Contributor Level: Admiral

Mandatory Safety Briefing

In the aftermat of the Costa Concordia Disaster, should Cruiselines reinstate the practice of passengers actually doning their life jackets at the safety briefings? On the Carnival Dream, we assembled in a conference - type room not a muster station. There weren't even enough chairs & I ended up standing giving my seat to a handicapped person. Many people had to stand. The sound didn't even work on the video. On other recent cruises, we did report to muster stations, on others we went to lounges. On none of my recent cruises on different cruiselines were we told to bring our life vests or wear them to the briefings. I think from now on, I will always keep a small flashlight on my person in the evenings while on a cruise ship.

Tags: General discussion safety-briefings life-jackets

5 Answers

Contributor Level: Purser
Having only been on one cruise (in 2001!), when we did have to go to our muster station, wearing our life jackets, I'm pretty surprised that they don't still do this practice. How many people even get out their life jackets to make sure they fit, or there are the correct number? Do they even know where their muster station is?
I'm hoping that the Costa Concordia tragedy changes the way cruise lines look at these safety briefings. Not everyone has been on a cruise, so how very important those emergency instructions are to those people! In fact, no matter how many cruises you have been on, you still need the reminders, so they are fresh in your mind. The crew does safety drills weekly, I'm pretty sure that we can all do them once for an hour....
Contributor Level: Deck Hand
We have been on 2 cruises so far. The first one was in "08" on Carnival Fascination. On that one we had to wear our life jackets & meet at our muster stations. The second cruise was in "11" on Carnival Liberty. That one we just met at our muster stations. We are leaving on our 3rd cruise on Sat. on the Carnival Dream. I do hope after what happened with the Conquest that they go back to the old life jackets & meet at your muster stations. If not I'm sure I'm not the only one that makes it a point to locate where our muster stations are as soon as can. I might even try to figure out how to launch the life boat, just kidding. Good idea Glomarrone ! I didn't even think about packing a flashlight.
Contributor Level: Second Mate
I've cruzed many times, but I ALWAYS take Muster drill seriously. I'm sure that RCCL will now go back to "conventional" muster drill. No just going to one of the lounges.
Contributor Level: Deck Hand
I agree completely with reporting to the muster station with life vest on for drill. My problem is with people having way to much to drink before muster drill. Not only are they not paying attention, they can be annoying to others that want to listen.
Contributor Level: Second Mate
We just returned yesterday from sailing on the Carnival Destiny...during that muster drill we assembled at the actual muster station/no life vests required...approx 30 minutes before sailing began..and they were VERY clear on instructions and took peoples drinks away from them and set them aside while the announcements were made.At that point there were already many drunk people who had to be told by staff to be quiet.
In November we sailed on the Carnival Valor and we met at the muster station as well.. this time with the life vests. There was clearly much more instructions and muster announcements on this cruise we just completed than the one in November 2011. I am certain the Costa disaster has made them re-vamp the muster drill!


* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top