Cruise Director

Hometown: Kingston, TN
Joined: 02/08/2014
Helpful Vote

About MrBill

Save your Fork...There's Pie.



Cruiseline: Carnival Cruise Lines

MrBill's Upcoming Cruises

MrBill's Past Cruises

Freedom of the Seas

January 2017 - Freedom of the Seas to Caribbean - Eastern

What a wonderful trip!!

We were so happy to experience the rapid boarding procedures.  RCL really has a handle on this!  


Our Cabin 2340 (video here  ) was a conveniently located cabin very near the dining rooms and the elevators.  Plenty of room for two scooters but I did have an issue without any electrical outlets by the bed for our two  CPAP machines.  ANY handicap room needs electrical bedside.  Our Cabin Attendant supplied us with distilled water and a nice extension cord but it had to lay across the cabin during the night which was a tripping hazard for some people.   Cabin was very neat, clean and tidy all the time.  Excellent attention to our needs since we had to call maintenance twice re: toilet flushing issues.  As of Sunday morning, the toilet still was not flushing correctly.   Unfortunately, the next guests to arrive that day will have the same issue.    


We bought a three night upcharge restaurant package.  I bought the package in August and was charged $70PP.   Late November, I discovered our package had been cancelled with a refund to my credit card.   I called RCL and they apologized for the cancellation but were happy to rebook my choice.   Guess what...they price was raised to $75PP which wasn't a big was the principle.  


First night we chose Sabor for our upcharge dining choice.   The food was very good...but I don't believe it really should be an upcharge restaurant.   Any suggestion of a Mexican/Spanish restaurant was completely void in the interior design and decor.   This looked like they could have taken down the "Sabor" signage and open a French restaurant the next night.  Also, I found Giovanni's restaurant lacking in any kind of Italian decor.   


MDR food was very good....with a few minor objections that don't deserve mentioning. The bakery staff were exceptional with their wonderful selections including breads, rolls and other sweet treats.   All was enjoyable including the MDR breakfast and lunches that were served.  Beverage service was very prompt.    It wasn't until Wednesday that I stumbled across Johnny Rockets which has a $6.95PP service charge.  Frankly, I don't know why there should be an upcharge for a mediocre land based fast food operation.   


Giovanni's and Chops went out of their way to provide an excellent dining  experience.  Maryland Crab Ravioli is not to missed in Giovanni...and our perfectly prepared Filet Mignon at Chops was unbelievably flavorful and tender.  Both restaurants deserve two thumbs up with food quality, service and attention to fine dining details.  


We downloaded the new Mobile Passport app to our phones and that really is wonderful feature....we were walking thru with ease in spite of the 3500+ passengers debarking.  


I will choose RCL again.....since this was a 99% successful trip.  I would highly suggest sailing after the first of the year....lower prices and children are back in school.  



Read Full Review »

Carnival Fascination

January 2015 - Carnival Fascination to Caribbean - Bahamas

Carnival Fascination

January 2015 - Carnival Fascination to Caribbean

Carnival Elation

December 2014 - Carnival Elation to Caribbean - Western

Our Frist from NOLA

Let's start with the good.....embarkation was smooth...nicely controlled.  Our room was on the Riviera deck...clean, tidy and our steward kept things in tip top condition.  Food was very good...lots of choices to please.  I did like the option of up purchasing in the Main Dining Room since there wasn't a Steakhouse aboard.   My upcharge choice was the whole lobster perfectly prepared and in addition I ordered the flank steak at no charge for my surf 'n turf selection of the evening.  I would also recommend the up charge New York Strip...nicely done.  And on the the not so good features.   The Serenity Deck obviously was a retro fit.  There wasn't a bar even close...not good planning.  The Anytime Dining seating was a total debacle.   We have sailed many times with Anytime and never had an issue.   This trip was miserable.  We would approach the Hostess station and would be handed a "pager".   Our average wait time was 30 minutes and up to an hour.   We weren't the only ones complaining...there was a line of guests that really were mad.....and the poor hostess stand knew they would rather be somewhere else than facing the "angry crowd".   The Dining Room sent us complimentary Chocolate Strawberries after we returned to the room....a nice gesture with an apology of the situation.  

But to make EVERYTHING even better....Elena, our Bartender in the Great Gatsby served the perfect Martini every evening...she was such a treat....just the sweetest.    

Although the ship was in need of cosmetic updating, the Carnival Value exceeds....would definitely sail again on the Elation.    I hope Carnival will continue the Shareholder OBC's in the future.  Owning CCL does have perks.  


Read Full Review »

Carnival Legend

May 2014 - Carnival Legend to Caribbean - Western

Carnival Legend

February 2013 - Carnival Legend to Caribbean - Western

Carnival Legend

February 2013 - Carnival Legend to Caribbean - Western

Carnival Fantasy

February 2012 - Carnival Fantasy to Caribbean - Bahamas

Carnival Inspiration

December 2010 - Carnival Inspiration to Caribbean - Western

Carnival Fantasy

May 2010 - Carnival Fantasy to Caribbean - Bahamas

MrBill's Tips

Badges (Learn More)

Points (View Leaderboard)

This Week

Recent Activity

commented on a Freedom of the Seas cruise review. - "We arrived at Port Everglades for our FOS sailing at 1:30PM. We walked directly on the ship with no delays or crowds. Moral of the story....don't s..." read more

voted up a Freedom of the Seas cruise review written by rburns1 -Excellent Mediterranean cruise.

commented on a Freedom of the Seas cruise review. - "Highly recommend. FOS was positive experience from beginning to end. " read more

commented on a Carnival Dream cruise review. - "There is a cup for every saucer and obviously cruising is not your cup of tea, cruiser. Try a "land vacation" next time. " read more

voted up a Carnival Sunshine cruise review written by psethi2 -

commented on a Carnival Sunshine cruise review. - "It is amazing how two people can be on the same ship, same cruise, same sailing dates.  One has the worst time of their life (wondering if they ar..." read more

commented on a Carnival Sunshine cruise review. - "My obstructed view cabin had doors that opened about 4 inches. That was nice for ventilation and the lower cost was the bonus. Ask your PVP for thes..." read more

commented on a Carnival Sunshine cruise review. - "Did I understand that Carnival BROKE your toe?  
" read more

voted up a Carnival Sunshine cruise review written by lindanaw -DIDN'T WANT IT TO END

commented on a Carnival Victory cruise review. - "Afraid of missing a vacation.....too many passengers  GO to the ship sick.  Such a long convoluted story....sorry, but something doesn't ring tr..." read more