Hometown: Kingston, TN
Joined: 02/08/2014
Helpful Votes

About MrBill

Save your Fork...There's Pie.


Cruise Lines: Carnival Cruise Lines


Cruiseline: Carnival Cruise Lines

MrBill's Past Cruises

Carnival Fascination

January 2015 - Carnival Fascination to Caribbean

Carnival Elation

December 2014 - Carnival Elation to Caribbean - Western

Our Frist from NOLA

Let's start with the good.....embarkation was smooth...nicely controlled.  Our room was on the Riviera deck...clean, tidy and our steward kept things in tip top condition.  Food was very good...lots of choices to please.  I did like the option of up purchasing in the Main Dining Room since there wasn't a Steakhouse aboard.   My upcharge choice was the whole lobster perfectly prepared and in addition I ordered the flank steak at no charge for my surf 'n turf selection of the evening.  I would also recommend the up charge New York Strip...nicely done.  And on the the not so good features.   The Serenity Deck obviously was a retro fit.  There wasn't a bar even close...not good planning.  The Anytime Dining seating was a total debacle.   We have sailed many times with Anytime and never had an issue.   This trip was miserable.  We would approach the Hostess station and would be handed a "pager".   Our average wait time was 30 minutes and up to an hour.   We weren't the only ones complaining...there was a line of guests that really were mad.....and the poor hostess stand knew they would rather be somewhere else than facing the "angry crowd".   The Dining Room sent us complimentary Chocolate Strawberries after we returned to the room....a nice gesture with an apology of the situation.  

But to make EVERYTHING even better....Elena, our Bartender in the Great Gatsby served the perfect Martini every evening...she was such a treat....just the sweetest.    

Although the ship was in need of cosmetic updating, the Carnival Value exceeds....would definitely sail again on the Elation.    I hope Carnival will continue the Shareholder OBC's in the future.  Owning CCL does have perks.  


Read Full Review »

Carnival Legend

February 2013 - Carnival Legend to Caribbean - Western

Carnival Fantasy

May 2010 - Carnival Fantasy to Caribbean - Bahamas

Badges (Learn More)

Points (View Leaderboard)

This Week

Recent Activity

commented on the roll call for Jan 7, 2017 cruise on Freedom of the Seas - "Just a heads up to everyone with somethi..."

commented on a Carnival Conquest cruise review. - "You have decided your cruise vacation would be miserable...and YOU WERE RIGHT!    Try an auto trip for next year's vacation.    " read more

commented on a Carnival Dream cruise review. - "If you BELIEVE the cruise line will be bad....we can guarandamntootin' assure you it will be miserable.  Maybe an auto trip would be a better choi..." read more

added Jan 17, 2015 cruise on Carnival Fascination to their profile.

followed a discussion, Please remember before you book a Carnival Cruise it is known as the...., on the cruiseline forum.

replied to the discussion, Please remember before you book a Carnival Cruise it is known as the.... on the cruiseline forum.

uploaded a photo album from their Carnival Elation cruise on 2014-12-08

reviewed their Caribbean - Western cruise on Carnival Elation and gave it 3 stars!

added Dec 8, 2014 cruise on Carnival Elation to their profile.

added May 5, 2010 cruise on Carnival Fantasy to their profile.