Cozumel, Mexico - Too touristy for my taste. Mostly shopped since it was the last port and we needed to get some gifts for friends.
Roatan (Isla Roatan), Bay Islands, Honduras - Had a great snorkeling excursion, but the island itself did not seem very friendly for travelers. I'm glad I booked an excursion, otherwise I don't think i would have felt comfortable exploring on my own.
Costa Maya (Mahahual), Mexico - Loved going to see Mayan ruins here.
Belize City, Belize - Pretty cool city. Took an overpriced horse carriage tour, but it was fun. Visited the ZBelize City museum. It was well worth the visit.