Torn between these cruises! HELP?!

Curious if any of you have been on these cruises or can comment (good or bad) on ships or ports? Trying to organize a group cruise w several families and we are torn. Want a fun, lively time for adults and teenagers but at decent price too.

from New Orleans (600miles) on carnival dream for 7 days to roatan-Belize-Cozumel
Prices are:
4 to room 3133 so 783 per person

8 nights from port canavaral (700 miles) on carnival magic to grand Turk- San Juan- st Kitts-st Martin
4 people 3600 so 900 per person

from mobile for 5 days on carnival fantasy to Costa maya and Cozumel
Pricing is:
4 to room 2023 505 per person

from New Orleans on carnival triumph to Cozumel and yucatan
4 to room 2224. 556 per person

5 Answers

Check out the ships under the explore tab...I have been to the ports of call but never on any Carnival ships.....We have a lot of Carnival cruisers in the family here and I'm sure that they will have plenty of information for you as soon and they see your plea.

Before I can answer I'd want to know the age groups and home location.

If $ is an issue not only do you need the cruise cost but also the cost of air lines, hotels and transportation.

If flying into a port, you may want a couple days to see the port since already there. In Port Canaveral Kennedy Space center is worth a day to see it. If No Lo, I'd want to see Bourbon street and must have a good dinner out.

If younger kids going with you then you may want one of the larger ships with more activities for the kids to do.

Adults are 40-41 and kids are mostly 15-16. We love a good time 😊🙌🏼 And we would drive to both locations.

If you are driving then I would also factor in price of parking. Parking can get up there. I've been to a few of the ports, but never on Carnival. San Juan its been YEARS since I've been there and we did a horseback trip through the rainforest. Cozumel we just putzed around and shopped (which was fine by me!). Belize we had an excursion that I did not care much for. It was a "nature reserve" but had a pool to lay by, rental canoes to pay for an a bar for drinks.

My personal preference is nothing shorter than 7 days, but I also take into consideration all the other things in price (flight, drink package, hotel, cabs/transportation etc etc). If I have better deals on flights and hotels, I don't mind paying a little more on a different cruise or week.

Personally, I would do the Port Canaveral 8 night. At $112.50 pp/pn as opposed to the New Orleans 7 night at $111.00 pp/pn, I think it comes down to personal preferences.

having been to both sets of ports, I find that they are all good, but the Eastern itinerary wins in my mind. Also, I do not know anything about the Dream, but the Magic is a great ship.

I do not think I would consider the 5 day cruises, but that is only my opinion.


* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top