Liberty of the Sea is a very beautiful ship. The Royal Promenade was a wonderful way to met people and gather. Main room food was very good and well presented. Disappointed that with My Time dining because you are lock-in to only one dining room. The buffet was unorganized and confusing when looking for certain food. Unfortunately there was limited choices after 9 pm. The Windjammer was closed at 9 pm. I felt that the overall food and choices were better on Norwegian. After several days you can see that the ship should be going to dry dock in January, Carpet was dirty, elevator buttons damaged and wore seats in the theater. Lastly, they charged $1.50 for a bingo marker after charging $30 for 12 cards. Nickel and diming at its best!