Not as good as others...

Carnival Ecstasy Cruise Review to Caribbean - Bahamas

Cruises: 2-3 cruises
Review: 1
Helpful Votes: 2

Overall rating:

2 out of 5
Carnival Ecstasy

5 Night Bahamas (Charleston Roundtrip)

Sail date: February 04, 2017

Ship: Carnival Ecstasy

Cabin type: Oceanview

Cabin number: R109 & R181

Traveled as: Family (older children)

Reviewed: 7 years ago

Review summary

My family was a little disappointed with this cruise. We loved our previous cruise in 2015 on the Carnival Fascination (Best experience ever!) , however he Carnival Ecstasy was no where near good. The service was sub par and that is being nice. We had 2 cabins, we wound up with one great steward and one we never saw the whole trip. The service in the dining room was beyond slow which wouldn't be as big of a deal if the food was as good as previous cruises. The food in the dining room was very bland and often served cold. We didn't have any dining room entertainment except on the last night they sang the goodbye song. This was very disappointing since it was the first cruise for our two 13 year old kids. We finally talked them into trying a cruise with us and told them all of the cool things they would see entertainment wise and this ship didn't measure up. Our first two days didn't have any shows only auctions, and gambling. They did have minimal entertainment (scateggories and a paper airplane contest) the days we were in port, but most people are on the island those days. There was some trivia and shows on the Last day at sea. I am not bashing Carnival because I will definitely cruise with them again, but not on this ship until they improve the experience. On other ships there are deck parties on the Lido at night and music at minimum during the night, this cruise had one at night for an hour, and one for an hour for St. Jude, other than that no one hardly on the decks and nothing going on elsewhere, left no options but to sit alone somewhere or stay in the room. This ship just came out of dry dock so it has a Guy's burgers and a Mexican place that  took over the Mongolian Wok. Hardly anyone used the new Mexican place, and I personally like the Wok better and hope they live it on some of the other ships. My kids are 13 so they used Circle C to meet other teens on the ship. The girl running it was friendly and the kids liked her. The only issue was that she would kick all of the kids out and close shop if she felt like it, even of it was posted that it was supposed to be open. The kids did have a good time there when it was open so no real complaints there. Nassau was the normal, but we also ported in Half Moon Cay this time, and it was our first time there. The island is pretty but there is not much there at all. They will do a buffet at some point in the day but they ran out of food before everyone got food. This island is owned by Carnival much like CoCo Cay is owned by Royal Caribbean.  Here's the difference, on CoCo Cay, Royal Carribean honors their drink packages from the boat but Carnival does not honor their drink packages on Half Moon Cay. People, including myself were not happy. We spent a lot of money on drink packages and then we get on their private island and they charge almost 3.00 a piece for a soda and they want 12.95 for a drink in a plastic bottle or 9.00 for one of those little clear 8 oz plastic cups. The island was pretty though and worth seeing. We did an excursion in Nassau where we went snorkeling at 2 different reefs which was fantastic. We have a lot of underwater photos of the coral and sea life (we bought an underwater camera on the Ecstacy for 15.00). This boat did have the 24 hour pizza and ice cream but rarely had any food out except during lunch and dinner time. Other cruises have food on the buffet during much of the day and evening. All in all, this ship lacks in service and friendliness of staff. We chose this one because it ports out of Charleston, a mere 2 1/2 drive, but I will drive the 6 hours to Port Canaveral next time to get better service.

Ship experiences

Food and Dining

1 out of 5
Just okay, not available as much as on other cruises, dining rooms were very slow and food was often bland and cold.

Onboard Activities

1 out of 5
Minimal to none except for auctions and gambeling

Entertainment

3 out of 5
Hardly any

Children's Programs

5 out of 5
Teens enjoyed it!

Service and Staff

3 out of 5
Just okay, not friendly like on other cruises and a little scarce. We had 2 cabins, one steward we never saw and one that was excellent..I believe his name was Durma ..he was always in the hallway, always smiling, and greeted all of us by name, even those of us who were not his guests!

Ship Quality

5 out of 5

Cabin / Stateroom

5 out of 5
The cabins were both roomy. Things were all in working order and clean.

Ports of call

Charleston, South Carolina

3 out of 5

Nassau, Bahamas

3 out of 5

Half Moon Cay, Bahamas (Private Island)

3 out of 5
Was this review helpful? 2

12 Comments

JusMe    7 years ago

Thank you for a well done review with examples to back up why you were not happy with things. ‚  Food is a big part of a cruise. ‚  I have also downgraded cruises for bad cold food in the MDR.

 

It's a shame,   I like the old Fantasy class ships.

911swtea    7 years ago

so many complainers!!!just be thankful that you get to get away with your spouse and have fun for a week with no everyday hassle!!!Im so excited because I dont have to cook 3 meals a day for a week what a wonderful vacay!!!lol and I get my hubby all to myself and we get to do whatever it is that we want with no kids in tow and we get to be kids again ourselves (kinda) well that sounds like a blessing from God and a fantastic week to come cold food and all!!!!

reneej    7 years ago

I've been on cruises before where everyone else complained. I've always had a great time! We make our own fun. We are cruising on the Ecstasy for the first time in July. We're just happy being on a ship, in the middle of the ocean, and out of our regular routine. :)

nickdmcintosh    7 years ago

Where going on the same cruise Brummitt20

willwork4cruz    7 years ago

I am sure all of your complaints are valid but just remember the sophomore slump. It is hard to recreate the magic of a first cruise even if everything was jus as perfect. When the experience is not as good it feels like a real disappointment when it actually wasn't that bad.

donofglade    7 years ago

I really hope they look into the complaints too. This is our first cruise in April and I want it to be the first of many....

TWM    7 years ago

Just got off Jan 10th before dry dock! It's an older ship but they're getting some good updates! Guy's burgers was one! We found the crew excellent! Friendly and very helpful!! You will enjoy your cruise just remember she was built in the 90's so she's smaller ! Benjamin is a great director! Have a blast !! Safe travels friends!

mmrowles1    7 years ago

Remember that you are on a cruise. You could be working. If you go into it with an open mind you'll have a blast.

cruz910    7 years ago

Your review is extremely helpful and will also be our first cruise experience. I just wish I would of known of this app before I booked. Live and you learn.

rissaj14    7 years ago

Thanks for your review! I cruise on the 23rd of this month. I hope my experience is completely different.

Brummitt20    7 years ago

I really am praying and hoping that Carnival looks at these reviews. we are going on our first cruise in June on The Ecstasy.

aprilnu2003    7 years ago

We cruised on the Ecstasy last summer. Our service was subpar as well. Dining service was extremely slow. One night, we walked out of MDR because of poor service. Our daughters (age 9 & 14) thought the cruise was boring & did not enjoy it. We've decided to stick to Royal Carribean for future cruises.

Other reviews of this sailing