive. I know that on Carnival it depends on what “offer” you book your cruise IF you receive compensation if the price goes down after final payment. Not all offers allow that. Sorry you were so disappointed.

karlgrgurich     6 months ago

Interesting. We have always booked early with Princess. Almost always it was the best price. Only once during Covid it came down, significantly, and at final payment we got the better price as well as the drink package thrown in. I was shocked! But gladly took it!

HeavySeas     6 months ago

Thanks for sharing

Other reviews of this sailing