Contributor Level: Cruise Director

Review by AlValentino

Feast at sea

In response to review, capeman says ...

Glad to hear that you can't destroy my lungs with your smoke on a balcony. ‚ Why should anyone have to pay for your habit. ‚ I wish smoking was ban completely on the ships.‚ 

Tags: Norwegian Cruise Line Caribbean - Western Norwegian Getaway

3 Answers

Contributor Level: Captain

Thank you for posting your review. So nice to hear you had a great time.

On the point of smoking (of any kind),‚ you are correct in saying‚ the U.S.‚ cruise industry shifted to non-smoking, with the notable exception of HAL (which may change at some point too). ‚ Customers made their opinion loud and clear... cruise lines took note.

The issue with smoking (on the balcony or anywhere else except a sealed room) is that the smoke‚ affects many other people's enjoyment of that space. ‚ One person's smoke can ruin a hundred people's ability to enjoy any given number of square feet. The issue grows more urgent for‚ people with respiratory and other chronic health conditions who can ill-afford inhaling second-hand smoke and associated particulates.

When we cruised the Med in 2012, there were a lot of balcony smokers. We could not sit on our own balcony because of‚ other people's smoke and the cigarette‚ odor. ‚ We could not open our cabin door at night to enjoy a nice sea breeze because‚ the smell of smoke obliterated the fresh air and filled our cabin. ‚ 

While we respect a person's right of self-determination, exercising said right‚ cannot come at the expense of anyone else's right to health or comfort. While there is a chance that cruise lines could come up with another solution for smokers, I'm not sure they would spend the money unless there was‚ an overwhelming outcry‚ to take action... and even then, I'm not so sure anything would happen considering the known associated public health and safety risks.

Contributor Level: Captain

Happy anniversary Al, glad you had a great cruise! Thanks for the review!

Contributor Level: Admiral

HAL is changing it's policy.  On future cruises you cannot smoke on your balcony.  I think that smoking on balconies is a real fire hazard.  I think that MSC maybe the only cruise line still allowing smoking on balconies.


* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top