Another suitcase bites the dust...not sure whether it happened on cruise or by airlines but I've had a wheel collapse into the luggage ...not off but in...does anybody have tried and true luggage that withstands abuse and overweight I need a steamer trunk lol?

18 Answers

Any luggage can be damaged today. We use hard sided over soft, except for carry on. But it gets scratched. I bought a small supply of handles, because they break so easily.

We had a similar thing happen after our last cruise - a wheel was damaged. The piece was fine when we left it outside our room the last night and it was damaged when we collected it after we left the ship. The suitcase was only a year old, but I was not going to file a claim with Carnival because accidents happen, and nothing was damaged. It may have been a faulty wheel when we purchased it. Things just aren't made well sometimes, and break so easily.

We certainly can sympathize with you. For many years our luggage only lasted one or two cruises when we travelled overseas. It was a joke, for us, buy new pretty soft sided luggage for Christmas and throw it away before the next. That is until we bought our first Samsonite 28’’ Spinner type luggage, years ago. Can’t believe it, we have travelled around the globe so many times with them I’ve lost count and the ramp rats haven’t damaged one yet. We have five now. Maybe Samsonite should hire bigger than their 500 lb. guerillas to test them for their adds, LOL. Hey, they still look pretty too.

Our last cruise was the death of our big case. Ours tend to last about a year.

I have not had the problem but I tend to carry my case on and off so it does not get beat also keeps me packing light if I know I have to carry it.

Eddie Murphy had a joke where he compared something to luggage because you had it for life.

That’s not our experience. Between work travel and leisure travel we’re on the road a lot and we’ve yet to find a suitcase that can outlast us…Sad

We get our luggage from Groupon deals. So far, our 31" hardside spinners have held up through three cruises and flights. They are ugly as all get out, but that makes them easy to spot at the airport. Plus, nobody else wants our bags LOL I can't even tell you right off hand what brands they are, but I do know that I paid $79 for one and around $100 each for the other two. When I researched the prices, the same bags in more desirable colors were $300-$600 on the manufacturer website.

I got mine from, and they are fine. Hardtops, three sized (small medium and large) and have held up *Knock on wood* with the exception of the inside strap clip and sewing.... Oh well.

So far my luggage has survived several cruises.

I have some that have lasted 4 cruises and many flights, and others that didn't last a day without three of the four wheels falling off (Flight from Korea - Japan - Houston. We bought the bag in Korea the day before we left. The bag started disintegrating in the Japan airport).

I think the ones we have that have lasted are Samsonite.


* is not a booking agent or travel agency, and does not charge any service fees to users of our site. Our partners (travel agencies and cruise lines) provide prices, which we list for our users' convenience. does not guarantee any specific rates or prices. While prices are updated daily, please check with the booking site for the exact amount. is not responsible for content on external web sites.

Back to Top