Has anyone been on both and can tell me the favorite?  

 

We have always sailed Carnival but I'm interested in the extra "perks" you get with Norwegian booking like beverages, excursions, etc...

 

I've read different things on Norwegian that i'm not crazy about.  

One being having to pay and make reservations for the entertainment.  

Two.. the small rooms even tho we always do interior.

Three ... Norwegian nickels and dimes you with everything

 

Has anyone cruised Both and can give me some pros and cons??