Very poor experience

Carnival Ecstasy Cruise Review to Caribbean - Bahamas

Cruises: 7+ cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 24

Overall rating:

2 out of 5
Carnival Ecstasy

5 Night Bahamas (Charleston Roundtrip)

Sail date: July 31, 2017

Ship: Carnival Ecstasy

Cabin type: Inside

Traveled as: Family (young children)

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

For starters, I am a seasoned cruiser having logged over 200 nights at sea among a handful of lines...So I know already to temper my expectations on Carnival as they are known to be the budget cruise line, but this was truly the worst end f the budget spectrum. First and most significantly, I was appalled by the lack of basic first aid training of the staff. My young son tripped in his sandals catching his big toe on an exposed steel edge of a step in the main stairwell (more on condition of the ship in a moment). I sat my son against the wall and ran to the Pixels photo booth to summon help and an emergency kit. The young man attending the booth could barely speak english but I told him my son had a large gash on his foot and was bleeding profusely. I asked for a first aid kit and for a medic to be summoned. The man simply said, "infirmary, floor 3". I explained I knew where the doctor was and that would be our next stop but he was bleeding heavily and could not walk down six flights of stairs or wait for an elevator without first controlling the bleeding. Again he repeated, "Infirmary floor three". At that point I just yelled, "Call the doctor now!!!"... He attendant shrugged his shoulders picked up the phone but then put it back on the receiver..saying again.."you need infirmary". In my frustration, I scooped up my son and began to carry him down the 6 flights of stairs. Since our room was only down one flight, I opted instead to carry him back to the room where I had my own first aid kit. I was able to clean the wound, remove the large flap of skin and control the bleeding after about 20 minutes. Fortunately no further medical attention was necessary once the bleeding stopped and the wound was dressed. I get that this wasn't necessarily a heart attack or anything but thank God it wasn't since the staff is so grossly ill-equipped to handle even the most basic of medical needs. Secondly, this ship is a dump. They say the vessel was renovated in 2014 but I saw no evidence of it. Floorings were extremely worn, bare metal was exposed on the stair treads, the pool ladder was broken, the aft elevator bank was out of service, one of the only two coffee machines was broken in the Lido cafe and several hand dryers and urinals were broken in the bathrooms, broken deck railings were being replaced with cheap pine 2 x 6's and the whole ship smelt of urine. I think a fellow passenger summed it up best when I overheard her "they need to sink this ship and turn it into a reef...it has seen better days." As is typical on all Carnival cruises nowadays, food was sub par. Blue Iguana taco/burrito meats were salty and dry, Guy's burgers were burnt, Lido deck buffet was borderline school cafeteria quality and closed at the most inopportune times (including times they published as beIng open!!!). The main dining was only slightly better featuring poor cuts of beef, dry chicken on less expensive seafood (tilapia and shrimp). Room service is now no longer free unless you are looking for a PB&J or Turkey Sandwich. Chicken strips, a salad or even a side of fries will now cost you (even though they are free on the lido deck). The positives were the Seaday Brunch and our nice young cruise director, Gary (surprisingly only three weeks on the job, but very engaging and present). All in all, this was a very poor experience and will likely mark our last Carnival Cruise as we explore other lines for that right balance of budget friendly and quality experience.

Embarkation

3 out of 5
Quick easy port to navigate. Parking fees are steep but secure.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

1 out of 5
As is typical on all Carnival cruises nowadays, food was sub par. Blue Iguana taco/burrito meats were salty and dry, Guy's burgers were burnt, Lido deck buffet was borderline school cafeteria quality and closed at the most inopportune times (including times they published as beIng open!!!). The main dining was only slightly better featuring poor cuts of beef, dry chicken on less expensive seafood (tilapia and shrimp). Room service is now no longer free unless you are looking for a PB&J or Turkey Sandwich. Chicken strips, a salad or even a side of fries will now cost you (even though they are free on the lido deck).

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5
The assistant cruise director (Roger, I think) was chosen to run the game "Sorry" for the kids. He admitted he had never heard of the game and would be of no help in facilitating. Fortunately an older child took charge and ran it for everyone else while the Crew member watched. Oh, and they chose the smoking lounge as the location to perform this children's activity.... no joke.

Entertainment

1 out of 5
Its a cruise ship..not broadway

Children's Programs

1 out of 5
My 11 year old son said activities were not organized well and that toys were broken/missing pieces. He called it Kiddie Prison

Service and Staff

1 out of 5
Overall staff was friendly and worked hard but are grossly untrained and incapable of tending to basic emergencies...see write up below.

Ship Quality

1 out of 5
Filthy worn out shrimp boat

Cabin / Stateroom

3 out of 5

Ports of call

Charleston, South Carolina

3 out of 5

Nassau, Bahamas

3 out of 5
Nice beach within walking distance (Junkanoo)

Freeport, Grand Bahama Island

2 out of 5
Not much to do there, beaches not very nice. Just walked the port market and got back on ship

Disembarkation

3 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 24

13 Comments

geneinkilts    7 years ago

Over 200 nights at sea, but 0 cruises history?

lc42957    7 years ago

usmcwife53    7 years ago

From my understanding this ship was in dry dock earlier this year so not sure why you mentioned it being renovated in 2014 and not 2017.

Castiel    7 years ago

Love how many people are Platinum and Diamond with Carnival yet one cruise pushes them over the edge. Why go so many times if you're treated so poorly?

phoenixraquel    7 years ago

There are so many reviews talking about the smell of this ship. I wonder if something will be done about it. I hope so. 😕

davidnlisa    7 years ago

Sorry buy this a bit dramatic for me to take seriously.

willwork4cruz    7 years ago

So as it turned out the photo booth guy was right? The wound was minor enough you could take care of it yourself. That guy saved you a lot of money, I would have thanked him for his calm headedness and ability to accurately access the situation. As a parent we can get freaked out when our child is hurt but it usually isn't that bad. It probably didn't slow the boy down at all.

GIL155    7 years ago

ok - why 2 stars??? This reads like negative 2-stars.

Hollylop    7 years ago

I would think that I'd be better off just canceling my cruise and booking something at a local campground.... but honestly I see too many positive reviews with people saying wonderful things. I think it's all what you make it. Yes, Carnival Ecstasy is an older shop and I'm sure she has problems. However, it still sounds a dang site better than anything going on in my backyard. Cooperro1 I do hope your son is feeling better and I'm sorry you didn't enjoy your vacation.

texasharts    7 years ago

To bad about your son's injury but then again you must have one hell of a first aid kit to stop a profusely bleeding wound and remove a large flap of skin

enos0357    7 years ago

So are you saying I would be better off going to a camp ground or maybe you would be better off going to a camp ground.

jeffthomas139    7 years ago

I call bs on your post 200 days at sea and your still trying to find a cruise line also seriously brings huge doubt of what u posted above Go lurk somewhere else

Lopaka    7 years ago

Cooperro1: Many subscribers to this app are put off by negative reviews, but mostly by those offering a disparaging viewpoint without facts to back it up. Sorry for the experience you had, but thanks for pointing out a serious lapse in crew readiness to come to the aid of an injured passenger.

Other reviews of this sailing