EXCELLENT review!!! Well thought out, explained and informative!! We sailed the Grand years ago before they removed the "Skywalker Lounge" and we loved the treatment we received from Princess on that cruise. Maybe a change of scenery may give you some insight on the other lines but (and as a veteran cruiser I'm sure I don't have to really mention this to you) ships of any line can be hit or miss. Sometimes sticking with a positive past relationship with a cruise line is something to consider. Thanks for a great review.