Filter reviews by

104 reviews mentioning "" Clear results

104 Carnival Magic Reviews

Write a Review
5.0

Love this ship by lolabill

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic

Day 1: lost my IPhone before we even left port. A awesome fellow cruiser found my phone and I got it back. Day 2: lost my GoPro while snorkeling at Jacks Shack in Grand Turk. It was amazing how everyone at the beach helped me look for it. Must have been about 20 people. A fellow magic cruiser found it for me. He felt it with his foot. Said it was buried under the sand and we would have never found it by snorkeling. It was a amazing cruise. The Magic is a nice ship. Simon is the best cruise director, he seems to love his job. I’m also thankful I made it home with all my electronics thanks to my fellow cruisers.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 17
10 Comments
4.9

Love the Southern Caribbean by sally199

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Southern

We enjoyed this cruise. The ship was great employees were always cleaning. People were friendly we had a great time. I would advise everyone to take this cruise the ports are beautiful.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 17
4 Comments

Husbands 50th birthday gift by bjonak8

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

We had a great time. Lots to drink and eat. Food was delicious in the prime steakhouse, southern lights dining room, and buffet. Loved the hamburgers from the burger joint.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 18
2 Comments

Wonderful by nyjetz

Sail date: / Traveled as: Singles/Friends
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

Staff was great ship was great service was excellent

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 18
2 Comments
5.0

Amazing Cruise by 3negirl

Sail date: / Traveled as: Singles/Friends
Ship: Carnival Magic

Overall the cruise was amazing. Already booked my next cruise.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 17
4 Comments
4.7

First trip and will not be our last by rschneider82

Sail date: / Traveled as: Family (older children)
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

this was our first cruise and we had a great experience and will be doing the cruising thing every year now.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 17
6 Comments
4.8

Wonderful Winter Caribbean Cruise by Carnivallover1

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

We love cruising with Carnival, The crew are always so freindly and make you feel like one of their family.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 16
3 Comments
5.0

Excellent by tluchuck

Sail date: / Traveled as: Large Group
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

First time cruising and it was more than I expected ❤️ Absolutely loved the entertainment, cleanliness, friendliness on staff saying good morning everyday. I can’t express enough how happy I was with our cabin keeper. Rowan was outstanding!! He set my expectations very high for my next cruise. The waiters in the dining room surprised me. They remembered everyone’s name and what we drank all week. I was definitely impressed! We sat at table 625 and loved everything about it❤️

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 16
11 Comments
4.4

Magic Christmas Cruise 2019 by OchoTaco88

Sail date: / Traveled as: Family (older children)
Ship: Carnival Magic

This was a great cruise, some things we were bothered by but overall we made the best of it. The first day we had no soap in our bathroom and requested the bars of soap. They came molded. Black mold was growing on the inside. Asked for new ones and received clean bars of soap. The smell of sewage was not present in much of the ship as I read on previous reviews.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 16
3 Comments
4.2

It was okay. Better than being at work. by cruisensnoozen

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

Over all, the cruise was still nice, even though it didn't meet our experience on the previous 2 cruises. There were some things that were better, and some that were not, The ship seemed to be at max capacity and the time of year probably had something to do with how choppy the water was and the windy conditions on the 3 sea days. Very disappointing to not be able to enjoy certain areas of the ship because of windy conditions.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 16
4 Comments
3.9

Some good points with some bad points by daveandlinda

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Southern

Magic is overdue for a dry dock. Carpeting was worn in some places. Layout needs overhaul, better signage would go a long way in assisting people to get where they want to go easier and faster. Decor could also use an upgrade. While not directly affecting us, moldy smell and AC seems to be an issue is some areas on some decks.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 16
9 Comments
4.6

Very happy trip! by thepeaches44

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

Carnival Magic is as clean as she can be but there's no doubt a cosmetic overhaul is due. The only things I really did not like about this ship, silly as it sounds, are the round green and white lights. They are everywhere and they look like the bloodshot eyeballs of green-blooded aliens. See if you don't think so too!!! I would hop back on board for another cruise on Magic tomorrow if only I could!

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 14
7 Comments
5.0

Totally awesome Cruise by Patsy7780

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic

Fantastic!! Balcony cabin was great. Food delicious Parties and activities so much fun Shows awesome Islands beautiful. Staff friendly, helpful , knowledgeable Best vacation ever!!!

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 13
7 Comments
4.7

Carnival Magic delivers! by MrBill

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic

The Carnival Magic is a beautiful ship. Everything we needed was right at hand and I would highly recommend this ship to cruise to any destination.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 13
6 Comments
4.8

Excellent Vacation by anairheadhere

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

The cruise was the absolute best. I will say though, the Spa people were the most aggressive that I have encountered. It seemed like every time you turned around, they were there trying to sell something.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 15
4 Comments
5.0

Awesome by wendymaples

Sail date: / Traveled as: Singles/Friends
Ship: Carnival Magic

Had a wonderful time. Relaxed a lot and will be booking another soon I hope

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 12
5 Comments
4.7

Awesome cruise by danaalan64

Sail date: / Traveled as: Singles/Friends
Ship: Carnival Magic

All in all it was a great cruise. I see on here all the time people saying the magic is older and Outdated, This was my 14th cruise with carnival and this was definitely my favorite ship. I’m not sure where all the negativity sometimes comes from. Didn’t notice any bad smells we thought the food was always great. Sometimes people are just hard to please. I think this is an awesome ship And everyone there including Simon the cruise director were great !

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 13
8 Comments
4.1

Whole Family Cruise by idredwingfan328

Sail date: / Traveled as: Family (older children)
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

Wife and I took our 2 college students and our oldest daughter and her family (2 grandsons) on cruise to celebrate our upcoming 25th wedding anniversary (February). Had a great time.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 11
5 Comments
4.8

Great cruise by maedte

Sail date: / Traveled as: Couple
Ship: Carnival Magic / Destination: Caribbean - Eastern

Great cruise. Plenty of different activities. Very clean environment. Met some great people. Already planning next year cruise.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 11
7 Comments
4.9

A wonderful cruise!! by Cathy0525

Sail date: / Traveled as: Family (older children)
Ship: Carnival Magic

The Carnival Magic ship was so beautiful and the staff top notch.

Read full review

Was this review helpful? 11
6 Comments

Find a cruise on Carnival Magic