Rumours around Carnival and FB ( I'm not on FB, someone who is posted it on Funville ) are that Carnival will soon make gratuities mandatory.  No option to remove them from your account.   Do you agree with this policy, or should the customer still have the right to decide on a gratuity ?

Of course, any line could turn around and call it a service charge.

Would you still be inclined to tip extra ( if you do ) ?