July 2015 - Carnival Liberty to Caribbean - Southern
i give a 2 star because i did not expect to have smoking in the late night club area , especially when there is only on board. It was extremely hard for me , someone who is allergic to smoke to deal with. The bathroom in certain areas of the ship had a foul odor , not pleasant. i would recommend to have a separate smoking area ( room ) for people who attends the clubs on board. The staff was not as friendly on board a the other cruises i have been on, its kind of dissapointing.